𝐹𝑎𝑛𝑔𝑖𝑟𝑙 - Jeff the Killer x Fem Reader

ᏖᎥፈᏦᎥᏁᎶ ᏖᎥᎷᏋ

"MAYBE IF JEFF WASN'T SUCH A FUCKING BIGBACK, WE COULD ALL FIT IN THE DAMN TRUCK." Ben crossed his arms, looking at Y/N and Jeff. Toby and EJ were still in the front seats.

Jeff's jaw dropped, and he shoved Ben's shoulder.

"Excuse you, BIIITCH." Jeff retorted.

Ben scoffed and shoved Jeff back, resulting in them shoving each other river and over until they were fighting on the ground. Y/N watched bewildered, but Toby was on his phone, and EJ was just waiting for them to cut it out.

Y/N grabbed Jeff by his hood, pulling him away from Ben. Jeff let out a choked sound, falling back and letting Ben out from under him.

"You're still- holding on- Let go!" Jeff growled, flailing like a maniac.

"Cut it out, idiot!" Y/N said with a firm grip on his hood.

A unanimous sound of "Ooooooo" came from the people in the car, excluding Jack.

Jeff gritted his teeth, looking up at her. Ben sat in the car. Y/N followed after Ben and looked at Jeff with a slight smirk.

"C'mon Jeff, you're gonna have to sit on my lap." Y/N chuckled, causing some giggles from the other boys.

"HELL NO." Jeff replied, crossing his arms.

"Then I guess you'll have to sit in Ben's lap." She shrugged.

Ben and Jeff both looked at each other with mild disgust, and Jeff pulled his hood over his head and face. Jeff probably could have gone apeshit right then and there, but he didn't.

"Fine, you freaks. Only because I want free food." Jeff sneered, going over to the backseat and sitting in Y/N's lap. A few snickers came from Toby and Ben as the truck drove away from the mansion.

Jeff was surprisingly light, at least on Y/N's lap he was. Ben occasionally would tease Jeff during the car ride, just to make him upset. Toby got the aux cord and connected to it to his phone, playing some emo-ass music.

Because it was the middle of the night, barely anything was open. At the edge of town, there was a sketchy taco joint that they all agreed upon.

"YIPPEE!" Toby ticked, his neck popping to the side.

"GET ME OUTTA HERE. I WANT TACOS!" Ben said while banging on the car window. A few sus looking people gave Ben weird looks as they drove by.

Jeff grabbed Ben by the collar of his shirt, yaking him away from the window.

"WHY WERE YOU BORN LIKE THIS?!" Jeff said, shaking him.

"Could we please stop screaming until we're out of the car?" Y/N asked.

Suddenly, Pink Pony Club by Chappell Roan started to blast through the speakers.

Jeff shot up, giving Toby a dumbfounded look.

"Toby, what the fuck is this?" Ben asked, a smirk creeping on his face.

Toby's face immediately reddened, and he scrambled to his phone to shut off the song. "I DONT EVEN KNOW THIS SONG! I SWEAR B-BRO, I SWEAR."

Y/N laughed out loud before starting to sing along with the song.

"Pink Pony Club! I'm gonna keep dancing at the Pink Pony Club!" She sang, watching as a weary smile grew on Toby's face.

Toby started to sing along with her.

"I'm gonna keep on dancing down at West Hollywood!" He sang, albeit not great.

EJ nodded along with the song, while Ben let out a surprised chuckle.

"It's kinda catchy." He laughed, looking at Jeff.

Jeff glanced at Ben before his gaze ended on Y/N, who was singing passionately. It reminded him that he was also still sitting on her lap, and he was starting to feel out of place.

Y/N's hands wrapped around Jeff's waist instinctively, causing him to tense even more.

EJ found a parking spot just as the song ended. 

"Perfect t-timing!" Toby smiled.

Everyone got out of the car. Jeff shuttered as if he had the heebie-geebies. Y/N chuckled and nodded him with her shoulder as the group headed inside.

"Come on, stupid." She smirked, her stomach fluttering as she followed behind the others.

This really was her ideal friend group.

Jeff followed after her, staring at the back of her head like he had just gone through the most traumatic event of his life.

They all went to a table, since they didn't have to wait to be seated. Ben sat next to Jeff and Y/N with Toby and Jack across from them.

An exhausted worker went up to their table and slapped a handful of menus onto the table, then took out a pad of paper and a pen. Tbh, they were unamused by the killers.

"What drinks?" The waiter asked.

"Dr. Pepper." Y/N replied, taking a menu, a few others did as well.

"I second that. " Jeff said plainly.

"I want a sprite, and he wants a root beer." Toby said, pointing at EJ.

They all looked at Ben. Ben blinked at them before staring at the waitress.

"Anything but water." He said.

A snicker came from Jeff and the waiter frowned, walking away. The others couldn't help but smile or stifle laughter as the waiter turned their back.

"Don't be a bunch of assholes." Ben pouted, crossing his arms and slouching in his chair.

"You could have just ordered- like- A normal drink." Toby said, leaning his elbows on the table. Jack poked his straw into his drink and slipped it under his mask, taking a sip.

The waiter came back, giving everyone their drinks.

Jeff glanced over at Ben's drink before letting out a wheeze.

"BRUH. THEY GAVE YOU MILK!?" Jeff exclaimed, letting out a cackle. Ben's face went pale and he scrunched his nose.

"It don't smell like milk." Ben frowned.

"The chef probably made it special just for you." Y/N joked, eliciting a laugh from the table, except for EJ.

Ben's jaw dropped.

"Y'all are foul." He said and scooted the cup to the center of the table.

~After eating a delicious meal (except for the sus milk)~

Jack had Clockwork's meal in a to go bag, carrying it at his side as they went to the car.

"Oof... I think I ate too much." Y/N said, sighing as she opened the car door.

Jeff rolled his eyes and grabbed her arm. He pulled her back enough so he could get in first, and he crossed his arms.

"Hey, what was that for!?" Y/N said as the others got in the car.

Jeff leaned back in his seat, smirking.

"Your turn."