Love and Knives (Johnny Ghost/Jimmy Casket X Reader)

A Movie With Jimmy

  (POV: You)

  "Hey, _____, it's about time for your and Jimmy's movie. What are you guys watching?" Johnny said as he texted someone on his phone ("Probably Johnny Toast" you thought).
  "I've picked a weird horror movie that has a romantic subplot. I figured he'd like it because there's some murder in it." you answered.
  "I'm going to go out with Johnny at 9. Some party or something. I'll be back before 12." Johnny said.
  "I guess. I don't like you going out late, Jimmy's still a threat, you know," you said, "just not to me. You'll be careful, won't you?"
  "Yeah, I promise. Jimmy's yelling at me to let him take control now, so I guess I'd better." Johnny kissed you before he let Jimmy take over. Jimmy ran into the other room to get his knife.
  "Why do you need that?" you asked.
  "I don't do anything without Knifey!" Jimmy answered as he through his knife up in the air.
  "You named... your knife." you facepalmed.
   "I'm gay for Knifey." he joked as he grabbed you by the arm. You laughed, seriously hoping he actually wasn't about to stab you. He stuck "Knifey" in his sweatshirt pocket.
  "Let me find the movie, you goon." you said as you search through Amazon looking for the movie you bought.
  "Is it "My Lover is a Murderer", by a chance?" Jimmy asked.
  "Huh? Oh, yeah! I figured you'd like it because there's murder in it and I'd like it because it's romantic." you explained.
  "Yeah, I heard. I guess.", Jimmy said, "They probably don't know the first thing about murder."
  "It'd be fun, Jim!" you said as you punched Jimmy's arm.
  "Don't call me Jim..." he mumbled.
  ~Le time skip
  "Don't let that movie give you any ideas, _____, murder isn't that easy. Even when I showed you it, that was only Billy, and he was sleeping. And you don't just randomly make out in the middle of a murder." Jimmy said.
  "So you didn't enjoy any of this evening?" yous said, giving Jimmy a puppy - dog face.
  Jimmy sighed. "I enjoyed being with you. You're the only person I've ever loved. I wouldn't give you up for the world." he smiled a soft, loving smile, not like the ones he shows when he's acting crazy.
  "Hey, have you ever had a kiss?" you asked Jimmy.
  "N - no.", Jimmy rubbed the back of his head, "I'm not sure that's a g - good idea, _____."
  "Come on, Jimmy! One quick kiss?" you begged.
  "Not yet. I - I'm not ready. Please understand, I'll hurt you. Johnny's telling me he needs to get ready to go out with Toast." Jimmy walked away. 
  You were left dumbfounded and a bit upset, but you understood his concern. He knew what was best for your guy's relationship and he knew what he was and wasn't ready for. Best not to push him.