(+Yandere!) Creepypastas x Fem. Readers One-shots! (#Wattys2019) Requests CLOSED

Yandere! Ticci Toby x Fem. Reader PART 2

Part 2 so read the first part.
Nowadays I feel like making long, long chapters for some reason... Send help O^O

Y/n's POV
Toby's tourette syndrome starts to appeal more. However, it seems like he can control the syndrome but not his twitches and tics. He gets angry or sarcastic towards the guy who's with me. If he's looking at me from afar, he'll just look sad. He starts to act really creepy towards me and he starts to get really overprotective over me. It must've been my fault for rejecting his feelings. But his behaviour seems to slightly makes sense and I start to get really used to it.

Until my boyfriend transfer to my school.

He was just an online boyfriend, around my age. We lived faraway but we chatted through Discord (not sponsorred) and play games together. He was funny and kind so it'd make sense why he is my boyfriend. He came just yesterday and we hungout more often now. He had short blonde hair, shining deep ocean blue eyes, and usually wears a white shirt with jeans and black sneakers. But of course I didn't forget about Toby.

"Hey, Toby!" I called up to him who was walking down the hall, probably trying to hide his jealousy. "Y-yeah?" he said approaching me. "Meet my boyfriend, Nicolis." I showed Nicolis to Toby. He waved and smiled at him. Toby looked angerred but proceeds to offer him a hand, trying to make a good impression in front of me. He shooks back his hand. And the three of us hungout together everyday.

One day.
We were sitting in the school yard, eating out our lunch. Things have gotten really strange since I've introduced Toby to Nicolis. Toby makes more moves towards me than usual. If it's in front of Nicolis, Nicolis would pull me away in jealousy. This has become some sort of rivalry between the two. Anyway...
Toby suddenly side-hug me on my left. I looked at him a bit surprised but I didn't want to hurt his feelings any more so I let out a happy sigh. But on my right, I sense a dark and fierceful glare coming from Nicolis. He was glaring spesifically to Toby who was hugging me. "Uhm, I'm sorry to interrupt your cuddling but could you let her go?" he sarcastically smiled as he sarcastically said calmly. I start to feel some sort of deja vu incoming. "Well, s-sorry f-for making you such a j-jealousy b-butt h-head." Toby scoffs. Nicolis stood up and growled more, clenching his fists "Did you forget, tourette boy? I'm Y/n's boyfriend and so you have no rights to steal her. You're just her best friend." "Oh s-so yo-you're really j-jealous??" the two continued to fight. "She's mine, tourette boy!" "I-I'm Y/n's best f-friend so I-I h-have th-the rights t-to cuddle h-her!" "No you don't, you sick freak!!" he yelled and slapped him hard. But Toby didn't fell down or feel like he wasn't feeling any pain. But what's more surprising is that how Nicolis called my best friend, Tobias Erin Rogers, "a sick freak" (oh he's gettin it now >:[=  ). I clenched my fists and gritted my teeth. "You f*cking bastard! You don't call my best friend a sick freak!!" I yelled at Nicolis, slapping his cheek really hard which cause him to stumble. I ran away, crying in disappointment. I just ran to class and cried.

"This is all your fault." Nicolis blamed.
"It's not. I-I didn't d-do anything." Toby scowled.
"If you hadn't provoked me she wouldn't have slapped me." "I d-didn't provoke you, it w-was j-just your u-unecessary j-jealousy." "Grh...! That's it! I've had enough of you! You're getting a pirce of my mind, ticcing freak!" "You're the one who should pay for making my dear Y/n sad."

I stopped crying as soon as the bell rang. I wasn't going to worry much about the others since they're pretty scared of me now. I was so upset but I knew I should really apologize for slapping him so I plan to apologize after school.
But strangely, after the teacher came in, Toby has yet to come...
After a few minutes, he came into class. The teacher scolded him and he only apologizes and went back to my seat. He smiled behind his mouthguard and gets his chair closer to mine. His creepy behaviour starts to appeal more.

After school...
I waited nearby the lockers as I placed all of my stuff into my lockers. As I closed my locker, a guy pinned me against the locker. "Waiting for somebody?" he asked sweetly. That isn't Nicolis, it was a random creepy guy in school. From what I heard, he's the playboy of the school. But it seems like he's interested in me, which is what I don't like. "Yeah, for my boyfriend." "That ticcing guy? Hah!" "He isn't my boyfriend, but how dare you mock my best friend!" I yelled, pushing him away but he kept coming closer and managed to hold me. "What a waste, truly. You're beauty spend on such a monster." he said, leaning closer. But he was punched really hard on the face. There I saw a familiar figure.

It was Toby who punched him.

"Y-Y/n, leave." he said darkly. "But-" "Please Y-Y/n, leave for me. I'll h-handle him m-myself." he pleaded. I nodded and ran back home.

"Let's finish what you started, shall we?"

Time skip to 18:09
I was chilling in my room, relaxing myself after the unfortunate event. I sighed at the memory and switched to a news channel on TV.

"Breaking news! Two bodies of a male teenager was found on the lake nearby the Riverbed High school. They were reported by a man named Daniel at 15:00 while wanderring around the area. The victims cannot be identified, nor the weapon choice which caused a big wound on the head; leaving a big gap that makes their brain visible and it appears that their faces was cut out."

A female news presenter reported. I was shocked of the news. What's more is that one of the victims had a familiar blonde hair colour, but coverred in blood. Then I felt a hand on my shoulder. "You shouldn't be reading that kind of news now." a familiar voice spoke. I turned my head and saw a bloody Toby. My eyes grew wide and jump backwards, caused me to fall off the couch. "S-stay back, killer!" "It hurts, Y/n. Why would you call your best friend 'a killer?" "You killed them, didn't you...?" I mumbled loudly. "I did. It was very enjoyable. And now that everyone is out of my way, you finally belong to me~." he said as he gots closer, knelt down and place a hand on my cheek while the other takes off his mouthguard, revealing his scarred mouth. I flinched in fear at the sight. But before I could react, he pulled me into a tender kiss.

"I love you, Y/n~."

I'm one hell of a lazy writer, huh? Sorry, I've been reading some fanfics of creepypastas. I was absorbed into it I nearly forgot. Welp, I'm tired for today but please request more. Thank you very much for reading! Don't forget to request!