(+Yandere!) Creepypastas x Fem. Readers One-shots! (#Wattys2019) Requests CLOSED

Homicidal Liu x Affectionate! Clueless! Fem. Reader x Sully

Requested by RetroVinyle. Might be inspired.

Now, I'm not entirely certain if I can do this but lolz I'll do it anyway.

Y/n's POV
I have a really cool friend named Liu Woods. No, I didn't mispronounce that, it's literally his name. He's so funny and adorable! He's very shy sometimes but can be fierceful, due to a double personality. Yes, he has Sully, a personality formed inside him. Both of them seems to fight over me. What I mean is that they keep switching with one another and argue with eachother, like a crazy person arguing with themselves. But I wasn't sure what they meant. They keep saying, "Y/n's mine!" or something of the sort. I don't know what they meant by that. What? Don't say I'm oblivious! I am not, promise.
His life was pretty crazy. He was living a hell life until his brother snapped and killed his family. He's on the run, definitely, and is currently living with me. We both get along very well however, and I'm glad for it.
We go to the same school. Because of his wounds, people usually mock him, calling him a ‘freak’. Of course, as his good friend, I didn't like it. I'd usually yell at them and sometimes get myself into trouble quite a lot. I'm me, and he's himself, it seems.

One day, we both are chilling in my room. “Hey, Y/n. Stop holding hands with Jared. It's so annoying.” Sully spoke out of nowhere. “Hah? What you mean? We aren't holding hands.” “Then why are you holding his hand when you first met him?” he countered. Jared is a new student in our class apparently. I actually just shook his hand, that's all.
Oh.
That's what he meant.
“Silly Sully, it's not holding hands! It's called a handshake.” “Handshake?” “Do you not know what's a handshake?” “Err....” he said nervously. I grabbed his hand and shook it. “That's a handshake, silly!” I giggled. He blushed like crazy and looks away. “H-Hmph... but just stay away from him, okay?” he scolds. I giggled at his adorableness. Such a tsundere, aren'tcha? “Aww! You're jealous that he's gonna take your friend away from you!” “W-wha?! N-no way! D-don't claim such things...” he mumbles. I hugged him suddenly. “Ndaww! No need to lie about your feelings. Besides, he's just a friend to me!” I said enthusiastically. He blushed even more.

Heh...
Just a friend, huh?

Okay, okay! I admit. I might be clueless... but...
It's really nothing more than that. I probably wasn't interested in him. Like, I only see him as my friend.

But Jared? We talked a lot during class. We sat next to eachother, so it's understandable if we're being lousy. But after that chatter, I can feel a strong bond between the two of us. I know it seems so unbelieveable, but it's true. He seems kind and generous.
Sure, Liu is also like that. But Sully can be very hurtful sometimes, and that personality is barely controllable. So... what now?

I started to hangout with Jared more. Liu was left behind, feeling lonely. We only talk at home, and I swear he always put that fake smile on like something's wrong. I don't know what did I do wrong, but he appears to be very sad a lot. I mean, what did I do? Is it my doing?

Weeks and weeks after, my feelings developed for the guy. Jared, not Liu. Liu's my best friend so I don't want our little friendship feel awkward. But Jared? He's literally the kind of guy I wanted. And tomorrow after school, I'm planning to confess my feelings.
“Jared, do you have any crushes?” “Huh? What's this so suddenly?” “Juuust curious.” I said convincingly. He hums and thought about it a little. “W-well... there's this girl I'm particularly interested in. I really can't describe her into words! She's perfect for me.” he said. I blushed slightly. I didn't know who he was talking about. I just assumed it was me he's talking about.

“Y/n...” Liu called. I squealed and just went into my little imagination. “Hey, Y/n... talk to me, will you? You've been with that Jared guy for too long. Please...” he begged. He seems angry and yet so ‘gloomy’, seeking for my attention. I just completely ignored. He then suddenly lunges at me. No, he's not being Sully, he's being himself. He gripped my wrists. I snapped out of my little world and pays attention to Liu. Seeing him this upclose got me a little nervous. I blushed a little. “Y/n... please... talk to me.” he begged adorably. God lord, I swear, he's just the cutest. Whenever he made that sad adorable look, it kills me. “Y-yeah, Liu...?” “Stop being with Jared so much and be with me... I-I...” he spoke shyly. Nooo! Stop being so cute! I'll die from it, Liu!! “I-I'm... I-I...-” “Y/n, I've been calling for you-” my mom cuts off Liu, but was cut off when she saw this ‘scene’. “Aaahh! S-sorry for interrupting! Y-you can go on a-ahead and continue...” she said and left in embarrassment. Both of us blushed heavily. “Mom!!!!”

Today's the day I finally confess my feelings. Yeah, what happened yesterday meant nothing. I managed to explain to my mom and she was relieved. Phew, misunderstanding solved. But that was embarrassing. I couldn't stop thinking about it. Ugh, whatever do you mean, Y/n? Focus on Jared and your confession, right now! This is your chance.
I slipped in the note in his locker. I squealed mentally. I immediately left to class before anyone suspects me suspicious.

More time skips!!
I bet he reads the note so I rush to the back of the school. I'm nervous. I hope he accepts my feelings.
I reached there but... it wasn't something I expected. I saw Jared, hugging another girl I didn't recognize. I admit though, she looks more beautiful and looks very generous. My heart shattered into pieces. “J-Jared? Who's that...?” I spoke. He notices and smiled happily. He looks happy, so much more. “This is my girlfriend, the girl I've been talking about. Her name is Jessica Alderiene.” he introduces. She smiles sweetly and waves a hello to me. I hid my sadness and waved back, smiling. Then soon after I excused myself and left.
I sat at a bench and cried, burying my face inside my hands. I thought all this time, he likes me. B-but no...
“Y/n...?” Liu called. I lifted my head and wipe away my tears. “Don't lie to me, I know exactly what happened.” he said seriously, concerned. He then sat next to me. “It's nothing...” I sobbed. “He's not worth it. Besides, there's always someone else for you.” “W-who...?” I asked. He then pulls my shoulder and leans over for a kiss. A soft and a gentle one. It brightens everything. I feel so joyous. A euphoria, perhaps. A feeling I thought was never true for Liu. Apparently, all this time, I've been in love with him. But I lied, and cluelessly never understand his efforts. I felt guilty, but him kissing me means he forgaves me. I feel so grateful.

Maybe he is my one and only.

Ahh, a sweet, cheesy, fresh love, amirite? Cliched, sure, but I've done my best. Thanks for reading!