My Yandere and Me

Yandere Merman! x f! Reader x Yandere Siren! pt. 2

A/N: Technically, there's an extra yandere merman in this, but the title was getting too long for Wattpad's format.

TW: Spankings, Cuckolding

It had been a year since you went with Jacques and Calder into the sea. You learned how to swim with your tail and eventually had your baby girl, Pearl. You didn't know who the father was, and frankly, you didn't care. You only cared that you could now leave the sea and go back to being on land.

"Calder, the baby is crying," You groan, turning to your side.

"I got her," Calder replies, getting up from the bed and swimming to your child's crib. "You know, she really looks like me."

"Really? I think she looks like me. Especially with those beautiful eyes of hers," Jacques comments, giving Calder a cloth to wrap Pearl in.

"Don't start. Please, don't start. It's too early," You reply, grabbing Pearl and swaddling her.

"She definitely doesn't look like you. Obviously, she looks like me because she's mine. I did enter Y/N first," Calder says, swimming next to your side and looking at Pearl as she feeds.

"But we both came in her together, so your point is null and void," Jacques passively aggressively answers.

Merpolycule be damned. I'm not dealing with this shit anymore.

Your baby cries louder, and you wrap her onto your chest before swimming out of the shipwreck. When you pop your head out of the water, you see the beach you left so long ago. You swim onto the sand, feeling your legs return, and stand up in your naked glory, carrying your child. Luckily, you manage to walk all the way home without anyone spotting you, and you enter your old house.

"Look, Pearl. It's my old house. I'm surprised it looks clean, but I guess Calder must've kept maintenance of my house," You say, tickling Pearl's cheek.

"Ae!" Pearl giggles, smiling as your finger rubs her cheek.

"Come on, let's pack a bag and we can find somewhere else to stay," You state, kissing Pearl's forehead.

~~~~~~~~~~

"Y/N, who do you think Pearl's father is?"! Calder and Jacques exclaim, realizing you're gone from the bed.

"How could you let her escape? She took our baby!" Calder shouts, pushing his older brother.

"Piss off, she couldn't have gone that far!" Jacques exclaims, glaring at his brother.

The two mermen swim to the surface and find your footprints in the sand.

"Ok, Pearl, we're going to take a short trip," You say, rubbing your daughter's head and walking out of your house with a duffle bag.

Even though you were a mermaid for a year and practically living the dream of many girls, you missed being on land. You missed feeling the sun's hot rays hitting your skin directly. You missed eating seasoned food. You missed everything that made being a human girl great. Which is why you stepped onto the train station platform and enjoyed the hour-long ride to the big city, much to the dismay of your merboyfriends.

"Shit, she packed her shit and left! Calder, you knew her the longest, where would she go?" Jacques asks, walking out of your room.

"I don't know. She had a whole Pinterest board of cities she wanted to go to," Calder exclaims, looking at the scattered papers on the table. "There's a train station nearby, we can check there."

~~~~~~~~~~

When you got off the train station, you were astonished by the high-rise buildings and bustling life of the city. The hordes of people were something you only ever saw during the spring and summer, when tourists flocked to your town. You wandered the streets until you bumped into a young man in his early thirties with black hair to his shoulders, tan skin, and green eyes wearing the finest of suits.