𝓤𝓷𝓮𝔁𝓹𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓮𝓭 𝓒𝓸𝓷𝓷𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓲𝓸𝓷 ~ Jeff the Killer X Reader

Missing pt 3

Your POV:

A few weeks have passed and I'm starting to have some suspicions as to what happened to Maddy and maybe Dylan too, he hasn't been at school since the fight. He went missing at the same time as Maddy, the night me and Sarah told Jeff and Toby what happened at school. Me and Sarah sat in our usual spot at school and I pulled out my phone.

Me: Hey Jeff? Can you get Toby and come to my place this afternoon?

Jeff: Yeah sure, what's up?

Me: I'll tell you this after noon.

Jeff: Ok see you then.

"Hey Sarah? Wanna come to my place today?" I asked curiously.

"Yeah sure." Said Sarah as she bit into her cookie.

"Jeff and Toby will be there, I've got a sneaking suspicion I know what happened to... M and D." I whispered to Sarah.

"I was just thinking the same thing." She said quietly.

The bell rang for class and we grabbed our stuff, the last two sessions of the day went on forever.

*Why does it have to be math?! I hate math!* I thought to myself.

"Now remember to do your homework on congruent triangles and get them back to me on Monday." Said the teacher in a boring monotone voice.

The bell rang for the end of the day, me and Sarah bolted out of the school grounds and back to my house. We ran inside and I quickly put some waffles into the toaster.

"I bet Toby will spill what happened if we offer him these." I giggled.

"Oh definitely!" Giggled Sarah.

The waffles popped up perfectly cooked, I covered them and put them in the microwave to keep warm then me and Sarah ran to my room and waited.

"How long do you think they'll be?" Asked Sarah.

"How long will who be?" Asked Jeff.

We opened the door just as Jeff was coming in the window with Toby. Me and Sarah jumped at the sudden voice that came from a room we thought was empty.

"Jeez Jeff, you scared us." I giggled.

"Sorry girls, but what's up?" Asked Jeff as he sat on my bed with Toby.

Me and Sarah stood in front of them and crossed our arms as we exchanged glances at each other.

"We know what you two did." I Said looking at Jeff then Toby.

"And what would that be?" Asked Jeff.

"You two had something to do with the disappearance and possible deaths of Maddy and Dylan didn't you?" Asked Sarah.

Toby and Jeff sat silent on my bed not saying a word.

*Are they mad because we killed them? But why?! They should've wanted them dead just as much as we did.* Thought Jeff.

"Come on Toby~ if you you tell us what you did I've got some nice warm waffles for you." I said raising my eyebrow.

Toby's head perked up with curiosity.

"W-Waffles?" Asked Toby.

"That's right I watched her cook them just before you came in so they're still toasty warm." Said Sarah leaning down and looking into Toby's eyes.

*They've got him, he won't say no to waffles. They're gonna be pissed that we killed them aren't they?* Thought Jeff as he mentally face palmed himself.

Toby looked at Jeff and he just did the 'I don't give a fuck' look. Toby looked back and be and Sarah and just slowly nodded his head.

"W-We did it, we k-killed Mad-Maddy and Dylan." Said Toby as his gaze dropped to the floor.

"Are you mad at us?" Asked Jeff.

"No, we get that your killers and we're not going to try and change that, we just found it curious that they went missing the night we told you about what happened at school." I said as I sat down next to him.

Jeff and Toby looked at each other then back and me and Sarah.

"Well... you'd told us that Maddy had been a bitch to you for a while now and then you said Dylan hit Sarah while trying to hit you and..." Jeff trailed off.

"And w-we got angry..." Said Toby.

Me and Sarah just looked at each other with great big smiles on our faces before we wrapped our arms around Jeff and Toby to make them feel better.

"Don't worry guys, we're not mad at you or anything." I giggled.

"Yeah, we just wanted to make sure it was you and not some random killer that wasn't a Creepypasta." Said Sarah with a smile.

"C-can I have tho-those waffles now?" Asked Toby.

"Oh right, the waffles! Give me two seconds ok?" I said as I got up to leave.

"I'll come t-too, then I c-can put my top-toppings on." Said Toby jumping up and running after me.

Jeff's POV:

"I saw that." Said Sarah.

"Saw what?" I asked.

"You blushing." Said Sarah with a smile.

"What? When?" I asked confused.

"When Y/N hugged you." She said nudging my arm.

"I didn't blush! Plus maybe you should be keeping your eyes on Toby, he was brighter than a bloody strawberry." I said quickly.

"He was?" Mumbled Sarah with a slight blush.

"Oh?" I said raising my eyebrow. "Now look who's blushing."

Sarah glared at me then walked out the room and across to the bathroom. I laughed to myself as Toby came back into the room with a plate full of waffles.

"W-where did Sarah g-go?" He asked.

"Bathroom." I said as I tilted my head towards the door.

Y/N came back into the room and flopped onto her bed.

"I'm so exhausted. God I wish school was over." She said with a yawn.

"Me too." Said Sarah as she walked back into the room.

"Schools so shit! So many rules and teachers are always on your ass about something." Y/N said as she sat up.

"Ooooh~ I have a great idea! Remember what we always used to talk about?" Asked Sarah.

"Hmm... we used to talk about a lot of stuff." Said Y/N looking at Sarah confused.

Sarah suddenly ran up to Y/N jumping onto the bed next to her and whispered something into her ear.