SPN Theories

Theory 17

*THIS IS AN ALTERNATE UNIVERSE ONE*

WARNING(S): MENTIONS OF SEXUAL ASSAULT, MENTION OF SEXUAL ASSAULT AGAINST MINORS 

When Dean was born, Mary had given him up when he was a baby, Dean was put into foster care and was put into many dangerous situations. Dean then learned to fight and how to defend himself from trouble, by that he started breaking the law.

At age 16 Dean hated being in the system, he wanted a family, but he never had that. He then found his file, he read about Mary and John. Dean knew he had to find them.

Dean then went to Mary and John's house, when he got there he saw lots of toddler toys, chalk.

Dean approached the door, there he saw Mary open the door, she looked almost terrified when she saw Dean.

Mary: H...how did you find this address?

Dean: I'm Dean Winchester, you gave me up sixteen years ago.

Mary: You shouldn't have come.

Dean: Why did you even give me up? Was I not a good son?

Mary: No, no, you were a good son, it's just...

Dean: Just what? You didn't want me, you got rid of me the second I was born!

All of Mary's neighbours looked out their front doors and windows, watching and listening to Dean and Mary.

Mary: Look why don't we go inside?

Dean followed Mary inside, there he saw John and Sam studying together, laughing together, having a father-son relationship.

Dean: Whose he?

Mary: My son Sam, and his father John.

Dean clenched his fist with rage, he felt replaced, he felt like trash that someone had just thrown out waiting to be picked up. Dean then grabbed his pocket knife and completely destroyed Sam's notebooks and textbooks.

John, Mary and Sam were scared, Dean was still holding onto his pocket knife, he felt his power and his control.

Dean: SIT DOWN ALL OF YOU!

John, Mary and Sam obeyed him, fearing for their lives, he then closed the curtains in the living room, so the neighbours wouldn't see anything.

Sam: Why are you doing this?

Dean: Ask Mom, she gave me up 16 years ago.

Mary: Dean I'm sorry.

Dean: WHY DID YOU GIVE ME UP HUH?!

Dean then grabbed Mary by her hair and put the knife to her throat. John tried to move but Dean pushed the blade against Mary's skin, some blood slowly running down her neck.

Mary: Okay, Okay I'll tell you.

Dean: I'm not moving the knife, but one of you move, you're all dead.

 Sam, John and Mary looked at each other scared, Mary then started to tell her story. Dean sat in front of Mary, holding his knife and a kitchen knife.

Mary never told anyone this, she felt too ashamed by it. Mary was raped when she was walking home from her college classes. She was attacked by 5 boys, she pressed charges against them but her main attacker that got her pregnant threatened to kill her and Dean.

Mary thought that giving Dean up would protect him, but she was wrong, Dean was fostered by Mary's attacker, but Dean killed him when he overheard him on a call.

After Mary finished her story, John looked at her with sympathy. He wanted to hold her and comfort her, then they all hear Dean scoff.

Dean: You know what's funny, the guy you said attacked you with his buddies, one night, they were all talking about you and others that they had attacked.

Mary looked at Dean with wide eyes, as did Sam and John as Dean was talking to them about his first kill.

Dean: I was only 11, but one night I heard a girl scream, I went downstairs to the basement, she was tied up, they didn't attack her. I untied her, then they showed up, pissed off. The girl was scared, she was only 15-16.

Sam: What did you do?

Dean then turned his head to Sam, then a smirk went across this face, he then had this look in his eye almost like a proud moment.

John: What did you do?

Dean: I killed those sons of a bitches. One. By. One.

Mary, John and Sam looked shocked, Dean looked almost proud.

Dean: Turns out they were serial rapists. They fostered girls before, girls about age 7 and up, then hurt them. I saved one girl from them, she then disappeared.

Dean then leaves, Mary and John's house, he walked to the cemetery in town, there he saw the girl he saved, she was smiling, happy and hugging her family, Dean gave a little smile then he frowns.

Dean was sitting looking around, he didn't realize the girl he saved ran up and hugged him.

The girl, her name is Lina, her father is the chief of police, she told him about Dean, Dean looked scared but then heard Lina's father say.

"Thank you for rescuing my angel."

After that Dean, started acting behaviour, he did better in school, he then got many scholarships, he went to many ivy league schools such as Harvard, Yale, StanFord, Columbia. Dean studied law, he then became a police officer, he also had another job... hitman on serial criminals such as murderers, rapists, abusers and more.

Dean was feared by man criminals, he was only their number one target of kill.