It Started At The Record Store (Ponyboy X Reader)

Part 18

I let the warm water from my shower wash away my worries. I step out if the shower and put on high waisted shorts and my cherry red crop top. I blow dry my hair and scramble out into the kitchen where Pony sat. His hair was wet from taking a shower before me, a smile planted on his face.

"Now we have to make my bed and spray perfume or something." I grab his hand and guide him back to my room. It smelt like sweat and sex... My mom can't find out. I spray perfume and open a window, "Help me make my bed?"

"Of course." Ponyboy had a goofy smile on his face, and he helped me make my bed. I crawl on to it to replace some pillows, in their proper spots, and I flinch slightly as Ponyboy flips me on my back and hovers over me, kissing my lips softly.

"Ponyboy, you have to get going before my mom gets home." I whisper, my face rose red.

"Okay." He kisses me again, then getting off the bed and slipping his blue hoodie on. He took my virginity... in the moment I wasn't scared... I just followed my heart. But it was sure uncomfortable for a good while, but I'm thankful Ponyboy took it slow and didn't hump me like a bunny.

I sit up and walk him to the back door, "Goodnight, Pony." I plant a kiss on his cheek, my eyes followed the few hickeys I left on his neck.

"I love you." He whispers into my ear while kissing the temple of my head softly.

"I love you too."

...

"School ends next Friday, so I would like this assignment in by next Wednesday. Have a nice weekend." Mrs. Jackie smiles as I throw my bag on my back and rush to Ponyboy's locker.

Its been four days since I lost my virginity to Ponyboy Curtis the love of my life. He never spoke a word to anyone about it, thank god.

Pony walked down the hallways with his friends, his hickeys almost faded away,"Y/n."

He smiled and trotted over, planting a kiss on my lips then opening his locker, "I was wondering if you wanted to go swimming party I was invited to tonight."

"Sure." I watched him focus on putting his books into his bag. I bit my bottom lip, "What time do you think I'll be home?"

"I don't really know. The party starts at six , and we are all meeting at the river bed on the park trail." Pony glanced over at me and winked, "lets go get your stuff before going to my place."

I follow him outside and all the way to my building, we both skip up stairs into my empty house. I guide Pony into my room and I throw my clothes around trying to find a swimsuit. Ah ha!

I found my sweetheart neckline black top and my high waisted red bottoms with golden buttons on them, "Okay, lets go." Pony sat on my bed watching me, "What are you looking at Mr. Curtis?"

"You Miss. Y/l/n."

"Well," I walked over to him and placed a kiss on the tip of his nose, "Aren't you just adorable. Now, lets go."

We left and went to his house where Darry sat on the counter drinking cold beer, ""Hey."

Darry stared at Pony and I with a half smile, "Hey Pony. What are your plans for tonight?"

"We are going to a party." I didn't expect Pony to tell the truth, I mean Darry wouldn't let him go, right?

"Alright. Don't get drunk because if you do... Dont bother coming home." Darry threatens and Pony nods.

"I won't." Ponyboy rolls his eyes and we walk to his room. I sit on his bed as he digs through his berrow for some swim trunks. I watch him until his finds plain black trunks and begins taking hus pants off. Oh my god. I look away, heat rising to my face. I have seen his penis but... NO! I'm not watching him get changed, its too much for me to bare.

I hear him slip his swim trunks on so thats when I know its safe ti look over at him.

"Are you going to change?" Pony asked and I felt my face flush again.

"Umm... I think I'll change in the bathroom. "I pick up my swimsuit and rush into the bathroom. It smelt like cigarette smoke, and the was a ash tray on the counter. The curtainwas ripped off the shower and left on the floor. I slip my clothes off and put my swim suit on, throwing my t-shirt on over my top.

I silently walk out and stop before taking the corner into Ponyboy's room, "Listen, I know that you and y/n are serious so thats why you should tell her."

"Soda, who told you that y/n and I had sex."

"Darry. Even though you didn't tell him, he knew thats what you and her have been doing because the last condom was taken." Soda took a deep breath, "when are you going to tell her?"

"She knew I wasn't a virgin." Ponyboy sounded irritated.

"Yeah but does she know who took it? Or did you lie just to spare her from being in pain." Soda raised his voice slightly, "This isn't a small thing Pony. This is a bit of a big deal."

"I'll tell her."

I felt betrayed. He lied to me. Why won't he tell me this big secret? I turn around the corner and trott into Pony's room, Soda leaned up against the wall and Pony sat on his bed.

"Oh, hey Soda." I played dumb, like I hadn't been snooping.

"Ready to go?"

"But we still have time before we have to leave. " I raised an eyebrow at Ponyboy.

"Yeah, but I want alone time with you out of the house." Pony stood up and guided me out of the house, "Soda just was being annoying."

"Where are we going?"

"Where the party is gonna be. We will be early but it won't be too early."

We walked across the park to the edge of the forest, down a dirt path that led to a river. A few teenagers were there unloading liquor and other food.

"Hey Ponyboy." A thin blond kid says as he takes out red solo cups, "Is this y/n?"

"Yes it is. Ain't she a beauty." Pony smiled down at me, making me get butterflies.

"Why yes she is." He walks away as more people show up.

I felt nervous being around all of these people. Most of them are probably Ponys friends.... I really don't want to mess up.

"Y/n!" Cherry came jogging over to me with a bright smile of delight. Her elegant body and beautiful hair made me a bit jealous.

"Hi Cherry."

"Come on, lets go swimmin." She grabbed my hand and took me to the shore. I slip my shirt off and throw it to the side. Ponyboy just stared at us while drinking from a red solo cup. Cherry and I jump into the water. It gave me chills, the water was nipping at my skin.

"Oh that's chilly." I say as we both surface, "Good golly."

"It fells great though." Cherry flashed a pearly white smile, "So how are yiu and Pony?"

"Great." I smile, "We have never been better."

I may not be as beautiful as her but I have the better relationship. Haha, stupid bitch. What am I thinking? She is being so kind and I am being like this? God, I get so jealous...

"Cherry, baby, where ya been." Her boyfriend James stood as0t the shore and she rolled her eyes.

"I'm hanging out with my friend." Cherry turned the other cheek while swimming to the other side of the river. I followed her and we both sat on a rock and watched the boys use the rope swing,"I'm really happy you and I are friends y/n. You know, how Pony and I used to be a thing."

No, no, I didn't.

CLIFF HANGER