Come Back

21 // Wrong Brother

Jakes POV-
I was laying on the couch which to my surprise all six of us fit on. Chance and Tessa were knocked out. Anthony went up to his room and it was just Logan, Erika and I.
The movie ended when Erika got up and fixed her shorts.

Erika: so... another movie? Or you guys tired? 
Logan: Let's talk. I'm not tired, I just don't wanna watch another movie. 

Erika turns the t.v. off and sits back in between us. She looks at me then back at Logan. Things were a bit awkward. The air was silent and we just sat there. 

Erika: Soooo...... 
Logan: You're pretty 
Erika: Thanks Logs
Jake: Okay.. I think I'm gonna go. 
Erika: I thought you were sleeping over? 
Jake: Yeah.. I was going to, but Hailey keeps texting me and I need to attend to her. 
Erika: Or..... 
Logan: Let him go. He always chooses her. 

I look at Logan with a "what the fuck" face and then look at Erika, who looked hurt. I wanted to be here with her, but I know I can't. 

Erika's POV- 
That hurt a little. Partially because it is true.. But its whatever, I knew that things between Jake and I would never be the same. 

Erika: I can walk you out. 
Jake: Alright 

I walk with Jake outside and close the door behind me. He grabs both my hands and apologizes. 

Jake: I'm sorry Rik. I know we had plans too see each other tonight, but-
Erika: She's more important. Yeah, I got it. 

I looked to my right, fighting tears that were seconds away from dripping down my face. 

Jake: That's not it. Right now I think I'm falling for her. 
Erika; Why her though? I thought.. I thought you loved me. 
Jake: I do- I did. Erika I loved you. So much. Hell, I still do. But we aren't for each other.
Erika: WHY NOT JAKE 
Jake: Because you cheated Erika!
Erika: Bullshit Jake. Hailey cheated on you so much more than I did. That's not why. 
Jake: I gotta go. 

His body turned and he looked as if he was about to cry.  I was hurt. Too hurt to chase after him. I ran inside and went straight to Logan, who was on the couch waiting for me to return. At this point I was sobbing. 
He wrapped his arms around me and I cried in his shirt. We sat there for almost ten minutes, until I finally didn't feel the urge to cry anymore. 
I looked up, and Logan wiped my tears from my eyes. He smiled, which made me smile too. I pulled his up to my room and he slipped in my bed. I took my shorts off and got in too. I snuggled up next to him. 

(SMUT WARNING)

I felt a pair lips connect on mine and soon realized it was Logan.  I felt myself get up and climb over on top of him. He had taken his shirt off and I was amazed by what i felt under me. Hard rock abs.
I felt all over while we were making out. He bit my lip and rubbed up my thigh. I smiled and broke the kiss to pull my shirt over my head.  
We were intensely making out until he flipped us over. Everything he did was similar to Jake, not the same, but similar. 
Finally we were both naked and I grabbed a condom that I had in my dresser, and handed it to him. He smirked and put it on. When he slipped into me, I moan out softly. I bit my lip trying not to make sound,because everyone was asleep. I heard the front door open and I stopped Logan. No one should be here.. 

Erika: Who was that? 
Logan: Probably Anthony.  
Erika: Should we check it out? 
Logan: Nah. 

I giggled and nod my head. I pull Logan down to me and kissed him. He started again, stroking in me. It had been so long since I've done this. I was panting a little as Logan went full speed inside me. Before I could finish Logan pulled out of me and came all over my stomach. 

Erika: i didn't even finish Lo-
Logan: don't worry babe. 

He went down and started eating me out. I grabbed the sheets and screamed out as he went deep inside me with his tongue. "Lo-Logan Oh-Oh my g-god!" I felt my stomach curl up and I came. Logan just cleaned me up and we snuggled in bed, until I fell asleep. 

--Next Morning----
 I woke up next to Logan and he was in only his boxers. I had his shirt on, which fit me kind of big. I sat up and sat thinking for a minute. 
I got up and brushed my teeth. After I did that, I went downstairs to see everyone still crashed. Except there was an extra body on the couch.. I went up to it and saw Jake. Oh shit. I turned around and quickly went to my room. I slipped in my door and closed it behind me. When I got in, I saw Logan awake looking for his shirt. 

Erika: hi
Logan: shit. I was hoping this was a dream. 
Erika: Me too.. I don't think we did the right thing. 
Logan: Promise not to tell anyone, if you wont. 

I smile at him and take his shirt off and throw it to him. I only had panties on, so I covered my boobs. I saw Logan with his jaw practically on the floor. 
I walked in my closet and grabbed an outfit. After, I hop in the shower and wash up. When I got out I got dressed, and went back downstairs. Chance, Jake, and Tony were there. 

Erika: Morning. 
Jake: Hey
Chance: what time did you go to sleep? 

I look around, in search for Logan. I didn't see him anywhere. "Where is T?" i asked, totally disregarding his question. "Logan and her went to shower and change." Anthony answered. I nod my head and see that they are cooking breakfast. 

Erika: How was Hailey? 
Jake: She didn't want to talk, so I just came back here. 
Chance: Bummer dude. You don't need her man. 
Anthony: Yeah.. shes a whore anyway.. 
Jake: Hey man. I like her a lot. 
Erika: You do? 

I ask kind of sarcastically. He rolls his eyes and I giggle a bit. I sat on the stool watching Chance cook eggs, Jake cook the bacon and Tony toasting bread. 

Chance: Hey bro, where did Logan sleep? If you took the couch? 
Jake: I don't know, he wasn't here when I got back.. 
Erika: I told him he could have the guest room. 
Anthony: I didn't hear him come up? 
Erika: Well that's where he was. 

Jake raised his eyebrow at me. I just looked away, trying to avoid contact. 

Jake's POV- 
Last night, I realized that I wanted to be with Erika. For sure. I know I said I didn't want to be with her, but I know now in my heart, that I want her. 
She may be sarcastic and a bit of a bitch but I want her. 
I was going to tell her today, and hopefully she feels the same. I mean she got upset last night because I left her, but hopefully I can change her mind. 


Wow guys, I bet you are all mad right now. But just remember everything always happens for a reason. 
Also, if your'e not following me on insta pls do, @ Jerikababiezx I posted info about my future stories! Keep on voting and DON'T HATE ME LOLO