«𝗦𝘁𝗿𝗮𝗻𝗴𝗲𝗿 𝗧𝗵𝗶𝗻𝗴𝘀 𝗣𝗿𝗲𝗳𝗲𝗿𝗲𝗻𝗰𝗲𝘀»

➙Reaction: Spiders.

Mike
Pretends to not be scared even if he is
"Don't worry Y/N, I got this"
Gets closer, just then the spider starts crawling away
"Oh my god, did you see this? It just shortened my life expectancy"
Dramatic

Will
Would treat it like a normal spider, although still flinches when it moves
"AaaAND- Oh my god I'm sorry let's just get this over with"
Gets a glass and a paper and puts the glass over the spider and starts sliding the paper underneath the glass and brings it outside
"Look, I made it!"
He's literally beaming, super proud even if it's just a spider

Dustin
Would probably roll his eyes at you for being scared
"Y/N, this is a spider, probably more scared of you, and yet there you are being scared of it"
Uses the same method as Will, with the glass
"You literally just do this, then that... And you're done! I'll just bring it outside really quick so you can walk around like a normal human again"

Lucas
Nervous
"You really want me to do this-"
In the end you'll be the one getting the spider out, just because he said it would be the better idea
"So, why wouldn't you bring it out, my dear Lucas?"
Quiet
"No reason-"

Eleven
This girl can move things with her mind, so that's what she'll do
"Hey, uh there's a spider right above you"
Stares at it, then starts to use her powers to make it fly outside the window, then turns around to look at you with a serious expression
"There."
You're just there like 🧍

Max
Holds her hand towards the spider for it to crawl upon on, you're just there looking at her like she just broke her arm or idk
"Let me just bring this outside"
Sees you looking at her, confused why you're looking at her like that
"It was a spider, did you think it would kill me?"
You nod

Steve
Similar to Max, holds his hand towards the animal
But then he holds his hand closer to you, after the spider crawled on top of it, and teases you about shrieking
"Seriously? It's just a spider, why would you be scared of it? It's probably more scared of you, do I need to protect you from the big bad spider?"
Annoyance
"No Steve, I want you to get that away from me-"

Eddie
Huffs
"Seriously Y/N? It's just a spider! There's no need to be scared of a little thing like that. Aren't you adorable bud?"
You're just watching
"You didn't just replace me with a spider did you"
"Let me think about it, yes. This one doesn't always complain like you- MY GOD I WAS JOKING DON'T KILL ME"

Gareth
"It's just a spider Y/N..."
Confused
"So like you're 99,9% sure that this spiders mission is to kill you and every human alive?"
Nods
Sighs
"Gareth?"
"Hm?"
"Would you still love me if I was a spider?"
"Y/N-"
"Tell me >:("
"Yeah of course, why not? I'll just bring the guy outside"
Rethinking life choices

A.N:
This chapter was more about the reader being more scared, if you want it the other way round, just tell me!