𝓤𝓷𝓮𝔁𝓹𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓮𝓭 𝓒𝓸𝓷𝓷𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓲𝓸𝓷 ~ Jeff the Killer X Reader

Bloodstained

⚠️WARNING⚠️
THIS STORY CONTAINS A LOT OF ANGER!
If you are sensitive to this sort of thing I advise you either do not read or read at your own risk.

Your POV:

I hung my head to try and cover up my fear and pain but the tears were visible as they fell and made puddles of dark patches on my now dusty denim shorts. "Who?... Who killed my sister?" I asked, my words strained and and felt like sandpaper as they left my mouth.

A low chuckle came yet again from the now identified man. "Now what fun would it be to tell you straight away? No, no, no, let's play a game! You get three guesses, if you guess correctly on any of the three goes, I'll let you and my brother go free after I have a chat to him... but should you choose wrong..."

He hesitated and a chill ran down my spine, I didn't need to look up to know that the once menacingly playful smile had now left his face and had been replaced with a bone chilling frown and shadowed eyes.

"Choose wrong and I'll make you watch as I rip your entire family and anyone you love to pieces, before I slowly disembowel you and leave you to die, a slow and painful death as you watch your friends and family burn!" His words came out like daggers and I could do nothing but panic and nod.

"Good, now that we've agreed on the terms of this game... Let's play, shall we?" He said as he went back to his playful tone.

"D-Do I have a time limit in which to give my three answers?" I asked as I preyed he would say no.

"Hmm... I never really thought about it, no time limit means you could think rationally, but a time limit sounds like fun!" He laughed as he turned and grabbed my face and forced me to look at him. "Your face is pleading for a no... But hearing your rushed answers will be SO much fun! YES! There's a time limit! You have 1 hour per answer, I suggest you make it count!"

And with that, he left through a heavy iron door and I could clearly hear it lock as it closed behind him. I finally took a deep breath and though I knew it would do nothing, I screamed, I screamed my lungs out for the first time since she died, since my sister was murdered. After about five or so minutes I began to feel lightheaded from screaming and crying and decided it was time to get my shit together.

"I have an hour to think of my first answer..." I mumbled to myself. "Obviously I just wanna know straight up..."

I stopped, the thought that ran through my head terrified me, I didn't even want to think it let alone know if it was or not... but I have to know!

*Is it possible?... Did Jeff kill Max?...* I chocked at the thought, it made me sick to think he might've been the one who did it, more tears fell onto my shorts as I prepared myself for when he came back and I got the answer to my first question.

Jeff's POV:

"FOR FUCK SAKE! It's been too long! WHERE THE HELL IS SHE?!" I yelled as I punched a tree near the mansion.

I slipped down and sat at the base of the tree, Sarah had gone to the police with a missing persons report, the voicemail Y/N had left and her phone. She said there wasn't anything else we could do, "it was up to the police now" Like they could do shit!

"Fat, lazy, bastards couldn't arrest a criminal if they walked in already cuffed!" I muttered under my breath.

Suddenly Sally walked out and put her hand on mine.

"Don't worry Jeffy! I'm sure Y/N will be ok, she's a tough girl ya know! I mean, she soon tamed you, didn't she?" She said innocently with a big smile.

I smiled back and ruffled her hair as she giggled playfully. I patted the ground beside me and Sally quickly skipped over and sat with me.

"Look Jeffy! The sky is so clear tonight we can see all the stars!" She said happily as she looked up and smiled.

I looked to the sky and somehow the stars seemed dimmer than normal, they flickered slightly agains the cool bluish-black sky but even so, it was almost as though a veil covered them, making them dull and almost lifeless, like the smallest wind could snuff them out and the sky would turn as black as Slendy's perfect suit.

"What do you think she's thinking right now Sally?" I barely asked as my voice came out no more than a whisper.

"I think she's probably thinking about you Jeffy! She loves you and nothing could change that!" She said softly with a warm smile.

"I hope so... she's everything to me!" I said with a small half smile.

Your POV:

Time skip - 1 hour

"Guess who's back!~" Cooed the Liu as the iron door swung open yet again. "Did ya miss me?"

I lifted my tired, dusty, tear soaked face to look at him and gave him a weak scowl.

"Oooh!~ You look exhausted! Must've been all that screaming and crying you were doing earlier. Oh well, do you have your first answer? Ooooh!~ I cant wait to hear who you think did it! C'mon! Who do you think offed her? Who slaughtered your sister like a pig in a slaughterhouse?!"

"SHUT UP! MY SISTER WAS NOT A PIG! SHE WAS ONE OF THE MOST AMAZING PEOPLE I KNEW! IF YOU DARE SPEAK ABOUT HER LIKE THAT AGAIN I SWEAR YOU'LL REGRET IT!" I screamed as my blood boiled more than it ever has before.

"CALM THE FUCK DOWN YOU LITTLE BITCH OR I CAN GLADLY MAKE YOU JOIN HER!" He boomed as he slapped me across the face. "ANSWER ME OR I'LL REMOVE YOUR FINGERS ONE BY ONE!"

"OK, OK! I'M SORRY!" I pleaded. "I have my first answer..."

"Good, and I think I have an idea on who your thinking of." He said with a maniac smile.

"... W-Was it Jeff?"