Her Sister's Boyfriend

01

Got the idea for this story from chocolatechipTNS with her Jiley or Jemily book. I'm loving the plot so far, and was inspired to write something similar except a flipped version. You should all check out her account because her stories are amazing!! This is just going to be a short chapter book- nothing too long.

James's POV:

I pull away to break mine and Riley's kiss. It's so horribly wrong but it's amazing at the same time. We had kissed for several seconds, our lips moving in sync without a single break. She seemed out of breath but a smile was on her lips at the same time. I don't know what it is, but something about my lips being attached with hers feels so magical that I feel myself leaning in again and she does the same.

This time, we don't stop as she maneuvers her hands from resting on my arms to the back of my neck, pulling me all the more closer to her. I move my hands which were placed on her hips downwards, over the top of her butt, allowing it to rest there. Our kisses become rougher and harder as I manage to slip my tongue into her mouth when she releases a gentle moan, but it still felt like the best thing in the world, I didn't want to let her go.
We had purely just been choreographing a routine because Miss Kate had put us in pairs to come up with a duet and perform it to everyone. It's not for anything, in particular, just something fun to do and to build up chemistry with one another. I realized that she had mainly paired up the people who seemed to have a strong hate towards each other and that just so happened to be Riley and I in her eyes.

I'm currently dating her sister, Emily, and we have been together for two years. I've always teased Riley for being two years younger than her and she's always teased me back. We've always just meant it as a joke, I'm actually super protective over Riley, just as much as her sister is. Maybe it's because she is younger and so we feel responsible for whatever happens to her. Either way, we must have portrayed it as a dislike for one another to Miss Kate since she wanted us to work on ur chemistry. Well, one thing I know, is that chemistry has led us here. Kissing in the music room.

A couple of moments later, Riley pulls away once again, gasping for air. I tuck her hair behind her ear, wanting more, but she steps back, placing her hand in mine.

"James this is wrong. We shouldn't be doing this," she says, panting. Something tells me Riley's never had that much of an extreme make-out session with someone before.

"Riley, I know it's wrong, but you have to admit that you feel something," I tell her. I look directly into her eyes and that's when I take in how beautiful they were. Hazelnut brown, just like the brown highlights in her blonde hair. I know her hair is naturally brown, but she's dyed it blonde now, with only some parts brunette.

"I did..." she finally says with a sigh, a happy one. I step closer towards her and place one hand on the small of her back whilst the other cupped her cheek, giving her no option but to look at me. Emily was the last person on my mind right now. I never would have thought I would be kissing her little sister, but yet, here I am.

"Then let's do it again," I say softly but in a seductive tone. Her eyes dart around my face before she leans forward once again, smashing her lips to mine and pressing our bodies a whole lot more closely together. I run my hand through her hair as she detangles mine with her other hand. Her hand is smaller than mine but I loved the soft touch of it. I was able to feel it as she pulls me closer, her hands resting on either side of my cheeks. I could feel the cold metal band on her ring finger against my skin, but I didn't mind. I just continued to pay attention to her. "Do you want to go somewhere else?" I mumble against her lips. She nods quickly and I feel a smile grow on my face as I hold her hand in mine and we go into the costume closet which was in the same room we were currently in. She closes the door, knowing that it only opened from the other side, which meant we were probably going to be in here for a while...

As soon as she turns back around, I instantly smash my lips against hers once more. It's surprising how good her lip-work is considering she's only just turned 17. That's another thing that'd be wrong about us, despite me dating Emily, it's also the fact that I'm 18. I'm turning 19 in a month's time. But I don't want to and can't stop kissing her.

As I push her up against the wall, she jumps up and wraps her legs around my torso so that she's straddling me. As our kisses begin to slow down, I break our lips apart and then move down her jawline and place kisses along her neck, down the front of her chest. She let out a short, quiet moan making me smirk but continue. She then tugged at the hem of my t-shirt and I pulled off of her to help her lift it over my head. "There's no way we're allowing you to stay fully-dressed," I smirk. She smiles sheepishly before I pull her tight baby blue top off as well, leaving her in just her shorts and black sports bra. All I could think was how gorgeous she was.

Our lips connected again as we continued where we had got up to, but then the sound of the door opening alarms us. Riley immediately jumps off of me, her cheeks turning a bright crimson red. I place my hand on her back to rub it, not caring who it was that had caught us.

But when I look up, I see Ella, the new exchange student girl from England, stood there with her arms folded and smirking.