"My love for a greaser" Ponyboy Curtis x Reader story

Chapter 11. Between bestfriends with their bestfriends together?

(The title kinda doesn't make sense but I promise it will soon.)
Y/N POV:
"So how was last night?" Vanessa said to me whispering towards me but obviously both boys could hear. "Excuse me one second boys." She said to them as she pulled me away into the empty girls bathroom. "So how'd your date gooooo?" She asked excitedly waiting for an answer. "It was good." I said blandly. "Good? Just GOOD? What was it that it wasn't spectacular or amazing or made your heart almost want to leap from your chest? Do you not like Pony???" She asked worriedly and I had a cheeky smile. "I knew you'd answer like that If I said good. I'm not gonna tell ya the niddy griddy. Hah." I said to her and smiled some more. "Oh come on pleaseeee Y/n I'll tell you a secret if you tell me what happened." She pouted and I sighed. "Fine. But that secret better be life changing." "Okay okay now just get on to telling me what happened!" She said and sat on the sink counter. "Well I put on a cute outfit. He took me out for some milkshakes, we talked, we headed to my place, watched a movie, fell asleep on my couch. That's all." I said. "I believe ya well time for my secret. Ya know that kid Pony is best friends with?" "Yeah." "Well I like him. I like Johnny Cade and we only just met. What a disaster! We have almost every class together, we sit near each other, and he even talks to me. Oh Y/n what do I dooooo???" She said to me and I just stared at her in awe smiling. "Well...I donno... I kissed Pony before I really told him I liked him so my situation was different. Well maybe talk to him more, see what he likes, maybe ask him to hang out. As just friends though....WAIT! Pony and Johnny love going to the movie house and the Nightly Double. Maybe if I tell them we can all hang out there they'd go and so would we. As a group. And you can get closer to Johnny that way." I say to her smiling with my finger pointed up to the sky and my hand raised up as if I was some scientist who found a new investigation. It was quite funny.

(This is gonna he shocking But-)
PONYBOY POV:

As I was in the halls with Johnny waiting for Y/n and her friend Vanessa, Johnny spoke to me. "Hey Pone...how'd ya know that you liked Y/n like what did it feel like to ya?" He asked me taking me out of my thoughts. "Well gee...uh talking to her was harder and I stuttered a lot. My stomach would feel funny and it was weird. I thought of her often. And being 'round her too close or alone was nervwrecking ya know. Why Johnny? You like someone?" "Yeah sorta but I wasn't sure so I wanted to ask ya since you'd know." I nod at him and smile. "So who is it? Is that girl in your math class? The one with the pretty hair? Or-" "No pone it ain't her. It's that girl Y/n is friends with...." he said to me shyly. "Vanessa? That girl? Well she is pretty. Do you think she likes you?" I ask him to know how he feels and if maybe she has something for him. I'll ask Y/n what she likes and stuff. She would know plus she's my girl or something like that and that's her best friend. If that's someone Y/n is fond of and Johnny likes her then I think it's fine. She lives near us too anyways. Finally I see from the halls Y/n and Vanessa. I playfully nudge Johnny to tell him look who it is but he turns around and goes from his normal skin tone to super red. My best friend Johnny Cade one of the most friendliest, nicest, kid I know has a crush. I see Y/n and before I can pull her aside and tell her she grabs me first and puts me to the side.

"Pony I just came out of the bathroom from talking with Vanessa and you won't believe what I found out." "Yeah well I got news too but I can wait go ahead and tell me." I smile at her waiting for her response. "Vanessa...Yeah she likes Johnny. Isn't that crazy? So I have this whole plan to maybe get Johnny to like her so they could be together. I think it would be cute, will it work though?" "Well I don't think we are going to need to do that because I found out while you two were talking that Johnny likes Vanessa. Maybe us four should go out sometime soon and then have them get even closer then. What do you think?" I say that smiling to Y/n. She smiles back at me happy feeling good knowing about the news I told her that helps both our situations. She smiles and nods. "Oh yes that sounds perfect Pony! Ah I knew you could help out greatly." She hugs me tightly and I hold her waist kissing her forehead. This girl makes me so happy. And seeing how we are helping two people come together makes her happy makes me know she's an amazing person. She is so thoughtful and caring. She always puts others before herself which is very nice but I will admit sometimes I wish she were selfish. She should put herself first in line sometimes. She deserves it. That girl deserves everything in the world. I hold her smaller body against mine and kiss her once on the cheek before parting away. We both stare at each other smiling happily until the words of Vanessa and Johnny snap us out of our current state and nod at both of them. The bell rings and we all head to class.