(+Yandere!) Creepypastas x Fem. Readers One-shots! (#Wattys2019) Requests CLOSED

Yandere! The Puppeteer (Jonathan Blake) x Fem. Reader

Requested by ClaireFirefly111. Might be inspired.

First time doing Jonathan! Dunno much of him so deeply apologize for cringe :')
Oh, did I ever say that Jonathan looks like someone who has never brushed his teeth before? XD
Long chapter ahead!!

Y/n's POV
I love to dance at young age. Classical dances like ballet, tap dance, tango (I ain't French XD), and many more. When I'm 10, I fell in love with theatres like musical theatres and operas. It also makes me love classical music, clothes, lifestyles, even their cultures and histories. But I tend to focus more on dance and theatres because they are the ones that grew on me more.

I enrolled a school full of talented people. Many people attended this school because of its popularity in the country. It's a big and successful school after all so no wonder people came to enroll here. Each individuals have different talents of course and so the talents' classes are divided separately. I joined drama and dance class, for example. Yeah, there are variety of classes and each students can only join 2 classes at a time and can switch a year after.

One time I was practicing dance alone in the classroom after school. It was 3 PM so it was already empty. Just me rehearsing dance moves along with my bag. Suddenly I stumbled on my toe and fell painfully, spraining my ankle. I groaned and whined in pain quite loud, causing it to echo in the silent room and hallway. I hold my tears and tried to stand up but immediately fell, causing a loud thud. "Anyone there?" a male voice spoke, echo in the hallway. I didn't feel like answerring his call even if I seriously need it right now. I stayed quiet and tried my best to hold my tears. My sprained ankle really ache my legs. The male peeked in and rushed towards me. "Are you alright, miss??" he said. I looked at him and he looked very scary. I backed away after seeing his appearance. "Don't back away. I won't hurt you, despite my... creepy appearance." he smiled and got closer. I wasn't sure but I let him. He massaged my feet gently, giving me an enjoyable feeling.
"T-thanks..." I said. "Not problem. Can you stand up?" "I think..." I tried to stand up. I stood perfectly fine. "I'm glad. How can you sprain your ankle like that?" "I fell as I practiced the dance moves." "I see. Be careful next time, but I think you shouldn't force yourself too much." "No... It's fine, really." I said then sighed. I took my bag and begin to exit the class. "Wait! I'm Jonathan. What's yours?" "Y/n. Nice meeting you." I exclaimed and left.
"Y/n, huh? Interesting."

Next day
I enterred school as usual. I was greeted with a familiar face. "Hey, Y/n." he said. It was Jonathan. "Were you waiting for me?" "Maybe." he said playfully. "You'll look like a creep y'know." I joked. "It's fine. I want to get to know you better. Is that fine with you?" "Eh, sure. I haven't made many friends so far." I said. We walked together throughout the time. People looked at us strangely. Sure, he might look creepy and weird but he's a nice guy and people shouldn't judge someone by its looks. It's annoying when people judged your appearance.
He was apparently in my class and he helped me through the class sessions. We begin to spend time more and always hung out whenever we can. It's fun for us.
Nowadays he acted shy towards me. He blushed sometimes, look away, and dodge questions if I ask about it. But he would find ways to scoot over closer to me, wait for me at the entrance of the school, growl at any guy I talked other than him, and follow me around often. I feel uncomfortable and confused, like it's my fault. I really need to know why.

"Hey, Jonathan?" "Y-yeah?" he stutters. Here we go again. "Can you be honest with me for a bit? Why have you been acting strangely towards me? Did I do something wrong?" I looked at him, concerned. "You stole my heart..." he mumbled. "What?" "N-nothing!! U-uhh... You didn't do anything wrong to me, Y/n. But... I can't tell you... not now!" he stutters. Now I became more confused of his behaviours. "Please tell me what's wrong. You're making me a bit uncomfortable with that behaviour. But it's not like I hate you or anything!!" I stated, panicked at the end. He looked at me confused. "Maybe someday..." he said. I sighed. "Fine... But please tell me that 'someday'. Whenever it is." "Alright, Y/n." he said and patted my head with a smile on his face. I smiled at him.

After school
After taking my stuff I begin to exit the school but a group of girls came over to me. "Hey, could we talk?"

"What do you want?" "A favor." one of them started. "Can you stay away from Jonathan?" "Which?" "Ugh, that one you always hung out!" the other yelled. I gasped. "Why? I thought you people would see him as a creepy figure. Why should I stay away from him??" "Look if you don't stay away from him, I'll tell everyone you made a mistake on a dance performance." "W-what...? How did yo-" "It's our secret to keep. Now will you obey?" the leader said. I lowerred my head and begin to grow sad. I was famous in the town and school. I couldn't simply disappoint my parents either. I sighed regretfully and nodded. "Good girl. You can leave now." she exclaimed. Can't believe I've been blackmailed.

For the next few days, I ignored Jonathan and dodged him. I sometimes cry whenever I'm alone. I was sad that we couldn't spend time anymore. But it was for the best. Wish I could tell him what's happening.

I was behind the school, throwing out trash. As I was about to leave, Jonathan came and immediately pinned me up against the wall. "W-what're y-" "Why're you ignoring me??" he cuts off. I grew sad and shocked. "I can't te-" "Y/n tell me!" he yelled. "I-I'm sorry b-" he cuts off by kissing me and holding my wrists, the other hand holding my chin. My eyes grew wide and I begin to blush. He had feelings for me?? He lets go. "Now tell me." "I... I've been blackmailed... by a group of girls..." "Who're they??" he growled. I flinched but managed to clarify their appearances.
"Thank you. You should go home and rest." he smiled and hugs me. I hugged back. "Alright." I said. I went home soon after.

Time skip
I was sitting comfortably at my living room, watching some shows. Suddenly, yellow, bright golden strings wrapped around my body off guard and finally coverred my view. Soon somehow, I passed out.

I woke up, gasping and breathing heavily for air. I realized I was chained against the wall. I panicked mentally and scanned the dark room. The door then openned and footsteps were filling the silence. It switched on the light but it's dimly lit. I could barely see anything but it's enough for me to see the figure, and I wished I didn't or hoped it to be. It was Jonathan, the same one. He shines a toothy grin (pun intended??) at me. I flinched in fear, only to get distracted by a rotten smell. "Calm down, princess. You're fine." he said softly. He began to approach me. "What's this... awful smell...?" then realization struck me. "Did you kill someone?!" I panicked. He proudly nods, making me more panicked and my eyes grew wide. "Why?? Who did you kill?!" I cried. "No need to pity those who blackmailed you." I grew shock, heart starts to race. "They didn't deserve it! This isn't you, Jonathan...!" I cried more. He placed his hand on my cheek, carressing it gently and wiping my tears with his thumb. "Sshh... It's fine, my princess. You'll finally understand." "I'm not your princess..." "You can't be this clueless, right? I love you, Y/n. And you will learn to love me back, because now you're finally my princess, my only~." he slowly leaned closer and finally kissed me. I couldn't do anything. I was weak and pathetic to even do anything, aside from accepting this cruel fate.
"No worries, princess. You'll learn to love me like how I love you. Just listen to me and you'll do fine~."

The next thing I knew, Jonathan got control over my body. I was hypnotized, unable to do anything completely. I was in his yellow golden strings, following his movements, dancing just the way he wanted me to.

Ahh, delaying the inevitable. I seriously need to stop slacking off XD
Hope y'all enjoyed this awesome chapter. :)