The Siren Sisters (A Creepypasta Fanfic)

Chapter 19

Rhapsody's pov

I sighed as I leaned over Toby, wrapping my arms around his neck while he played video games with Ben, Masky, and Hoodie. I glanced over at Jack, remembering what he told us a couple of days ago.

He spoke to Harmony. He told us that she would be back soon. In that time, my extra features had receded back into my body, leaving me back to my normal, adorable self.

I hugged Toby with a frown on my face. "It's just not the same without Harmony."

I watched his character on-screen get killed before he turned his head to look back at me. "Lighten up, Rhapsody. She said she'd be back soon. It's weird seeing you so depressed."

I smiled and squeezed him. "Aww, thanks, Toby."

He went back to the game, leaving me to frown again. I wish Harmony was here. It feels weird not having her here to tell us what to do. I really miss her.

After a short while, I got up and started heading upstairs. That's when I heard the front door open. I turned to see who it was and instantly felt my eyes widen.

It was Harmony. I wide grin spread across my lips and I quickly rushed up the rest of the stairs. I ran to Jeff's room, poking my head in.

Melody was sitting with Jeff, watching a movie with him. I was shaking with excitement and the grin never left my face.

"Hey, Melody. Guess what?"

Jeff paused the movie with a sigh of annoyance while Melody looked at me questioningly. "Someone just got home. I think you'll want to see her."

Melody gasped with wide eyes, instantly knowing who I was talking about. She smiled brightly and asked, "She's really back?"

"Yes! Come on! We've got to go see her!"

Harmony's pov

I walked into the room, watching as everyone's gaze was on me. I looked down nervously and smiled slightly. I noticed Jack quickly get up out of his seat and come over to me.

"You're back. Have you made up your mind?"

I looked up at him and nodded. "Yeah. I have no reason to fight it anymore. I'm here to stay."

We suddenly heard loud footsteps coming down the stairs. I looked to see Melody and Rhapsody both running toward me with smiles on their faces.

Jack took a step back, allowing the girls to tackle me in a group hug. "We're glad you're back."

"Yay! It's so great having you back after so long! We missed you, big sis!"

Melody parted from the hug while Rhapsody kept her hold on me. "Rhapsody, I was only gone for a few days."

"Well it feels like a long time!"

She squeezed me so tightly that I could barely breathe. "Rhapsody...too tight...let go."

I finally pushed her away, causing her to giggle. "Oopsies, my bad. I'm just sooo happy!"

I smiled at them both and asked, "Can we go for a walk? Just us three? I want to talk to the both of you."

They both happily nodded. I then heard Jack's voice cut in. "Don't be too long, okay?"

My sisters seemed to move back slightly, giving me a clear view of Jack. I smiled and went over to him. "I won't."

I placed a quick kiss on his mask where his lips would be. Before I could leave, I noticed Slenderman standing across the living room. I hadn't even noticed him appear.