Secret // Ticci Toby x Reader

Chpt 13: Time to get along

-----A few days later..-----

(Y/N)'s P.O.V
Mom and dad are out shopping for groceries so I have a few hours to have a couple of people come over.
Deciding to help Toby and Tim get along, I invite them both over to my place - not telling any of them about my plan, of course. It's frustrating just to watch the two constantly argue when they bump into eachother outside.

The first one to arrive is Toby. When he knocks on the door, I rush to open it and smile up at my boyfriend. "Hey!" "Hey. You said that your parents are out for a few hours?" he asks, removing his goggles and mouthgard like he always does when he comes over. "Yeah." "So..." after placing them in the table, Toby traps me between himself and a wall with his hands on both sides of my head. A small smirk forms upon his lips as he looks down at me. "... That means we'll be alone for a little while, huh?" oh, if only Toby knew who else was coming over. "Mmn... Not really." I reply, placing my hands on his chest and softly pushing him away from me. His expression turns to that of confusion. "What do you mean?" just then, the doorbell rings and I open the door, only to see Tim with his hands in his pockets. "Hey. What did you need to talk to me about?"
When the two notice eachother, they both freeze. Taking this chance, I grab Tim by the arm and pull him inside, locking the door behind him. "Today is going to be the day you two learn to get along!" I say with excitement only to have the two men snap their heads towards me in surprise. "What?!"

----------2:00pm----------

It's been two hours since they both arrived. Toby is sitting next to me while Tim is sitting on the armchair in silence.
A few minutes pass and Tim gets up, stretching before looking over at me. "Do you have any cheesecake?" "Yeah, I bought some yesterday. It's in the fridge." Tim walks to the kitchen and Toby gets up as well, following him. While Tim gets the cheesecake, Toby leans on the counter, watching him. "You're going to get fat if you keep eating that stuff." I hear him say and I immediately look at him. "Toby!" "What? I'm just speaking the truth." "I only have one slice a day and I work out, unlike you who eats ten waffles a day and doesn't even bother to work out." Tim says and sighs, cutting himself a slice of cheesecake. "Pfft, I do work out!" "Lies don't earn you anything, Rogers."
Once he places the slice of cheesecake on a plate, Tim puts it back in the fridge and grabs himself a fork. He then takes hold of the plate and starts walking to the kitchen table. However, he falls face first to the ground when Toby trips him, causing the cheesecake to splatter all over the floor. He glares at Toby who is laughing. "I am going to KILL you!" he says, clenching his fists in anger. However, Toby doesn't show any fear, he just smirks. "Hehe, heh, bring it on, Timothy." Tim gets up and tackles Toby to the ground where they both start yelling insults at eachother and fight. A minute passes and I stand up, walking over to the two before yelling "ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME RIGHT NOW?! STOP FIGHTING THIS INSTANT OR ELSE I WILL STOP GIVING YOU CHEESECAKE AND WAFFLES FOR FUCKS SAKE! HOW CHILDISH ARE YOU TWO?!" the two men stop fighting and stand up, looking at me. Tim points to Toby "He started it...!" when he says this, Toby sends him a death glare. "I don't care who started it! Both of you were fighting and that is NOT accepted in this house! Now, Toby. Since you tripped Tim and made him drop his cheesecake, you will be the one cleaning it up. Tim, feel free to grab yourself another slice." once everything is settled, I walk back to the couch, sitting down and sighing softly. "Geez, you guys are lucky I'm not on my period."

Once Tim enters the living room, he is holding two plates with cheesecake on them. "Sorry about that." he says, handing me a plate as I smile softly. "It's fine. I guess I should have expected this to happen, considering how much you and Toby don't like eachother." he chuckles and sits on the armchair, moving his mask a little so that his mouth is visible. We begin to eat the cheesecake.
"Hey, can I try some?" Toby asks from behind me, a smile on his face. "... Did you finish cleaning up the mess?" "Yep!" I take some of the cheesecake onto the fork and hold it out towards Toby. Instead of taking the fork, he just eats the cheesecake off of it while I giggle. Once he take a bite, I take some more cheesecake onto the fork and continue to eat. "Not a huge fan of cheesecake but this tastes okay." he says, taking a seat beside me.
Once we finish eating the cheesecake, Tim stands up and takes the plate from me, heading to the kitchen to wash them. "Oh. Thanks, Tim!" I say and he nods, turning on the sink. He then removes his gloves and puts them in his pockets before rolling up his sleeves and washing the dishes. As he washes the dishes, Toby stares at him for a minute before turning to me and pulling me closer. He then kisses me out of no where. My eyes are wide for a moment, surprised at the sudden kiss until I slowly close my eyes, returning it. I'm not sure how long we've been kissing, but we hear a person clearing their throat from across us. When we pull away, we see Masky sitting in the armchair, awkwardly rubbing the back of neck. I glance at Toby who is smirking before looking back at Tim with a smile. "Thanks for washing the dishes, Tim! I could have done them myself, though!" "You're welcome. I know that you could have done them yourself but I thought that since many women do alot of things by themselves, I might as well help out a little. I doubt that Toby does much around here anyways when he's over, right? Like wash the dishes after he has his waffles?" Toby flinches and blinks a couple times in surprise before bringing a hand to his chest. "I do a few things, actually. I'm not useless, you know? I once washed my own hatchets of blood." "Just once? You were probably told to do that by (Y/N). I highly doubt that she'd want to wash blood off of them anyways." Toby gasps, looking at Tim with disgust. Before anything could get too heated, I interrupt them. "Ooookay!! My parents will probably be back soon so I think that it's about time you guys go. It was nice seeing both of you." nodding, Tim stands up along with Toby and me.
Once they leave, I shut the door and lock it, sighing. "Well, that was a disaster."