𝓤𝓷𝓮𝔁𝓹𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓮𝓭 𝓒𝓸𝓷𝓷𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓲𝓸𝓷 ~ Jeff the Killer X Reader

Introductions

Your POV:

I helped Jeff to the couch to rest as Sarah went to get him a glass of water from the kitchen, he laid down on the couch while a sat next to him. He had one arm over his face and one resting on his stomach, I reached over and gently put my hand on his. Sarah came back in the room with the water and Toby asked her to stay with him while he spoke to me for a minute.

"O-Ok." Said Sarah hesitantly.

Toby led my to the back of the room just close enough that we could still see what was happening.

"Y-Y/N that w-was incredible! The whole time I've kn-known Jeff no ones b-been able to even be in the s-same room as him whe-when he's been like that." Said Toby with a smile.

"Really?" I asked surprised.

"Yeah, he usually j-just throws knives at u-us and try's to kill us. So we all k-kinda just leave him b-be." Said Toby rubbing the back of his neck. "He ho-holds back on us ob-obviously, he doesn't actually want to k-kill any of us... well maybe if one of u-us pisses him off enough." He laughed slightly.

I looked back towards the couch where he was now sitting up taking a drink of water before he saw me looking and gave me a small smile. I walked over and gave Sarah a smile as she walked back over to Toby.

"You ok Jeff?" I asked softly.

"I'm fine... did I scare you?" He asked.

"A little but it's ok, as long your alright." I said as I put my hand on his shoulder.

"I jumped to conclusions... I thought..." He trailed off.

"You thought Sarah was talking about how to make you go away? Or maybe whether or not we should turn you in?" I asked sadly.

He just nodded quietly and looked down into his lap.

"Wait h-how did all this start?" Asked Toby confused.

Me and Sarah exchanged glances before we took a deep breath.

"Sarah whispered to me today as you saw, she had an idea but I wasn't sure how well you would take it or if you'd even consider it at all." I said nervously.

"What?" Asked Toby.

"My idea was that... we could become Creepypastas too." She said with a nervous smile.

Toby's eyes widened and Jeff's head shot up, they looked at each other then at us then back at each other again.

"But wh-what about school? Your f-family? Your dreams?" Asked Toby shocked.

"No, it's completely out of the question! Y/N, Sarah you have great lives here don't give it up to become a killer like us." Said Jeff.

Me and Sarah looked at each other then back at the boys.

"Our lives aren't great, we get picked on at school and have no other friends but each other. Yeah we'll miss our parents a little but anything is better than trying to fit in and be normal." We said in unison.

Jeff shook his head. "No, finish school and live your lives for a while ok?" He said giving us a warm smile.

Suddenly Toby walked over to Jeff and this time it was the boys whispering to each other. Jeff looked concerned and sceptical at first but he soon turned to us and said.

"I think it's about time you met the other Pastas, don't you?" He asked raising an eyebrow.

Sarah jumped onto my back hugging me tightly with excitement.