Supernatural short stories

Benny's shirt (Destiny)

Things were quiet in the bunker with Sam and Dean gone on a hunt, so Benny decided to watch a movie. He wasn't sure what Cas was up to, but he'd been in his room most of the day. He was about halfway through an old black and white movie when he heard Cas' door open, and footsteps heading towards the kitchen.

Benny was getting bored with the movie, and wanted another person to talk to, even though Cas doesn't like him, so he walked out of the room and made his way to the kitchen as well. There, he saw Cas grabbing a beer from the fridge. But, he wasn't in his usual outfit. Wait, was that-

"Are you wearing my shirt?" He asked, startling Cas slightly.

Cas froze and almost dropped his beer, but set it on the counter instead. He slowly turned around to see Benny, with a very confused look on his face. 

"No." Cas lied. Terribly.

"You sure? Cause it definitely looks like my shirt."

Just then, Sam and Dean arrived home, and Dean walked into the kitchen to get a beer.

"Hey guys- Cas, why are you wearing Benny's shirt?" He laughed a little.

"See?" Benny looked Dean and then Cas again.

Cas blushed a bit, and refused to look at Benny or Dean.

"I am wearing your shirt."

"We gathered that Cas, but why? And where did you get it?" Dean asked. Cas blushed more, slightly embarrassed.

"Cas?" Benny asked.

"It smells nice." Cas said quietly, looking at the floor. "And I got it out your laundry hamper."

The room was quiet for a moment, but soon Benny was chuckling a bit and walking over to Cas.

"It smells nice? Oh Cas, Dean was right. You are adorable." He laughed. "Oh, by the way, what have you been doing in your room all day?"

Cas' eyes went wide and he ran out of the kitchen to his room, and ran inside locking the door.

".....Okay then." Benny chuckled, looking at Dean.

"Reminds me of last week when I caught him wearing one of my old T-shirts." Dean said with a smile.

Both Benny's and Dean's smiles slowly dropped and their eyes widened as they looked at each other and a thought came to their heads.

"Do you think he-?" Dean asked.

"No, it couldn't be." Benny said.

A few seconds later, they ran down the hall to Cas' room, and begged him to open the door. After a few minutes of denying them, Cas finally opened the door, defeated.

Benny went in first and looked at Cas and then noticed something behind him on the wall.

"Cas, what is this?" He asked, walking up to it. "Dean, you might wanna come see this."

"It's nothing." Cas mumbled.

"Cas, that's not nothing. Do you really feel that way?" Dean asked, seeing what Benny was talking about.

On the wall above Cas' bed, were probably about a hundred post-it notes with Dean's and Benny's names, with hearts and happy little messages.

"I told you, it's nothing."

"I'm not sure how to feel about this." Dean said, a little weirded out by all the notes about him, saying how beautiful he was.

"I don't know about you Dean, but I'm honored. I thought you hated me Cas." Benny smiled.

"Well, I did at first. But, after I gave up my grace and became human, my feelings about a lot of things changed." He explained, looking at the two men in front of him. "I guess as an angel, I just thought of you as a monster and nothing else."

"I guess this would be a good time to say that I've had a crush on both of you for a while now..." Dean said.

"Really?" Benny and Cas asked at the same time.

"Yup. I mean c'mon have you seen yourselves? You're both gorgeous as hell, and your voices are like heaven." Dean admitted, completely unashamed.

"Hey, you're gorgeous too." Benny chuckled and winked at Dean.

"Does this mean what I think it means?" Cas asked.

"Do you guys wanna go get some pie?" Dean asked.

"Will this be considered a date? Cause if so I'm in."

"Hell yeah it's a date." Dean said happily as he walked out of the room.

Benny and Cas followed after him and Cas had a huge smile on his face. This must be what heaven on earth feels like.