Calum:
Matching 'I ♡ my crazy boyfriend/ I ♡ my crazy girlfriend' phone cases and an Ed Sheeran signed CD
Ashton:
A 'Pugs Not Drugs' shirt, matching bandana, and a kiss under the mistletoe
Luke:
A stuffed penguin to go with his and a song he wrote for you
Michael:
An acoustic guitar in your favorite color, two game controllers, and a snapback