Burnt [Supernatural] #Wattys2015

That's What You Get

Song for the chapter: That's What You Get by Paramore

~*~*~*~*~*~~*

DEAN POV

I was actually on the verge of tears. I actually loved this girl. She lied to me about her and... That guy. I was really surprised.

While I thought, I opened the door and was met with Sam with a raised eyebrow.

"Not now, Sam." I said gruffly. I really didn't want to talk. I've poured out my emotions enough with kissing the girl I love. But, now I think I've poured enough out of my mouth.

"Dean-"

I grabbed my keys, "I said Not Now, Sam!" I shouted, slamming the motel door. I walked to the Impala, and hopped in. Turning the key in the ignition, I started up Baby, and pulled out as fast as I could. I looked in the rearview mirror, and saw Elizabeth standing in front of her car with tears in her eyes. My heart stopped for a second, and I kept looking at her. When I broke eye contact, so did she.

"Dammit." I grumbled. Now I was for sure alone... Aside from Sam.

I kept driving. The open road was really all I needed. I turned on the casette tape that was in the player. Bohemian Rhapsody by Queen blasted in my ears. I turned it up as loud as my ears could bare, and sang horribly along. For the six minute song, I sang and sped up on the open highway. My fingers tapped, and I started to think.

Elizabeth was kissing the guy she specifically said she'd never be with. And the guy that beat me to helping her with finding Jace. I sighed, knowing Leon was better for her than I was.

My phone rang, and I turned down the music. I answered without looking at the caller ID.

"What?"

"Dean?" It was a female voice.

I sighed, "Elizabeth. What do you want?''

I heard her take a deep breath, "I'd much rather do this in person, but here 'goes." Another deep breath was taken, "I'm sorry. I'm sorry Leon kissed me. I'm sorry if you feel that I lied to you about him. I'm sorry I ever had to ask you for help... I'm sorry if you feel like I'm a bitch. But, Dean... I need help-"

"Ask Leon. He seems to be happy to help." I growled. Her apologies weren't worth it.

"Dean, I'm serious. It's nothing he can help me with. You're more advanced with this hunting stuff. Neither of us are as good. Dean, please. I don't know what else to say... I don't know what else to do to make you help me. I don't know how to make you forgive me." She seemed on the verge of tears.

I will not forgive it, "No, Elizabeth. I'm sorry I told you I loved you. But, what I'm not sorry about? That I can't help you."

It was like I could hear her heart break a little, "Dean, Please-"

"No." I said, and ended the call.

_____________

ELIZABETH POV

He hung up on me. Wonderful.

I broke down a little, but got in my car to drive out of town. I didn't start becuase I saw someone emerge from the motel room next to the one I was in. It was... Sam? I rolled down my window.

He ran over to my car, "Elizabeth, hey. What happened?"

I wiped the tears from my eyes, and began to speak, "Uh... You might just want to ask Dean."

Sam shook his head, "I want your side before I ask Dean's."

I shook my head, "I'm sure my story will be way different from Dean's story."

"I don't care."

I sighed, "Fine. I told Dean Leon and I weren't a thing. Leon kissed me, and Dean saw. I didn't want it to happen, and now Dean thinks I lied to him. He won't listen to me. He said he was sorry about telling me he loved me. Sam..."

Sam licked his lips, and sighed, "He finally told you... Why did Leon kiss you?"

I shrugged, "But, that's beside the point. How do I get Dean to listen to me?"

"Don't leave yet." Sam stood up straight, "Come wait in the motel room. Then we can make him listen"

I did what I was told, and followed Sam into their motel room. I left all my stuff-but my keys- in the car. Now we wait.

________

After two or so hours, Sam and I finally heard the door open. Dean closed the door, and locked it. When he turned around, he saw me standing up. Dean turned to open the door again, but I slipped between him and the door.

"We need to talk." I stated, leaning against the door. He tried to pull open the door, but Ieaned all my weight on it, "Dean, I'm being fair. Please."

Dean rolled his eyes, and turned to Sam, "This was your idea, huh?"

I saved Sam's ass, "No. It was mine. Let's talk."

Dean looked at me, and glared, "I told you about this earlier. We talked already."

Dean and I moved away from the door, and Sam slipped out. Thanks, Sam!

Dean started to pace, and rub his face with his hands. I heard him sigh deeply.

"Dean-"

Dean turned and pointed, "I told you how I felt, and you lied. You lied, and now you're trying to lie again."

I shook my head, and stood directly in front of him, "No! Dean, that's what you don't get. I didn't lie! Leon kissed me. I didn't kiss back. I didn't kiss him. I'm sorry you felt that I lied."

We sat in silence for a few minutes. Dean looked like he was trying to figure out what to say, while I was getting anxious. Finally, Dean looked me in the eyes, "I told you I loved you."

"I know." I sighed, "I was there."

Dean rolled his eyes, "I'm not good at the whole telling you my feelings thing. Okay?"

"Dean, tell me how you feel now. I can't deal with you hating me." I was being truthful. I care for Dean. A lot.

Dean looked away from me, and sighed, "Well, you're going to have to deal with it."

When his last sentence came up, I felt my heart drop, "Dean, please-" I couldn't finish. Dean had turned away, and I felt my eyes well with tears. But, I wasn't going to give up. I grabbed his arm, and made him face me, "What do you want me to do to show you how I feel? That I wasn't lying?"

Dean's eyes softened, and he looked into my eyes. He kept silent, so I did the first thing that came to mind. I pressed my lips to his. It was something I wanted to do. After a few moments, I pulled away. The tears were still leaking down my face. Instead of waiting for him to reply, I turned around, and got ready to leave again. The cool metal of the knob was grasped by my hand, and I pulled the door open. Before completely walking out, I turned back to Dean, and saw he was standing there with his hand touching his lips.

I sighed, and closed the door behind me. I guess this is how it should've ended in the first place.

~*~*~*~*~~*

A/N: Hello, again, Lovelies! How's it been? Thoughts can be left in the comments, and if you loved it, LEAVE A GENEROUS VOTE, AND A COMMENT!

Thanks!

~Mae