"In order to make sure that the creepypasta's do their best at their jobs, Slenderman has one rule. You can't fall in love or be in a relationship... But what happens when Toby Rogers falls for his victim..?"
This is my first fanfic so feel free to...
(Y/N)'s P.O.V It's been 3 weeks since I've seen Toby. He's been calling me from time-to-time but of course, I've been ignoring him. What else could be expect? He was flirting with another girl. As I think about Toby, I am snapped out of my thoughts when my best friend (B/F/N) gently shakes me. "(Y/N)! Hellooooo?" "O-Oh, I'm sorry..!" I say as I laugh nervously to which (B/F/N) raises a brow. "Geez, are you seriously thinking about HIM again? Girl, you're just going to get all sad again." "... Sorry." she sighs, "It's fine. I'm just saying that it you cry and ruin your makeup, it's not my fault." I can't help but to giggle once she says this. Once we're both all dressed, we both smile and grab our purses. (B/F/N) was taking me out for a few drinks tonight, just to help me forget about Toby for a little while. Me and (B/F/N) are going to be out for a few hours and luckily, I'm sleeping over at her place so mom and dad don't get suspicious. When we're ready to go, we both leave the house and hop in the taxi.
Once we get to the bar, me and (B/F/N) exit the taxi after she pays and walk into the building, excitement bubbling inside us. When we walk in, the place is crowded and music is blasting. We both sit at the counter where (B/F/N) orders us a few drinks. "Maybe you can meet a new guy while we're here--" "W-What?!" I can't help but to shout in surprise, looking over at my friend with wide eyes. "Woah, what's with you all of a sudden?" "Meet a new guy while we're here..?!" I laugh nervously "I don't think so. Not today, (B/F/N). I'm still... dating Toby. I'm not going to cheat on him." "Whaaat? How are you two still dating? I mean, you caught him flirting with someone else!! Usually that marks the end of a relationship!" I ignore (B/F/N) and take hold of my drink, taking a sip. "Hey! Are you going to ignore me now?!" she asks, trying to get my attention but soon gives up, sighing and taking a sip of her drink as well. After we've had a few drinks, I start to feel bubbly inside and I giggle, looking over at my friend. "What do you say about having fun?" "Let's go dance!!" she shouts, throwing her hands up in the air. We both head to the dance floor.
----------2:00am----------
I groan, opening my eyes to look at my surroundings. (B/F/N) is laying in a bed next to me, sleeping. I don't know where I am, and I don't know what time it is either. As I sit up in the bed, I hold my head, squeezing my eyes shut. I have a painful headache - probably due to all that drinking. When I hear a door open, my eyes open and look towards it, only to see a familiar figure - my boyfriend, Toby Rogers. Anger boils inside of me and I grit my teeth, "Toby! Where the hell am I?! Did you kidnap me?!" his eyes widen "What the hell are you talking about? Why would I kidnap you..?" "Because you miss me!! And you're angry that I've been ignoring you!" I glare "... I'm not angry, actually. I understand why you would ignore me. Oh, and by the way, we're at Slender mansion." my eyes widen in surprise as I stare at him, "... Why are we.." "You guys blacked out on your way back to your friends place. Luckily for you, I just happened to be walking by to find my next victim. I tried taking you guys back to your place but your parents pulled up in the driveway and you would get in deep shit. Since I didn't know the way to your friends place, I had no choice but to bring you here." it takes me a minute to process this information but when I do, I sigh, looking down. "... Sorry for putting you through all of this." I feel a weight next to me and I look up, only to see Toby sitting next to me, smiling softly. "It's fine. I'm your boyfriend, it's my job to make sure you're safe." when he leans in to kiss me, I slap him across the face. "What makes you think I'll let you kiss me after THAT day?! Do you think I've forgotten?!" Toby freezes. "I'm still pissed about what you've done! Why else would you think I went out drinking for?!" after a minute, he sighs, looking down. "I'm sorry. Will you let me explain?" I stay quiet, allowing him to speak. "... Slenderman was hungry that day so he wanted me to get him some food. Since my victim clearly wouldn't go into the woods with me unless she trusted me, I had to flirt with her. Once she started falling for me, I took her into the woods and killed her. I swear, I did NOT flirt with her because I was interested..!" I stare intently at him for a minute, wondering whether I could believe him or not. Once I've decided to believe him, I feel my eyes grow teary as I hug him, squeezing my eyes shut. "I'm so sorry, Toby! You didn't deserve to be treated like this! It was all just a misunderstanding. I'm so so sorry that I was stubborn and wouldn't listen to you..!" instead of hearing his voice, all I hear is a chuckle while his arms wrap around me. "It's okay, don't worry about it. As long as we're still together, every thing is fine." when I hear this, I can't help but to smile, resting my head on his chest. That's when I realize something: If we're in the mansion, Slender will find out and punish Toby. As if he could read my thoughts, Toby caresses my hair as he speaks "Oh, and about that one rule Slender has. I managed to convince him to let us date under one condition: if this relationship interferes with my work..." he starts, "... Then he has the right to kill us." my eyes widen but then I smirk, leaning in towards his ear. "Then we gotta make sure we don't make any children in the near future." I tease which causes Toby's face to turn a bright red. I giggle.
// BTW this is your outfit for your night out:
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
