𝓤𝓷𝓮𝔁𝓹𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓮𝓭 𝓒𝓸𝓷𝓷𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓲𝓸𝓷 ~ Jeff the Killer X Reader

Feelings

Jeff's POV:

Y/N ran out of the room grabbing her towel on the way out, I sat on the end of her bed looking at the floor when I felt a hand on my shoulder. I looked at Sarah as she sat down next to me on the bed.

"Tell her." She said softly.

"Tell her what? What are you on about?" I asked confused.

"Don't play dumb with me Jeffrey Woods, you know exactly what I'm talking about." She said frowning at me.

"I honestly have no idea what your on about!" I said sternly.

"Right your a killer, I forgot about that for a second." She said rolling her eyes and getting up.

"What's that supposed to mean?!" I said walking in front of her.

"Nothing, I'm just saying you can't even see whats so obvious." She said looking up at me.

"What is so obvious?" I asked her.

"Think about it for long enough and I'm sure it'll come to you." She sighed.

"What does he need to think about?" Asked Y/N as she walked into the room.

"He just needs to think about what's going on up here and in here." Said Sarah as she pointed at my head and my heart.

"What? Nothing's going on in either of those places!" I said still confused as to what she meant.

"Ok, if you say so." Said Sarah shrugging her shoulders.

Your POV:

I looked at Sarah and Jeff confused as I hung up my towel and sat on my bed.

"Oooh~ I've got a great idea!" Said Sarah excitedly.

"What is it?" I asked curiously.

"Me, you, Jeff and Toby should all play truth or dare!" She said sitting on the bed next to me.

"Really? Truth or dare? Why do you wanna play that all of a sudden?" I asked giving Sarah a confused look.

"I don't know I thought it would be fun." She said shrugging her shoulders with a smile.

"Fine." I sighed. "I'm up for it if your up for it Jeff."

"Sure, why not." He said shoving his hands into his hoodie pocket.

"Awesome! I'll call Toby!" She Smiled as she got up and left the room to talk to Toby.

Everything went quite as Jeff stood staring at the floor, he looked deep in thought so I thought I shouldn't distract him. I sat on my bed still in Jeff's hoodie playing with the drawstrings, Sarah suddenly threw the door open with a big smile on her face.

"Toby will be here soon." She said breaking the silence.

"Ok, where are we doing this?" I asked.

"In here I guess... I mean we're already here soo~" She said sitting on the bed next to me.

"Ok." I said as I fixed my hair.

I looked over at Sarah when I heard a soft giggle, she had a big smile on her face which told me she was up to no good.

*I've got a bad feeling about this.* I thought as her smile quickly dropped when she saw me looking at her.

The was a tap at the window, Sarah shot up and ran over letting Toby in.

"Hey g-guys." Said Toby as he waved at me and Jeff.

"Hey Toby!" I said with a smile.

"Hey." Said Jeff quietly as he continued to look at the floor.

"W-What's up with h-him?" Asked Toby pointing to Jeff.

I shrugged as I walked over to Jeff.

"Hey, you ok?" I asked.

"Yeah." He said not lifting his head.

I frowned for a second before I lowered my head so it was in his field of vision.

"You sure? 'Cause you look pretty deep in thought." I said as he snapped from his thoughts and actually looked at me.

"Sorry... I was just trying to figure something out." He said as he scratched the back of his neck. "Don't worry about it."

"Ahh... ok, if you say so." I said as I grabbed his arm and pulled him over to my bed.

We all sat down in a circle on my bed and looked around at each other.

"Who's going first?" I asked.

"How about Sarah goes since it was her idea?" Suggested Jeff.

"Ok! I'll go." Said Sarah happily. "Y/N, truth or dare?"

"Dare." I said.

"I dare you to~... tie Jeff's hair up into a ponytail!" She squeaked excitedly.

Jeff just rolled his eyes and turned his back to me. I grabbed a hair tie and my brush off my bedside table and carefully brushed Jeff's hair.

*It's surprisingly soft.* I thought to myself as I ran my fingers through his long black hair.

I pulled all his hair back into a ponytail and tied it up. Sarah smiled and Toby tilted his head to the side. He turned to me and smiled awkwardly.

"How does it look?" He asked.

"I like it! I think it suits you." I smiled. "Ok my turn!"

I looked a round before my eyes landed on Toby.

"Truth or dare Toby?" I asked.

"Dare." He said.

"I dare you too... hold Sarah's hand." I giggled.

Sarah just looked at me then at Toby as she put out her hand. Toby slipped his hand into Sarah's as he looked directly at Jeff.

"T-Truth or dare?" He asked.

"Dare." Said Jeff with a smirk.

"I dare y-you to make Y/N sit on your lap like th-that night on the r-roof." Stammered Toby with a smile.

Sarah's gaze shot to me in confusion.

"What? When did this happen?!" She narrowed her eyes at me.

"Ahh... the night before I told you they were real." I said rubbing the back of my neck. "Eek!"

Suddenly I was scooped up and sat on Jeff's lap as he laughed at my reaction. Sarah gave out a slight giggle as Jeff looked up at her.

"Why didn't you tell me?" She asked.

"I was kinda more worried about whether or not you would be aloud to know about their existence in the first place." I said with a slight blush.

"Truth or dare Sarah?" Jeff asked.

"Dare!" She said happily.

"Hmm~ I dare you to... wear Toby's goggles." He said looking at Toby.

"Huh? Ok." Said Sarah as she carefully removed the goggles from Toby's head. "Woah~ everything's so orange." She giggled as she looked at me.

We all laughed for a bit before Sarah looked around as she looked at me again.

"Truth or dare?" She asked.

"Dare." I said.

"I dare you to do 7 minuets in heaven with Jeff." She giggled. "But there's a catch... no phones aloud."

"What? But then we can't see!" I said shocked.

"You don't need to see, plus it'll make it more fun~" She smirked.