Life on the Murder Scene || Gerard Way Horror Romance

25: Goodbye Beloved Pastor

Gerard's POV: 

Jules had fell asleep on the couch and looked rather peaceful. Her phone was blowing up with text all morning long it was getting fucking annoying. I look at it and see her messages filled with texts from Noelle. 

Noelle: Jules please answer did you see the news last night? You had to! 

Noelle: I know you have to have cared 

Noelle: Please answer me

Noelle: I really hope you're just in shock and not ignoring me 

Noelle: Can we please meet? I need someone to talk to please 

I groan and roll my eyes. Annoying bitch. 

Me: Leave me alone. 

Blocked. 

That should do the job. I can't forget to delete her contact as well. I lay a blanket over her and let her sleep, she was up most of the night so I'll let her get her sleep for as long as I can. For now, I'm gonna go talk and hang with the guys and work on our next plan of action. 

"She still asleep?" Mikey asks. "Yup, Noelle was blowing up her phone about last night." 

Frank whines, "God why can't we just get rid of her now? Get it done and over with!" 

"That time will be here before we know it, Frank. I know you're impatient." I laugh and he smacks the side of my head. "Ow.."

"Alright, let's figure out what's next. I'm thinking...kill the pastor or her parents." I can't help but smile and fidget at the thought. I see the others nod in agreement. Perfect. "Why not do both in one day? Said you wanted to make it painful right?" Mikey chimes in. This is how I know we're related. He just get's it! 

We write out the plan. 

We decide we're going to kidnap the pastor, film a hostage video, and send it to Noelle and her family. Then, we're going to a plan out a home invasion to kill her parents. Wonderful! 

"Gerard? I have a question." Frank decides to bring up the dream from last night. "Do you think they could mean something? She keeps having them, and all you do is brush them off." I get annoyed with his question. "They don't mean shit. Have you heard about the shit she's gone through? Of course she's gonna have crazy nightmares." 

"See, there you are brushing it off." Mikey says. "You know it means something but you won't say what." Frank laughs and gets up from the table off into his messy dark abyss of a room. "We'll start our plan tomorrow, got it?" 

~^~^~^~^

Gerard's POV:

"Gee? I need to ask you something." Walks into my study, voice soft. "What is it sugar?" She sits on my lap. "Did you delete Noelle from my contacts? She texted me on Instagram because it said she was blocked." She shows me her phone and I grab it from her, blocking Noelle on any other social media. "There. So she can't contact you, remember what I said?" She nods. "Good." I place a kiss on her nose. 

It was about time we start plan number 2. Our victim was ready and well prepared thanks to my friends. "Jules! It's time!" I yell from down the stairs. Here she comes, beautiful, dressed wonderfully. "Gorgeous." I whisper in her ear. "Says you."

I lead Jules to the side of our house where the basement door is, "I didn't even know we had a basement.." She says. "We've lived here how long? And you didn't know there was a basement?" I question curiously. "No! But I do now!" 

We head into the basement to see pastor tied to a chair and gagged. The cameras rolling. We go behind the camera slipping on masks. I take a smaller knife and cut his clothes on throwing them to the side. "I'll put you in something better." I whisper in his ear. 

He turns to me with fear, he recognized me. "Shhhh. If you stay quiet this will be a lot easier and quick for both you and me." Jules takes a larger butcher knife and slices his forearms from top to bottom. This man gets awful sweaty, eugh.  

Jules now carves a big cross into his chest, going deep. You can see his body give up and his soul leave once she completes the first line to the cross. We untie his body from the chair laying it on the floor, above the drain. 

His body now dismembered, we place it in a black trash bag. The video recording stops. 

We stuff his body pieces into a box, we plan on putting the VHS tape in the box as well. 

Job completed. 

~^~^~^~^

Noelle's POV: 

I got out of bed early in the morning. It was a Sunday and it felt weird not getting ready for church. We plan on rebuilding it but for now, we're unsure of where to hold service. For now, I just try to read my bible, look up online services, I try my best. 

While I'm sitting at the kitchen table reading the doorbell rings. I wonder who it could be! I open it to see a package just for me. I bring it inside, but it's quite heavy. I open it and see a black blag, it smells weird...On top of that I see a small box that says to open and watch first. 

I grab it and open the VHS tape. Who uses these anymore? I go to the basement to get out our old VHS player and hook it up to the TV. The box didn't say who it was from, so I assume it's from family or a gift from a fellow church member! 

I start to play the VHS, I could see a person in a dark room sitting on a chair. The room starts to lighten up and I see a familiar face. It was pastor... I continued to watch to see where it goes. A door behind him opens and in walks two people. A man and a woman. 

I couldn't see their faces, they had masks on. The man cut pastors clothes off and throws them to the floor. My breathing picks up, I'm scared. I have never seen a man naked like this before and scared to see what is done to him. 

The woman takes a knife to his arms. I gasp in horror. I couldn't look away but know I needed to. But, before I could turn it off my parents walk in. "Noelle what are you watching?!" She stands next to me in horror. The woman then cuts a cross in Pastors chest, he goes limp. "Oh my word. We need to call the police. Where did you get this from?!" Mother asks. 

"It showed up to the porch with my name on it!" I sob out. My mother calls the police and gets them here quickly. They take the VHS tape and the box, I later found out it was pastors body. I spent the entire night, crying, screaming, hyperventilating. 

This was the first time in forever that I was contemplating suicide. So I tried.