Falling For Who?

Chapter 11: "Baby Daddy"

Hally's POV
"Umm... Yes... It's true..." I lower my head in shame.
Mike looked bamboozled. "Wait... Take a step back... I'm a baby daddy??"

"I'm sorry okay? It was a mistake. I was drunk and... And I-" I began to explain until Caden rudely interrupted me.
"You see, this is the problem... This is the effing problem..."

"For goodness sakes Hally! You open your legs more than you open a frickin book!" Cory belted out. Now that, that just hurt. It hurt the empty space in the left side of my chest. That's right, I'm a heartless human being. He was right about one thing though. I absolutely hate reading. Ew books.

"You cheated on us for this doofus!" Finnick pointed at Mike.

"Don't you love us?" Caden said with pleading eyes.

"I do. I really do. For goodness sake I do. It was a mistake." Tears began to form in my eyes. Be strong Hally. Don't cry. Don't cry.

"You know Hally, you should stop leading us on and playing with our feelings. We're not here in this world just to make you happy. The whole world doesn't revolve around you, you conceited mother of - ughhh. I can't even describe it." Cory said harshly.

"You know, I was blind a few years back to even consider marrying such a selfish person. You never should have married three guys. If you loved me, you would have never chosen them." Caden said. With every word he spoke, he broke a piece of my heart.

"I'm sorry... Please.... Please forgive me..." I began to sob. I couldn't hold the tears back. Finnick picked up the basketball from the driveway and made a clean shot through the hoop.
"I won't ever forgive you for this. You disgust me." He said, his eyes piercing through me.

"Swish swish bish." Cory added then flicked his imaginary long hair and strutted towards the car with the others getting in their cars as well.

Now I was left with Mike. Great.

"So... I'm going to be a father... That's crazy... Oh my God. I'm a baby daddy! I swear, you better abort that baby other wise I'm gonna have a very ugly partner who is shi-"

"Finish that sentence and I'll kick your balls so hard you won't have another chance to become a baby daddy!" I threatened.

"Okay, okay. I may not want kids now, but I do in the future. No offense, but I don't wanna have them with you. You nasty!" Mike said.

"Ugh but I don't abort babies. That's just cruel!" I replied.

"Welllll... That means I have to marry you... Godammit! Like I said before, you're really shi-"

"I swear Mike... I'm gonna castrate you and feed your balls to the goldfish!!" I warned him and took a step forward, trying to size him up. His eyes widened in fear and stepped back.

"Okay. Okay. What do we do now?" Mike asked.

"I don't know. But I have a feeling that Caden, Cory and Finnick want a divorce."

1 week later
We're at the court clerk's office 20 minutes from home. All I have to say is... Things are getting heated. Not the scandalous, 'Fifty Shades of Grey' kind of heated. More like intense and serious kind of heated.

I really want to not get a lawyer involved and just do it ourselves, but it's quite hard to do so since the guys are so stubborn. Even if we were to get a lawyer, wouldn't it be kind of hard to file a case for three guys and a girl getting married. Oh yeah... I forgot to mention one thing, when I first got married to Caden and Cory...

It was kinda illegal... Just a tad... That wasn't the same for Finnick since we got fake identities.

Okay, okay. It was really illegal. We had to pay the officiant an extra $5,000 to get us married. It had a fake marriage contract and everything. We thought our love would last forever, but I guess not. It sounds cliche, I know.