Him

Blackmail

Mr Caid hadn't stopped looking at me as he taught. I was worried the other students would pick up on his obvious behavior. Andy made a point of moving his table closer to mine and rested his hand my thigh under the table. Every now and then people would look back at us making me feel very uncomfortable.

"You okay?" Andy whispered.

"No, everyone keeps staring at us." I whispered back.

"That's the whole idea." he said as he gently squeezed my thigh.

I couldn't help how my body was reacting to Andy's touch. My skin was on fire where his hand rested and I could feel I was wet between my legs. The bell rang and I sighed in relief.

"Miss White, please remain behind after class." he announced.

I felt Andy squeeze my thigh before he let go.

The class emptied quickly and Andy went to stand by the door before stepping out. I made my way over to Mr Caid's desk. He stood up, taking his glasses off and looked at me, his expression unreadable.

"Care to explain why you stood me up last night and sent Biersack? I thought we agreed to keep this a secret?" he said and he leaned forward onto the table.

"I didn't tell Andy, he figured it out because of how blaringly obvious you were." I replied.

"I don't appreciate your tone Scarlet." Mr Caid said.

"What? You outed us yourself. Don't accuse me of telling him." I argued.

"What's the story with the two of you anyway? Because I don't believe for a second the two of you are actually together. You and Ronnie broke up the day we fucked, there's no way you'd be bold enough to start dating another guy straight away and especially not someone as popular as Andy with the whole academy's eyes on him. It makes no sense, you seemed okay with us going forward, what changed?" he asked.

"What changed is that I realized that I just went along with what happened the other night. I said we shouldn't, I tried pushing you away and you ignored me." I answered.

"Are you accusing me of raping you? Or is that what you believe because of Biersack's influence?" he asked as he stood up straight again and crossed his arms over his chest.

"Does it matter? Either way it's true. I don't want to continue whatever this is." I state and he narrowed his eyes at me.

"You don't get to back out now. Not after how beautifully you came around my hard dick. I'm not letting you go. If you report me, I'll drag not only you but Biersack down with me as well. You see Scarlet... unlike you, Biersack just scraped his entrance exam into this class. While it would be impossible for me to make you suffer in this class, it's quite easy for me to make him suffer. Considering he has to write two sets of exams to remain in this academy, I could very easily subtract enough points to fail him on both." he said.

"Are you blackmailing me?" I asked and he smiled.

"You can call it whatever you want. But if you want your precious fake boyfriend to remain in this academy, you'll keep your mouth shut and just go along with it. Like I said... I am not going to let you go. Now... You wont utter a word of this to Biersack, and you'll meet me in the library tonight at 8pm. Got it?" he said as he leant forward onto the table again.

I swallowed hard unable to fully process the new position I was in and I nodded.

"Good, don't change out of this outfit. I like you in a skirt with long socks, I think you should dress like this everyday." he said as his eyes trailed down to my thighs.

I backed up and turned on my heel to leave the class, not even saying goodbye.

Once I left the class I was met with an annoyed Andy.

"The fuck was that all about? What did he say?" he asked.

"What did you say to him last night in the library?" I asked, avoiding his question.

We started walking to our next class and he cleared his throat.

"I just told him that I knew what he did and threatened to report him if he touches you again." he said.

"Is that all? Nothing else happened?" I pressed on and he shook his head.

"Now, what did he tell you just now?" he asked me and I had no choice but to lie.

"He apologized. He said he'd leave me alone." I lied, feeling my heartrate climb as he gave me a look that didn't look like he was buying what I was saying.

He narrowed his eyes at me as if he was studying me. He scoffed and grabbed my hand, walking hand in hand until we reached class.

Once our English lesson had ended we made our way over to the cafeteria. He took my flask from me and went to get us food. I walked over to the table by the fireplace again, seeing Evelynn and Candice there. I sat down in front of them and they smiled at me.

"I'm sorry again about this morning, I was being stupid." Evelynn said as she apologized again.

"It's okay Eve. Don't worry about it." I said.

Andy sat down at the table and handed me my flask and a gourmet burger and chips.

"Damn Andy, are you trying to make Scar fat?" Evelynn asked in a joking manner.

"No, I just want to make sure she is eating enough, don't want her to maybe go all hangry on me." he said as he chuckled.

"That's smart, I'm quite famished." I said before I bit into my burger.

Even though it's just pretend, I can't help but admit, Andy would be good for me. First the orange juice and now insisting that I eat. I wont have an issue with my anemia. I wont suffer from feeding the demon regularly if he keeps this up.

We ate in comfortable silence an the bell went. I grabbed my bag and flask and stood up.

"We don't have class today after this right? You want to come to my room again?" Andy asked and Evelynn's jaw dropped.

"Wait a sec, you guys fucked already?" she asked.

"No, I'm tutoring him." I said defensively, looking at Andy mentally asking him what the hell he was thinking saying that, he just smiled.

"Is that what we're calling it now?" Evelynn said as she chuckled.

"No, shut up, we didn't fuck. I'm literally helping him catch up on last year's work." I said and she looked at me and gave a stupid wink.

Great...my friend is an idiot.

"Let's go Andy." I said as I grabbed him by the hand, pulling him from the table.

"You got incredibly defensive back there, is the idea of having sex with me so bad?" he asked in a teasing manner.

I whipped around to stand in front of him, holding tightly onto his hand.

"Andy, if you want a rumor like that to start flying around, there'd better be truth behind it." I said to him, looking him dead in the eye and he raised a brow.

"Oh, so you do want us to have sex rather than to pretend we are?" he asked amused.

"God, you're such a dork." I huffed and turned around, pulling him in the direction of his dorm.