𝓤𝓷𝓮𝔁𝓹𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓮𝓭 𝓒𝓸𝓷𝓷𝓮𝓬𝓽𝓲𝓸𝓷 ~ Jeff the Killer X Reader

Double Date

About 15 minutes passed since Jeff left to get Toby, me and Sarah sat on my bed waiting for them to get back when there was a tapping on my window. We looked over and I ran over opening the window, Jeff and Toby climbed through the window.

"Hey Toby!" I said. "This is Sarah, the girl I told you about."

Toby looked up nervously and locked eyes with Sarah, his eyes instantly widened behind his orange goggles and a faint blush spread across his face.

"So y-your the girl who... l-likes me?" Asked Toby quietly.

Sarah nodded her head and walked towards Toby, she stopped in front of Toby and held out her hand.

"It's nice to meet you Toby." Said Sarah.

Toby shook Sarah's hand. "H-Hi Sarah."

Sarah had to calm herself down and I could see she just wanted to hug the life out of Toby but she restrained herself.

"Hey so where are we going?" I asked.

"How about to the park? We can get some food, sit on the grass and chat." Suggested Jeff.

"That sounds like a great idea! What do you think Sarah?" I said.

"Sounds good to me, Toby?" Sarah asked.

"Whatever you want to do." Said Toby.

"Hmm... I think it might be best if you leave your weapons here guys." I said. "Not many people will take lightly to seeing a boy with axes and a boy with a knife."

Toby and Jeff exchanged hesitant looks before placing their weapons in my wardrobe for safe keeping. Me, Jeff, Toby and Sarah all walked out of my house since my mum and dad had just left for work, we arrived at the park with a picnic blanket and some money. Me and Sarah got us all some hot chips to share, we sat in the sun laughing and talking until Maddy came over.

"Got yourselves some paid boyfriends did you?" Snorted Maddy.

"They're not our boyfriends and we didn't pay them, they're our friends!" I said angrily.

"What's with them? That one has a mask on and that one is hiding in a hoodie and looks like he doesn't know what a haircut is." Said Maddy pointing her perfectly manicured finger and Jeff and Toby.

"Didn't your mother ever tell you it's rude to point?! And so what if they're wearing a mask or covering they're face? They can do what they want Maddy your not the boss of anyone!" I Said now standing in front of Maddy.

"Get OUT of my face bitch!" Said Maddy pushing me to the ground.

"Ouch! Hey don-" I was cut off by Jeff who was now standing in between me and Maddy.

"You really shouldn't have done that..." Mumbled Jeff from under his hoodie.

"Tch! What are you gonna do about it?!" Snapped Maddy.

Jeff looked straight into her eyes and she started to back away slowly.

"H-How? B-BLINK YOU FREAK!" Yelled Maddy.

Jeff stayed silent but never broke eye contact, Maddy took a step back but her foot slipped on a rock and she fell over, Jeff still never broke eye contact until Maddy ran away terrified.

"Jeff!" I shouted happily.

I ran up to Jeff and swung my arms around his neck hugging him tightly. "Thank you!"

"Ahh... no problem." Said Jeff hugging me back.

I stepped away from Jeff grabbing his hand and pulling him back to the blanket. We sat down and laughed for a bit about what just happened, then we started talking a bit more about what each of us liked and disliked. Soon enough Toby was a little less shy around Sarah, me and Sarah found out we have a ton in common with Jeff and Toby. All was good until the sun started going down and as we were packing up I felt a knife to my throat.

"Your not going to move or make a sound." Said a girls voice.

*What is with everyone today?!* I thought.

Jeff turned to say something when he saw what was going on, he had the angriest look on his face as he stood staring at the person behind me.

"Nina what the fuck do you want?!" Growled Jeff.

"I just want you all to myself Jeffy, you and this human girl are getting too close! She's probably just playing with your feelings Jeffy, she probably doesn't even like you." Said Nina pushing her knife closer to my neck.

"THATS NOT TRUE!" I screamed. "I would never hurt Jeff, I really like him!"

Nina suddenly span me around and threw her arm up ready to stab me but I grabbed her arm digging my fingers into her pressure points making her drop the knife, I head butted her making her fall backwards. I grab Nina by her ponytail and drag her away from her knife, kicking and screaming she clawed at my hand to try and set herself free but I didn't let go.

"You want a fight? Then make it fair! No weapons, just me and you." I said as I threw her forward.

Jeff's POV:

Without hesitating Y/N disarmed Nina and was dragging her away from us a bit. Y/N threw Nina forward challenging her to a fight.

*This girls INSANE! No one challenges Nina to a fight and wins, she's going to get herself killed!* I thought to myself. *I've gotta stop this.*

Suddenly Nina launched herself at Y/N but she dodged and sent Nina flying into the ground. Nina got up and ran at Y/N, Y/N did a fancy kick and sent Nina to the ground again but before she could get up Y/N jumped on top of her using her knees to keep Nina's hands down, Y/N pulled out a switch blade and pushed it against Nina's throat.

"Now leave Jeff alone! I won, therefore you have to stop harassing him! Other than that you put up a good fight." Y/N said.

"Humph! Fine whatever, you won so I guess your better than me. I won't stop loving Jeff, but I won't try and kill you anymore..." Mumbled Nina angrily.

"Good." Y/N said getting off of Nina and helping her up.

Y/N and Nina walked back towards us, Y/N gave Nina's knife back and Nina ran off in a mood.

"Y/N that was amazing!" I said in shock.

"It was nothing." Said Y/N with a blush.

"No, no one beats Nina, that was amazing." I said to Y/N. "And you even got her to leave me alone!"

Y/N giggled and Sarah tackled her to the ground in a bear hug.

"Oh my god Y/N, I almost forgot you took all those martial arts classes." Said Sarah excitedly.

"Yeah, that was when my dad went through his overprotective faze, he still is overprotective but not as much as he used to be." Y/N laughed.

Your POV:

We walked back to my place where Sarah and Toby left after a while, Jeff and I started talking while lying on my bed and after a bit I fell asleep on his shoulder.