Supernatural Imagines for The Soul

Under The Mistletoe

Dedicated to both @HunterDoctorBlogger and @Im_a_superhero because they both had similar prompts but they wanted Cas and Dean, respectively, in the situation. So I decided to mix things up a bit. There are twins (originally I wanted it to be reader and her twin but that got messy) named Ellie and Milla Carson (after our lovely prompt givers and Carson after my last name for the fun of it). Also sorry for the lates ladies, my brothers hog the laptop 24/7.

It was barely a week from Christmas so the Carson twins decided to get the Winchesters and Cas to help them decorate the bunker to look Christmassy.

“DEANNNNNNNNN! Don’t be a spoilsport come on.”

“Ellie, I don’t want the bunker looking like Santa threw up in it.”

“But it won’t!” Ellie’s twin, Milla piped in. Both girls gave Dean the puppy dog eyes. Before he could say anything, Cas appeared behind the girls.

“Yes Dean, listen to Ellie and Milla. Let us all celebrate the birth of my half-brother.” This sets the girls into a fit of giggles and Dean starts laughing too. Cas just cocks his head to the side as he always does when he’s confused.

 “What is so amusing?”  Ellie  shakes her head, still giggling as she hugs Cas.

“Oh just you.” Ellie  has always had the biggest crush on Cas but she was always too shy to tell him. The past weeks of Christmas spirits made her slightly more brave and she has been dropping hints every now and then, but Cas being Cas didn’t understand them. When Cas became even more confused, Milla intervened.

“Never mind that, come on Cas! We need to make this bunker extra Christmassy!” Milla was practically jumping up and down. Her sister and herself were mad about Christmas, or any holiday for that matter. It was the only thing that gave them hope after going into a hunter’s life. She pulled Dean and Cas towards to the tree and instructed them to decorate the tree while Ellie  and her went to wake Sam up.

Boy, was he in for a rude awakening.

“SAMMMY! WAKE UP!” the girls yelled at him as they jumped on him. He stretched his arms and then sat up before pushing the girls off him.

“You two…” he playfully glared at us.

 “Aww come on, Sammy. You love us!” Ellie  taunted. Sam rolled his eyes before scoffing,

“Not as much as Cas and Dean.” The twins immediately went quiet and started blushing. While Ellie  had her secret crush on Cas, Milla had her own secret crush on Dean. The only person they told, other than each other, was Sam.

 Because we all know Sam is the girl-whisperer. 

“Shut up, Sammy. At least we are average size.” Milla retorted poorly. 

“Is that really the best jab you have?” Sam teased. The girls narrowed their eyes at him before leaving the room to let him shower and do his other morning duties. As they walked back, 

“I can believe this is the day, that asshat decides to blackmail us.” Milla says dryly.

“I just hope he doesn’t tell the boys how we feel about them, I’ll kill him if he does.” In her meek voice, Ellie ’s threat sounded anything but threatening. As they entered the living room, Dean and Cas were actually good at following instructions. Most of the decorations were up, Dean was doing the tree while Cas was putting up the mistletoes. Noticing this, Milla turned to her twin and gave her a sly smile. She pulled her sister and shoved her towards Cas.

“Hey Cas, you shouldn’t be under a mistletoe alone. Don’t you know the tradition?” Milla could barely contain her smirk.

“What tradition might this be, Milla?” 

“Um, I got to help Dean, Ellie  will explain to you, won’t you, Mils?”  Ellie  started blushing and stammering as Milla skips off to Dean.

“I know that look on your face, what did you do this time?” Dean asks as he notices Milla’s expression. She just points to her sister and Cas innocently.

“So what is the tradition that Milla speaks of?” Cas asks Ellie  again. Ellie  glances to the other side of the room to see her sister flirting with Dean. If looks could kill, Ellie would be dead by now. Ellie  looks back at Cas and clears her throat.

 “Um you see, when you’re under the mistletoe…it’s an old tradition to kiss the person you’re underneath it with. In this case, it’s me…but you don’t have to kiss me, I’ll just go and put up the other decorations.” She says shyly as she starts to walk off. Cas then holds her and pulls her back under the mistletoe.

“I want to kiss you, Ellie . If that’s okay?” Ellie  wasn’t sure if she heard Cas right. Then it hit her like a ton of bricks. She nodded eagerly; he pulled her close and sealed the deal with a sweet kiss.

“Looks like your plan worked.” Dean pointed to Ellie  and Cas making out. Milla nearly dropped the glass ornament in shock. Wow, Ellie  sure does work fast.

“Hmm I guess so. Wait watch this. HEY! KEEP IT PG!”  Milla yelled at her sister and Cas. The two immediately pull away and turn towards Dean and Milla’s direction. Cas gives them a sheepish look while Ellie  shoots daggers at her sister. And as if on cue, Sam walks in. 

“What do we have here?" 

“Cas’ got a girlfriend.” Dean says, almost as if he’s a proud father. Milla just casts her eyes down because her sister could get some action during Christmas break but she couldn’t even confess how she feels about Dean.

***

By the time all the decorations are up and done proper, the gang decides to sit down for dinner. Because of the twins, Sam and Dean haven’t died from lack of home cooked meals. Ellie ’s the expert on the main courses and Milla did the desserts. Tonight was mutton stew served along with bread and bunch of fancy vegetables the rest couldn’t be bothered to pronounce. As for dessert, it was apple pie, Dean’s favourite.

As Milla ate her meal quietly while the rest made small talk, Sam and Ellie  noticed and leaned over to whisper to each other.

“Do you think it’s a case of lack of Dean?” Sam asked worriedly. Ellie  smiled at his joke and nodded.

“You betcha, she’s been like that since Cas and I got together. We really need to get her and Dean under a mistletoe like she did for me and Cas.”

“I’ll take care of it after dinner, don’t worry." 

Just as Sam promised, his plan was set into motioned after they had finished dinner and washed their dishes. Sam were to work his magic on his brother as Ellie  worked hers on her sister.

“You know you have to tell him one way or another.” Ellie urges Milla to tell Dean how she feels.

“No thanks. He doesn’t even like me like that.”

 “How do you know that? Have you asked him yourself?”  Ellie and Milla were close to the mistletoe just as Sam and Ellie  had discussed earlier.  

“I just know, okay.”

“Yeah sure.” Ellie  says irritated and then a sly smile creeps onto her face as she pushes her sister under the mistletoe, the same time Sam pushes Dean under it as well.

“You two know what to do.” Sam and Ellie laugh at the same time and walk away to give the two of them space. Ellie  disappears to her room with Cas, to watch Disney films and Sam goes his room.  Dean and Milla turn to each other with sheepishly.

“Um.. you don’t have to do this, Dean…” Milla trailed off. He gives her a look.

“Well what if I want to kiss you?” 

“Then I say go for it.” Milla tells him bravely, and that’s exactly what he does. Heads starts to peek from the room. Ellie could barely contain herself and lets out a whoop and the new couple break away from each other.

Dean and Milla look at the eavesdroppers and laugh. The gang spend the rest of the night watching funny films on Sam’s laptop.