The Siren Sisters (A Creepypasta Fanfic)

Chapter 11

I frowned and glared at Jeff. "I should've killed you off when I had the chance."

He simply laughed. "Like you would stand a chance against me."

The guy behind me moved me forward slightly and I could now see my sisters being moved on either side of me. A figure in green passed by us and stood beside Jeff.

"Wow. You weren't kidding Jeff. Let me get a good look at you three."

The blonde boy made his way in front of my sisters before stopping in front of me. His eyes traveled up and down my body while a smirk crept across his lips.

"You've got to be the sexiest girls I've ever seen. My name's Ben Drowned, but you can just call me Ben."

The guy who held me then spoke. "And I'm Jack. Eyeless Jack."

"Um, what do we do with him?"

We all looked over at Masky who still had Travis pinned. Jeff shrugged his shoulders. "Kill him."

Masky looked down at Travis, moving the knife closer to his neck. "Wait!"

Masky stopped his movements and stared down at him. "What?"

"Can't I at least say goodbye?"

Masky sighed. "Fine. Go ahead."

Travis smiled and looked over at me. I could see all the emotions written on his face.

"My lady, it looks like my time with you is being cut short."

My expression softened as I gazed over at him. "Travis, I'm sorry. I'm the one who drug you into all of this."

"Don't apologize, my lady. It was my decision to stay by your side and I don't regret it. My only regret was not being able to protect you. I love you, Lady Harmony."

I watched helplessly as Travis closed his eyes, allowing Masky to slit his throat, ending his life. I felt my anger rise as Masky stood over Travis.

I barely even realized that I was growling and baring my sharp teeth.

"How dare you take away my favorite servant. I'll make you pay for this."

Jeff waved his hand dismissively at me. "Yeah, yeah, whatever. Come on, guys, let's tie them up and get going."

Jeff, Ben, and Masky came toward us. Jeff started taking my arms to tie them behind my back. I immediately began struggling, not caring about the weapon against my neck.

"Hey, sit still!"

Jeff was getting annoyed. In an instant, his hand replaced the weapon, wrapping around my throat. I stopped moving as I stared into his eyes in fear. I felt my hands being tied behind my back as Jeff held me by the neck.

"You're lucky we have to bring you back alive."

When he let me go, I could no longer move my hands. My sisters, with their hands already tied, were released and came over to me. The fear in their eyes was evident as they crowded around me.

"Maybe we should cover their mouths so they can't sing."

My eyes widened at Hoodie's statement. We'll be totally defenseless. Toby started explaining to the others about the power of our voices.

Hoodie and Masky started tying rags over our mouths. Once our mouths were completely covered, I smirked slightly. These rags won't do at all.

Ben then eyed us before asking, "Wait, what do we call them?"

Toby quickly interrupted him and said, "They call themselves the Siren Sisters. That's Harmony, Melody, and Rhapsody."

He pointed to each of us, telling everyone who we were. Jeff came over to me with that permanent grin on his face.