The Siren Sisters (A Creepypasta Fanfic)

Chapter 8

About a week has passed by and the Maneater has become quite the attraction thanks to us. Men swarmed to this place just to hear us sing.

We also do our job to keep these guys in line. We've gotten all the regulars here calling us Lady just like Travis does. And anyone who wants to cause trouble gets their soul taken away.

And the bartender, who I now know as Charlie, did us a favor and got us a wider selection of songs to play. He even got us special outfits to wear when we sing. They ranged from beautiful dresses to things that a stripper would wear.

Of course, we didn't mind. Using our voices and looks to seduce people is right up our alley. Melody and Rhapsody have gotten quite used to using these men like puppets and playthings just like I have.

I was currently outside, walking around on the streets with my hood over my head. I glanced up at the setting sun before heading back to the bar.

Entering the Maneater, I went over and took a seat at our usual table in the corner with my sisters and Travis. I smiled at them and lowered my hood.

"Good news, the police searches have died down. We're officially in the safe zone."

Rhapsody jumped up and cheered. "Whoohoo! We're home free!"

Melody looked at me and said, "I guess that means we can relax a bit now, right?"

I nodded. "Yep. The cops don't have a clue. Even after this whole time of searching the entire city, they're still chasing their own tails."

I looked down at Travis, who was sitting on the floor next to me, kissing and caressing my legs. I smiled and ran my fingers through his hair.

"And I suppose you'll still remain with me, huh, tiger?"

He looked up at me with a smile. "Of course, Lady Harmony. You will always have my loyalty."

"Good."

I played with his black hair for a moment before politely asking, "Could you bring us some club sodas, tiger?"

He quickly stood up, bowing his head. "Yes, my lady."

He headed over to the bar, leaving us alone for the moment. I leaned over the table toward my sisters.

"What do you girls think? Now that the police have lost interest, we could seek out more souls again."

Melody glanced at Rhapsody who simply shrugged her shoulders, saying, "Works for me."

Melody nervously looked at me again, rubbing her arm. "I don't know. Don't you think if we kill more people outside of this bar, the cops will be onto us again?"

I smirked and looked down at my palm. "Perhaps. But if we could gather enough souls at once, we could take our true forms again. Then, not even the police could stand in our way."

I clenched my fist, thinking of all the power. Travis soon came back with our drinks and took a seat behind me, wrapping his arms around me and kissing my neck and shoulder.

I took a sip of my drink before changing the subject. "So, what kind of song should we sing tonight?"

Rhapsody excitedly raised her hand, almost spilling her drink in the process. "Ooh, ooh, can we sing Cannibal?!"

I shrugged slightly. "I don't see why not."

Rhapsody cheered and began guzzling her drink. I suddenly noticed someone unfamiliar enter through the front door. It looked to be a male wearing black pants and a white hoodie.

I couldn't get a good look at his face since he had his hood up. He walked straight over to the bar, but as he did, I noticed a glint from in his hoodie pocket.

I narrowed my eyes. This guy's got some kind of weapon on him. He could be dangerous. I nudged Melody, getting her and Rhapsody's attention and tilted my head in the stranger's direction.

"We've got a newcomer."

Jeff's pov

I glanced around the room, waiting for the bartender to bring my drink. That's when I noticed three girls and one man at a table in the corner, watching me.

What really stood out about the girls was the faint, red glow of their eyes. They definitely don't look human.

Once I finally got my beer, I took a quick gulp before heading over to the table in the corner.

Harmony's pov

We all watched as the stranger made his way over with his drink in hand. He casually sat down at our table.

"Hello, ladies."

I glanced at Travis and my sisters. They all had suspicious looks written on their faces.

I fixed my gaze on the stranger and calmly said, "You don't have to hide your face, you know. This place is safe from prying eyes."

He chuckled slightly. "Point taken."

He slid his hood off his head. I was surprised by what I saw. He had pale white skin with black, shoulder length hair. He seemed to have no eyelids along with what looked like a carved in smile on his face.

My eyes widened slightly while I heard quiet gasps from the others. I quickly narrowed my eyes and asked, "Who are you? Why are you here?"

He chuckled again at my questions. "You can call me Jeff. And if it isn't obvious, I'm here for a drink."

He held up his drink before taking a few gulps. "What about you? You're an odd looking group."

I gave a small smile and leaned forward slightly. "We're not going to tell you that."

His carved smile seemed to widen. "Oooh, you like to be mysterious, huh?"

My eyes were fixed on his mouth for a moment. "That's a nice smile you've got there. Want to see mine?"

Before he could reply, I grinned, showing my full set of teeth to him. His eyes seemed to widen ever so slightly, causing me to laugh.

"What's the matter? Did I surprise you?"

He then shook his head. "Not at all, in fact, your smile is almost as beautiful as mine."

We were soon interrupted by a loud thud. We looked to see two guys getting into a fight, knocking into tables and chairs in the process.

I frowned and yelled at them. "John! Chase!"

They ignored me and continued fighting. I growled and stood up, storming over to them.

"That's enough!"

I pushed them apart, getting in between them. They immediately stopped and watched me in slight fear.

"Knock it off, both of you! If I catch either of you causing trouble again, I'll kill you myself! Got it?!"

They both started backing away, mumbling, "Yes, Lady Harmony."

I casually made my way back to my seat, letting Travis run his hands across my arms and kiss my cheek. Jeff let out a loud laugh.

"That was the funniest thing I've ever seen! Those guys are total wimps!"

I frowned slightly. "It's not that they're wimps, they're just being on the safe side. If you haven't noticed, this is our turf, and it isn't wise to cross us."

His laughter quickly died down and he stood up. "Well, I think I'll take my leave then."

He left without another word. Rhapsody suddenly said, "I like him! He's got a smile like ours!"

"Minus the teeth."

Melody added to Rhapsody's statement. Travis suddenly frowned at me.

"He seems kind of...creepy to me. I've definitely got my suspicions about him."

I pecked his lips and smiled. "You're right. He's not to be trusted. But I have a feeling we'll see him again, at one point or another."