What If...: The Story of What Could Have Been

Extra Ending

A/N: The results were still the same. This is after they walk out and Maxwell pulls his gun out

Lily held onto Eren tightly. Maxwell was shaking with the gun in his hand.

"Don't make me do this damnit!" Maxwell yelled. "Lily let go of that- that FREAK!" He yelled out. Lily shook her head and stared at Maxwell. Eren held Lily close and looked at Maxwell as well.
"Maxwell... just let us leave ok? W-we won't ever come back here! You can forget about us ok?" Eren tried to reason with the man. Maxwell shook his head.

"Let go of my wife you disgusting man and then maybe I'll consider you fat-head." Maxwell spat out. Lily looked at Eren.

"Let it go ok? Eren, we can walk away ok?" Lily asked him. "We can leave and ignore him ok?" Eren looked at Lily then at Maxwell. He then encouraged the two to walk away.

"So. Fat-head wants to chicken out instead of being a man. Ok. Ok. I see how it is. Maybe you shouldn't sleep around with other people's dames and just take care of yourself alone." Maxwell shot out, his smirk on his face. Lily felt Eren stopped and saw him beginning to get angry.

"Eren. Let it go. He can't hurt us if we walk away." She reminded him. Maxwell just continued to insult Eren but he took it a step too far.

"At least I know once I get my wife back, our kid won't be so dumb like your freak of a child." He insulted, breaking Eren's last mental straw from punching Maxwell in the face. Eren pulled away and turned to Maxwell.
"Eren... don't do it." She begged but he ignored and made his way over.

"You can insult me, my job, my dumb brain but you don't ever insult my child!" He yelled and threw a punch at Maxwell, making the rich man fall and drop his gun. Maxwell growled and pulled Eren down, the two beginning to fight for the last time. Lily was about to jump in but was held back by her butler.

"Eren!" She yelled repeatedly along with 'Stop!' but no use. The two were anything but gentle with their attacks. Lily eventually pulled away and ran over, bending down and trying to separate the two. Instead of that, she got punched. She fell back and touched her cheek. Eren looked over and pulled away from Maxwell. Maxwell quickly grabbed the gun and aimed at Eren. Eren held onto Lily and she held onto him.

"You Son of a bitch are gonna regret the day your father created you!" He yelled and before he could shoot at Eren, a guard ran over and disarmed the man. "Fuck you!" He yelled at the guard and struggled. Lily watched and looked down.

"Maxwell John Highland. I would like to declare a divorce and a restraining order on you for threatening my life, abuse and illegal possession of a firearm." Lily said out loud. Maxwell glared at her.

"You are nothing without me you pathetic whore of a woman." He growled. Lily smirked.

"I am stronger than you. If you ever come near me, Eren and Rosie I will personally shoot you in the head with no hesitation." She declared and got up, Eren following her. Maxwell began to struggle.

"YOU BITCH! YOU DESERVE EVERY HIT YOU GOT FROM ME AND YOUR DISGUSTING FATHER!" Maxwell yelled as she began to walk away.

"And you deserve to rot in hell." She said back to him, taking his rings off her hand and throwing them at him. He continued to struggle and growled at the two.

"Come on love. Let's go home and see Rosie." Eren said as he wrapped his arm around Lily, the two walking off.

6 years later

The couple sat outside on a bench, their sights out at their little daughter who was running around. They both had smiles on their faces and their eyes full of light. For once, their lives had changed and gone up. Lily was selling fresh bouquets of various flowers and made clothes. Eren on the other hand had picked up a job as a pilot, occasionally taking his wife out to the various exotic places he would go for work. They though lived a pretty stable due to the abundant amount of money Lily had earned as hush money from Maxwell for the years of damage he had placed on her and to make sure she never spoke about it to anyone with the Highland name. The couple looked at each other and smiled with their eyes closed and kissed gently.

"Should we tell her?" Lily asked quietly to her husband. Eren smiled and kissed her head.
"Rosie will find out soon anyway." Eren reminded his wife. Lily chuckled and looked at her daughter who was playing with a butterfly that had landed on the flowerbeds.

"Rosie darling! Come here!" Lily called out gently. Rosie turning and running over to the two, a huge smile on her face. Lily smiled and watched Eren scoop their daughter up and sit her down between the two of them. "Mommy has some news to tell you." She said to her daughter with a soft smile. Rosie's eyes lightening up quickly.

"Are we getting a puppy?" She asked excitedly. Lily chuckled and touched her daughter's light pink cheeks.

"Even better than a puppy. Mommy is gonna have a baby!" Lily said with a huge smile. Rosie's brain took a second before processing it. Her eyes soon wide and her jaw dropping from the news.

"I'M GONNA BE A SISTER!" Rosie yelled, jumping off her father's lap, accidentally kicking him in the groin and running in circles. Eren groaned slightly but smiled at his daughter's excitement.

"How much do you want to bet it's a boy?"

"I don't know. We'll just have to wait and find out."