𝐹𝑎𝑛𝑔𝑖𝑟𝑙 - Jeff the Killer x Fem Reader

+𝗕𝗢𝗡𝗨𝗦 SCENE

Toby walked outside, his hands stuffed in his pockets. He always wondered what the cold felt like as he stared at the snow.

Jack put his hand on Toby's shoulder, startling him.

Toby jolted.

"God... You scared me," Toby said, sighing and leaning against the railing. He had been so lost in thought, he hadn't heard Jack following him out.

EJ took his hand away, quietly staring at Toby.

Jack put his hand on top of Toby's, holding his hand with a firm touch. Toby's heart skipped a beat, and he looked at his black pools.

"What?" Toby said softly. He clenched his other fist, battling with his Tourette's.

"Raccoon," Jack said, his hand reaching out to touch the dark circles around Toby's eyes. Toby leaned back, his cheeks pink.

Toby chuckled nervously, using his free hand to push away Jack's hand.

"I guess so," Toby shook his head at Jack's nonsense.

Jack outstretched his hand again, carding his fingers through Toby's hair this time. Toby froze before swatting his hand away.

"What on earth has gotten into you?" he blurted.

Jack stared quietly before taking off his mask. Tar splotches covered Jack's face from wearing the mask so often.

Toby's eyes lingered on the other man's face, speechless.

"Is it bad?" Jack asked in a raspy voice.

Toby quickly shook his head.

"No, no, it's just..." He narrowed his eyes, touching some of the tar on Jack's cheek. "different,"

Toby took a small step closer, scanning the creature's haunting features with his eyes.

Toby took a deep breath before quickly leaning in and pecking EJ's lips with his. He quickly retreated, looking for a reaction. He could feel the residue of the tar and something metallic on his lips. It was strange, but not unpleasant.

Jack paused before cupping Toby's face with his hand, and he kissed him back.