Lover's Pentagon

Where Do We Start?

⚠️TW: Sex scene ahead (feel free to skip if this scene/chapter makes anyone uncomfortable! There will be another warning emoji to signify that the scene is over. Please take care in reading! -Liv)

Kathrine's POV

It's been a few weeks since I joined The Judgment Day and things have been extraordinary! I've definitely concluded that I love being with all of them romantically. At first, I thought it would be weird. Especially with Rhea and I being best friends before any of this but that friend love has evolved into a love that I can't explain. The same goes for the boys. I was friends with all of them before I left in 2021 but I wasn't as close with them as I was with Rhea. Now that I've spent almost a whole 6 months with them, I've gotten to know all of them in ways I never thought were possible.

Every time I kiss or hug one or all of them, it feels like the whole world around me doesn't matter. I've fallen for all of them and hard. I think they can tell too. I also think they're getting a little impatient about us having sex together. All of them including myself have high sex drives so the fact that we haven't yet blows my mind. I mean Rhea and I were so close but we got interrupted. Maybe that was a sign saying not yet. Who knows.

But all that changed. I finally had a day where I didn't have any meetings, so we came up with the idea that we would have an all-day date. I told Caleb he could have the day off and said if he wanted to stay at a hotel overnight he could. He took me up on my offer so it was just the 5 of us alone in the house.

I woke up later than I normally do. As I woke up, I looked around at the people I was in bed with and noticed that Damian was missing. Finn was awake and in his phone so I quietly asked where he was. "Damian's making breakfast for everyone. He used to do this for us before we moved in with you." Finn said hushedly while trying not to wake Dominik and Rhea. I cuddled up next to Finn as he put his phone down so he could enjoy this moment.

He pulled me into him and kissed my head. I closed my eyes and laid my head on his chest. He started to rub my back which made me sleepy all over again. I fell asleep again because I was shaken awake by Finn saying breakfast was ready. "You head down, I'll wake up Rhea and Dom," Finn said. I listened and made my way downstairs.

The smell of coffee was the first thing to hit my nose. I walked into the kitchen and as soon as Damian saw me, he handed me a cup. "You know me so well Dam, thank you," "De nada mi corazón". I love it when Damian or Dominik speak Spanish! Kinda makes what they say hot as fuck.

I sipped my coffee as I watched Damian finish up. Dominik sleepily made his way downstairs. "Good morning mi amor," he said in a sleepy voice to me before kissing my cheek and wrapping his arms around me from behind. "Good morning my lovely," I responded. "Morning papi chulo," Dominik said to Damian. I started laughing when I heard that. "Por el amor de Dios Dominik, really," Damian said while letting out some chuckles.

Dominik undid his arms and helped Damian. Rhea and Finn came walking downstairs. "Morning love," said Rhea as she kissed me on the cheek. "Morning," I responded. All of us sat together and ate the breakfast Damian made. We spent the day doing whatever we wanted. We played games in the game room, watched a few movies in the media room, and even went swimming!

Nightfall came and you could feel the energy coming off of all of us. The more time had passed, the more sexual things had become. I had gone upstairs to use our bathroom. When I came out, all four of them were on the bed, waiting for me. At that moment, everything felt right. "So I'm guessing now is the time we try this?" I asked as I walked over to the bed. "Only if you feel like you're ready," said Rhea. "We don't wanna push you if you're not," said Dominik.

"Where do we start?" Before anyone said anything, Dominik shot up from his spot on the bed and kissed me. I heard the others start to remove their clothes as Dom helped me out of mine. Once I was in just my bra and underwear, Rhea turned me around and pulled my face to hers. Rhea pushed me back onto the bed where I was met with Damian taking over.

Things were moving fast and before I knew it, all of us were naked. Dom and Rhea were at the end of the bed while Damian, Finn, and I were at the top. Damian pulled me up so Finn could go behind me. Once Finn was in a comfortable position, Damian carefully laid me on top of Finn. I watched Damian kiss down my body while Finn focused on marking my neck with his lips.

Once Damian's tongue made contact with my heat, I couldn't contain myself. With Damian eating me out and Finn giving me hickeys and playing with my boobs, I felt nothing but pure pleasure. Rhea and Dom moved up next to the 3 of us. Dominik copied Damian and started to eat Rhea out. I saw Rhea watching me out of the corner of my eye.

I felt a knot start to form in my stomach. I was getting close and I think Damian could tell because he put 2 fingers inside me and started moving them in and out at a fast pace. I was a moaning mess. When I came undone so did Rhea. All of us looked at each other. We felt nothing but ecstasy. Finn had gotten up from where he was on the bed and sat at the end.

Dominik and Damian switched so Dom was with me and Damian was with Rhea. Dom and I made out for a minute before he pulled away. He lined himself up at my entrance and slowly made his way in. He moved in and out of me, slowly quickening his pace. Damian and Rhea next to us were doing the same. Rhea and I turned to make out without moving our lower bodies too much. Rhea and I came undone again.

Rhea wanted her turn with me next so she climbed on top of me. She put her vagina in my face while she ate me out. Finn got his turn after Rhea. Damian got one more turn as well but instead of eating me out, he inserted himself in me. ⚠️

Once we all felt satisfied, we laid our heads on our pillows, trying to catch our breaths. "That... was... fucking... amazing," I said in between breaths. Everyone giggled at my comment. We lay there together for a little bit before the boys went to go shower. Rhea and I waited for them to finish up so we could take our turns.

"So, how was that?" she asked me. "It was everything I could've asked for" "Good! I'm happy we finally got to do this," "Me too!" The boys finished up so Rhea and I cleaned ourselves off. I put on a matching black lace bra and underwear set and walked out of the bathroom. I crawled into my spot and waited for everyone to join me. Once they were done, we cuddled the rest of the night until we all fell asleep.

I woke up the next morning bright and early. Since I didn't have any meetings yesterday, I had in-person all-day meetings today. Before I left the bedroom, I took one more look at the 4 still asleep. I wish I could've stayed with them but I had to take care of business. I quietly slipped out of the bedroom and walked downstairs.

I grabbed my purse and as I was about to open the door, Caleb came walking in with his suitcase in tow. "Good morning Ms. Daniels! How was your day yesterday?" he asked. "It was... entertaining if you know what I mean. What about you? How was your day off?" "It was stupendous! I know you have to head out so I'll tell you about it when you return," "Well, I'm excited to hear what you did! Hey when the others wake up, can you tell them I'm gonna be gone for the day but I'll be back around 5:30?" "Of course, Ms. Daniels"

It felt like my meetings were never gonna end! But finally, 5 pm hit which meant my meetings were over and I could finally head home. I pulled into the driveway and got out of my car. When I unlocked the front door, I was met with a rose petal path that went all the way upstairs. 

A/N: Ooo a cliffhanger! You guys asked for more intimate moments so here you go! Also, if you haven't seen my recent post on here then I will say it again. Thank you all so much for getting this story to 10k reads! This means more than you guys will ever know! Like I've said before, I've always loved writing but lost the love for it some years ago and just recently found the love for it again! When I got the idea to start this fanfic, I had no idea where it was gonna go or if it was going to be successful. Now having it at 10k reads shows that people (other than my family and bestie) love my writing! So again from the bottom of my heart, thank you! As always, I hope you enjoyed and I'll talk to y'all in chapter 22!!!!