𝓤𝓷𝓮𝔁𝓹𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓮𝓭 𝓒𝓸𝓷𝓷𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓲𝓸𝓷 ~ Jeff the Killer X Reader

Silence or Death

Your POV:

I woke the next morning hearing a tapping on my window and instantly jumped up and ran to the window pulling up the blind.

"Hey, let me in will ya?" Asked Sarah.

"Oh, hey Sarah, I thought you were someone else." I said opening the window.

"Someone else? Who else has been climbing through your window?" Asked Sarah curiously.

*Buzz buzz*

I walked over to my phone and it was a text from Jeff.

Jeff: Hey I'm on my way, I'll see you in about 5 minutes.

Me: Hey, ok see you soon, but be careful when you come in Sarah's already here.

Jeff: What? I thought you said you were seeing her this afternoon.

Me: Yeah I know, but she surprised me this morning.

Jeff: Can you get her out of the house while me and Slendy come over?

Me: I can try.

Jeff: Ok.

I put my phone down and walked over to Sarah.

"Can you walk to the shop for me please?" I asked sweetly.

"Why?" Asked Sarah.

"Because... it's that time of the month again and I've run out of sanitary stuff." I said quickly.

"Hmm... fine, good thing I like walking." She said turning to the window.

"Take your time, I've got a tampon left so I'm ok till you get back." I said as she jumped out the window and started walking down the road.

I sighed and texted Jeff that Sarah was out for at least 25 minutes. Suddenly there was a tap on the window and Jeff climbed in standing in front of me.

"I know, I watched her leave." Jeff said walking over to me.

I opened my mouth to talk but I was stopped at the sight of Slenderman appearing behind Jeff.

"H-Hello." I said. "I'm Y/N, it's nice to finally meet you."

"Hello Y/N, nice to meet you too." Said Slenderman in a deep voice.

"What do I need to do to prove that I can be trusted?" I asked trying to sound brave.

"I'm just going to ask you some questions." Said Slenderman sitting on my bed.

"Ok, fire away." I said.

"Have you told anyone about our existence so far?" Asked Slenderman.

"No." I answered.

"Would you at any point turn any of the Pastas into the police?" Asked Slenderman.

"No." I answered.

This continued for a few minutes as he asked me questions, I answered them all truthfully and finally he said he was done, I nervously opened my mouth to speak but before I could say a word Slenderman turned to me and spoke.

"You wish to tell another of our existence?" Asked Slenderman standing up.

I paused for a moment shocked at how he knew what I wanted to ask and nervously nodded my head. "She's a massive fan like me and would never do anything to harm or endanger the Pastas in any way! She's my best friend and I can't keep Jeff from her forever." I said to Slenderman trying to sound less shaky.

"... Very well, but you ask her questions before telling her anything. I'll hide and read her mind and tell you if she's lying." Said Slenderman after thinking it over.

"Ok I will! Thank you for trusting me Slenderman, it means a lot to me." I said with a smile.

Slenderman nodded silently a slipped into my wardrobe, Jeff jumped out the window and sat on my roof waiting for his call back inside.

Sarah walked back to the house and climbed back in through the window not long after and she handed me my stuff.

"Thanks Sarah... can I ask you some questions?" I asked.

"Ahh, sure! What's up?" Asked Sarah.

I started asking her questions. "Do you believe in the Creepypasta characters?"

"Well... kinda I guess, I mean anything is possible but to be honest they're just stories." Said Sarah thinking.

"Let's just say they're not just stories... if you met one of the Creepypastas would you tell anyone?" I asked.

"Ok, if they were real, then no, I wouldn't tell anyone but you." Sarah said with a smile.

*She's good so far.* I heard Slenderman say to me in my mind.

"If a Creepypasta walked in right now, what would you do?" I asked.

"Umm... Fangirl! But obviously they kill people so I'd probably run for the nearest weapon." Said Sarah with a slight giggle.

"I see I've taught you well." I giggled. "Would you at any point try to take and post pictures of the Creepypastas if you met them?"

"No! That's like the biggest rule, no pictures or video evidence that may lead to the discovery of the CPs." Said Sarah.

*She seems to be telling the truth. I'll trust her but don't make any mistakes, I will kill her and you if either of you step out of line.* Said Slenderman in a serious voice.

"Ok... promise not to freak out?" I asked nervously.

"Ahh... ok?" Said Sarah confused.

I walked to my window opened it up and tugged on the leg that hung over the edge then walked over to my wardrobe and opened the door, Slenderman and Jeff were now stood beside me and Sarah had her mouth wide open.

"Sarah? You ok?" I asked.

"T-That's... That's J-Jeff and Slenderman..." Stammered Sarah.

"Yeah, they're real... this was my big secret, Jeff is the one who's been climbing through my window and he was the reason I was happy yesterday." I said nervously as I watched Sarah's unchanging expression.

"Oh. My. GOD! It's so good to meet you!" Said Sarah running over and shaking hands with both Slenderman and Jeff.

I breathed a sigh of relief as Sarah hugged me.

"I have one more surprise for you too." I said to Sarah.

Sarah looked at me with an excited but confused look on her face. "What could be better than finding out the Pastas are real?"

"I think Toby wants to meet you." I smiled.

Sarah's jaw dropped again and she hugged me even tighter than before. "OH MY GOD! Y/N your the BEST!" Said Sarah jumping up and down with joy.

Me and Sarah looked at each other before turning to Slenderman and Jeff.

"Thank you for trusting us and letting us get to know you better!" Said me and Sarah in unison.

Slenderman let out a slight chuckle as he nodded and slipped out the window. Jeff walked over to me and Sarah on the bed.

"Hey, if I go get Toby and bring him back here would you girls like to hang with us for the day?" Asked Jeff widening his smile.

"YES!" Said Sarah squeezing my hand.

Jeff laughed and slipped out the window saying he'd be back soon. Me and Sarah sat on the bed and she just couldn't stop smiling, we sat and talk as we waited for Jeff and Toby to return.