The Siren Sisters (A Creepypasta Fanfic)

Chapter 25

I watched with a smirk as the guy shuffled toward me. My soft lullaby had him completely hypnotized. I stopped my song, letting him snap out of his trance.

His eyes widened as he looked at me in evident fear. He started to back away from me, causing my smirk to widen. After just a couple of steps, he bumped into Jack, who stood right behind him.

Jack quickly grabbed his arms, keeping him still for me. I walked up to the guy and stretched my mouth open, swallowing his soul.

Once finished, I closed my large jaws and watched as Jack began to slice him open. After his kidneys were removed and stuffed into a small bag, the man's lifeless corpse was left behind in the alley.

Jack walked alongside me with his arm around my shoulder as we headed out of the city. It's been almost two weeks since the whole Offender incident.

All of the cuts, bruises, and other marks left by Offender have healed. All except the stab wound on my side. While the injury is still faintly there, it no longer hinders me. I can move around and touch it without any real pain anymore.

"It's so fascinating to watch you feed."

I glanced up at Jack as we started passing a few trees. "It is? I don't really think much of it myself."

He chuckled and said, "Of course you don't. But it gives me a chance to see your full set of teeth. You have such a pretty smile."

I grinned up at him, showing all of my sharp teeth that are normally hidden.

"There it is. That smile I love so much."

We soon saw the mansion ahead of us. Almost as soon as we entered the house, we were greeted by two people yelling at each other.

"We found it! It's ours!"

"So?! You won't ever even use it!"

In the living room was Ben, Masky, and Hoodie. Hoodie sat quietly on the couch while Masky and Ben yelled at each other.

"Hoodie and I had it first! We're keeping it!"

"No way! It should be mine! It was made for me!"

I'm guessing Slender's not here to stop them. Jack and I went over to the boys. I shoved my way between them and pushed them back.

"Settle down, boys. Now what the hell is going on here?"

They both looked at me and Masky started explaining, "When Hoodie and I were out, we found a silver ring in someone's house. Now Ben wants it, but we found it first."

Ben butted in and said, "Oh, come on, it was made for me. It has the triforce on it."

Masky showed me the ring. It was thick and completely silver with a triforce engraved on it. I rose an eyebrow at them.

"Seriously? All this fuss over a stupid ring?"

Ben suddenly snatched at the ring in Masky's hand, but Masky didn't let go. Instead, they just pushed and pulled at each other, trying to grab the ring.

The ring was suddenly sent flying into the air and right toward me. The two boys stopped and watched as I reached out and caught it in my hand.

"You guys leave me no choice. I guess I'll be keeping this, thank you."

I tucked the ring into the front of my dress, letting it slide between my breasts. The boys stared for a moment before Masky shoved Ben away and came closer.

"But it's ours! We had it first!"

"Not anymore. What would you even do with it anyway?"

He remained silent and I said, "That's what I thought. Now behave."