Theo Raeken Imagines

Starting Over

"Surprise." Stiles said lacklusterly. He glanced between you and Theo who smirked, strolling across the room.

"Hey. It's so good to see you." He hummed happily.

You couldn't decide what to do, you missed Theo, mourned him, even after everything he'd done. Your friends understood and you'd gotten even closer with the pack. Without really thinking you lashed out with a sudden roll of anger rippling through you.

Theo gasped as your punch winded him. "I Should have seen that coming." he grunted out. You stormed away, relieved that Theo was back but furious over what he'd done.

He spent weeks trying to get you to talk to him. He did everything from hanging around outside your house to trailing after you like a lost puppy. Not once did your inner turmoil occur to Theo. You wanted to melt into him, appreciate that you had him back. But you weren't ready to forgive him.

"(Y/N)." Theo called as he strolled over to the car you were sat in. Malia raised her eyebrows when you growled, glancing at him and flickering your eyes.

"Leave me alone." You snarled and slammed out of the car.

*********************

"What do I need to do?" Theo asked, making Stiles jump and shriek as he turned away from the front door of his house to see Theo behind him.

"You need to stop sneaking up on people." Stiles huffed out through a fleeting breath.

"No. About (Y/N)." Theo huffed and Stiles narrowed his eyes.

"No you're not going to stop sneaking up on people or no you wanted and answer about (Y/N)?" Stiles' question made Theo shake his head a little.

"Both... I think." He answered.

"Fair enough I suppose. Um. Well maybe try talking to her rather than... stalking her like your dinner?" Stiles offered but Theo scrunched up his face.

"She won't talk to me." He said simply and Stiles groaned.

"Yes I am aware of that." He caught a glimpse of you and Malia over Theo's shoulder and grinned at Theo, shoving him round to look at you. "Instead of 'Hey. It's so good to see you,' Why don't you apologise and say you missed her?"

Stiles reached past Theo and tugged on malia to get her inside. For a moment she just looked between each person before realising she was supposed to help Stiles be 'subtle'.

"I missed you." Theo muttered and stared at his feet.

"I missed you too." You admitted, smiling awkwardly. You both spoke for a while before Theo kissed your cheek, living happily with the decision to start over. When you looked back at Stiles' house you rolled your eyes, seeing two faces staring at you from the landing.