𝓤𝓷𝓮𝔁𝓹𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓮𝓭 𝓒𝓸𝓷𝓷𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓲𝓸𝓷 ~ Jeff the Killer X Reader

Bloodstained pt 2

"... W-Was it Jeff?" I asked with a trembling voice.

"Ooh! No trust? But I thought you loved him... But I guess he is a killer so it's only natural to suspect him... I think it would hurt him to find out he was your first guess." Liu said with a playful voice and fake sad face.

"Your putting thoughts in my head!" I said angrily. "Your making it sound like he's the one who did it! Now just tell me! Did Jeff kill my sister?!"

"Oh... I forgot to tell you... You don't get to know if you get a guess right or wrong till after you've had all your guesses." He smirked.

"Can I at least have a clue after each guess then?!" I pleaded helplessly.

"Aww~ But that makes it so much less fun!" He whined annoyingly. "But I guess, seeing as though you've been a mostly cooperative hostage... You do deserve a little something." He said before sighing. "Fine~ I guess I can give you a clue or two."

I quietly sighed in relief as he pulled up a chair and sat in front of me.

"Hmm... What should your first hint be?" He questioned.

Silence fell over us for a few minutes as he stared expressionlessly at me.

"Oh! I know!" He said as he shot up with a maniac smile.

Jeff's POV:

Sarah, Toby and I all sat in silence on a fallen tree just outside the mansion, it was hell for us all not knowing where Y/N was.

*I think Sarah is taking it the hardest, it was the one time when she was away from her phone when Y/N needed her the most, but it's not her fau-* my thoughts were cut off.

"It's all Sarah's fault! Sarah didn't have her phone when your little toy needed her the most!" Screamed the voice in my head.

"No, no, no, no, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO!" I yelled as Sarah jumped.

"Don't try and deny it! You know deep down Sarah probably never wanted you and what's her name together!" It laughed.

"SHUT UP! THAT'S NOT TRUE!" I yelled again.

"J-Jeff?" Stammered Sarah.

"IT'S NOT SARAH'S FAULT! SHUT THE FUCK UP!" I growled as I gripped at my hair and hoodie.

"Ooh~ Defending your bitches friend huh?" The voice laughed.

"Y/N isn't a bitch! GET OUT OF MY HEAD!" I demanded as I fell to my knees.

Sarah's POV:

I could do nothing but stand there and watch as Jeff yet again fought with the voice in his head, until it clicked.

*I just gotta do what Y/N did... when she did that he calmed down!* I thought as I looked over at Jeff on the ground.

I ran past Toby as he tried to grab my arm but failed, I fell to my knees as I wrapped my arms around Jeff despite how scared I was on the inside.

"Jeff? Can you hear me?" I asked.

Jeff slowly nodded and I sighed with relief.

"Y-You need to g-get back!" He said slowly as his voice seemed full of pain.

"No, I'm not going anywhere, I'm your friend so that means I'm always gonna be here for you." I said as I rubbed his back.

"HA! Your not gonna get rid of me that easily!" Yelled the voice.

Ding!~

"Wait... That was my phone." I said quietly as I got it out of my pocket.

Unknown: Hello

"WHAT THE?!" I squeaked in shock. "It's from an unknown number!"

Toby and Jeff's heads both shot up as Toby ran up behind me.

Me: Who are you?!

Unknown: Tut tut, you should know better that this Sarah, that's not a very nice way of speaking to your friends captor is it?

Me: WHERE IS SHE YOU ASSHOLE?!

Unknown: Language Sarah! That's not a nice name to call me when I'm the one in control of your friends life now is it?

Me: What do you want with her?!

Unknown: Well, mainly to get in touch with someone but we have to finish a little game first.

Me: Game? What game?

Unknown: That's for us to know and for you to find out.

Me: Give us Y/N back!
Me: Don't ignore me! I want my friend back!

We waited but there was no reply.

"It's gonna be ok! See Jeff! We at least know she's ok because whoever has her needs her to get in contact with someone so they need her alive." I reassured him.

Jeff just nodded as he slowly spread out on the ground and put his arm over his face covering his eyes.

"As long as she's ok." He whispered.

Your POV:

"Your first clue is... You know this person extremely well, like the back of your hand." He said with an even more sinister smile.

"I know them extremely well?... But that could be anyone!" I sighed in annoyance.

"Who's the one person you know better than anyone else?" He asked.

I sat in silence for a bit as Liu left the room, my head was spinning as his clues made my question even harder to figure out.

*The person I know better than anyone else? That could be my mum or Sarah... But Sarah had only met Max a few times and mum wasn't home the night it happened... Or at least I don't think she was... Was she?* My mind span and span with thoughts until I started to feel sick and I eventually fell into a state of unconsciousness. *I just want this nightmare to be over! Why is he doing this to me?*

(Special!) Liu's POV:

I watched on the monitor as she stared into space with the most confused expression until all the colour drained from her face and she passed out.

"This girl is odd... She's undeniably cute though, I can definitely see what Jeff sees in her, she's smart and unique and surprisingly has no problem with the fact that Jeff's a killer." I spoke out loud as I watched her motionless body hunched over in the chair. "But really! My clue can't be that hard to work out, I thought I was rather up front about who it was... It's not like I really want to hurt her or anything... I just wanted to see her expression and see what she'd do to save the people she cares about... What do I do if she doesn't guess who did it? Do I have to keep my word and kill her and everyone else? Or do I spare her and her loved ones out of pity?"

I slumped back into my chair and sighed deeply as I watched the seconds tick by on the clock above my monitor.

"I hope she wakes up soon, it'll be fun to see who she'll guess next! Wonder if she'll get it right this time." I smirked to myself.

________________________________

Bum bum buuuuummmmm!~
Oooooh!~ This is getting juicy XD
I wonder what'll happen next? *~*
... Well... I know what's gonna happen next but you don't ^~^'
So that just means you gotta stick around to find out :-P
So until next time!
BAI!~