Man Eater

5.6K 57 26

by ZoomQ21

by ZoomQ21

A/N: So before you read this, I want you guys to know something. I didn't know much about Nagatoro. However, I did read a couple of things about her character, mainly her teasing nature. Know that if certain things are off, I am just now getting to know more about her. Requested by TGFOAnime2803. On another note, C0LDSUN wanted me to use the song Myself by Nav. Personally I have never heard this song, but hey it's something new. The song I believe that fits this chapter though is this (At the beginning that is).

____________________________________________________________________
3rd Person POV

Rain. It was said to last the whole entire day. Though most would groan at the rather unpredictable weather, Y/N L/N welcomed the water droplets for both he and the sky shared those common drops of water. However, for Y/N they weren't simple water droplets. They were tears. Tears for a broken relationship. Tears for his broken heart. Tears for Nagatoro. When he had first entered his relationship with Nagatoro, many of his friends had called her a "man eater", to which Y/N simply rolled his eyes. His friends were known to mess around a lot, however if he had heeded them... then his heart wouldn't be in pieces.
____________________________________________________________________

"It's really coming down out there..." Currently, Y/N was staring out the window of the school's library. Since nobody really came to the library, Y/N was free to enjoy the empty and quiet space. Not only did it allow him to read manga in peace, but it allowed him to think about the past events with Nagatoro. 'Each time she told me she loved me... were all of her words lies? Each kiss she gave me... were they not filled with the same passion I gave to her?' Suddenly, the sound of knocking reached Y/N's ears, breaking him out of his thoughts. "Hey babe~!"

'Nagatoro...' The sight of her nearly caused his eyes to tear up. By her tone, it didn't seem like she had been going through the same thing he was... though he should've known that. True to everyone's words, Nagatoro was in fact a man eater. "Aren't you going to say hi?" Nagatoro smirked as she sat down beside Y/N. She gently placed her head on his shoulder and wrapped her arm around his. "How come you didn't answer any of my calls or texts? I know that you saw them." Rather than attempting to answer her, since there was a good possibility he would break down, Y/N continued to read his manga as if she weren't there. This, of course, only made her smug smirk grow larger. "Y/N, are you still angry about what happened? I told you that he was just a stress reliever. I was so angry that day and you weren't there. I needed someone to help me... and his 8 inch cock was enough to help." At the very mention of the event, Y/N's hand shook. Nagatoro had brought it up as if it were something so passable like a party or a carnival.

"You know, he had some great things that I think you could learn from. The way he kissed my neck and nibbled on my ear was-"
"Stop..."
"Hm?" Nagatoro's smirk grew as large as her face could allow.
"Stop... please..."
"I'm just trying to tell you things to do when we have sex Y/N."
"You... How can you just speak like this was just nothing?" Y/N's tears hit the pages of the manga. Slowly, Nagatoro's smirk fell.
"Y/N-"
"Am I just some toy to you Nagatoro? Was I just someone to drag around?"
"Of course not! You're my boyfriend!"

"I was your boyfriend. I was the person who wanted to be there for you... but I guess there was something I wasn't. I wasn't the guy you really wanted. I wasn't the one who could satisfy all of your needs." Y/N then shut his book and stood up. Nagatoro would've tried to pull him back down, but she knew he was stronger than her. It was quite obvious. "I... If there's one last thing I can say to you... It's that I'm sorry. I'm sorry that you had to waste your time with someone like me. Someone who couldn't give you what you wanted." The petite girl opened her mouth to speak, but her words refused to leave. "Have fun with your new fuck stick. I hope you guys last longer than we did..." As Y/N walked away from her, Nagatoro felt her eyes water up with tears. "H-Hey... don't leave..." Nagatoro's words seem rather soft. To her, it was unknown if Y/N heard them or not. However, there was one thing she was certain of. If Y/N truly felt like this... then she couldn't simply let him go like this...
____________________________________________________________________

"I should've fucking listened..." Y/N released a soft sigh as he placed his head on the lockers. Though he was still upset about the encounter with Nagatoro, his mind had felt a little bit better. It had seemed as though his small confession helped lift a small weight from his shoulder. "E-Excuse me, I... I need to get to my locker." Y/N turned his head to see a ravenette with a few books in her hands "Sorry." As he pushed away from the lockers, he couldn't help but notice one of the books she was holding. 'Is that...'

"Hey, is that one of the latest chapters for My Hero Academia?"
"Y-Yeah. You... You read it too?" The girl held the manga closer to her.
"Yeah. I had just finished the previous chapter earlier." Y/N then held up the last chapter in his hand. "Do you... mind if I borrow it for a bit?" The girl smiled and handed to Y/N "Oh, I'm sorry. I didn't ask what your name was."

"I... I actually share my name with someone from My Hero. Yui..."
"Y/N. Class 1-B huh?" For a brief moment, Y/N smiled. This smile, however, caused Yui to notice something.

"W-Were... Were you crying?"
"...I... Yeah..." He chuckled and looked up at the ceiling.
"W-Why?"
"It... It's a long story. I... I don't think you'd be interested."
"You... Y-You could tell me. I... I think I could help you. Well, I'll try."
"...How about we get to know each other better? I... If we do that then I'll tell you. Deal?"
"Deal."

One Week Later

"Nagatoro. Hey, Nagatoro!" The petite girl broke from her daze at the sound of her friend's call. Slowly, she turned her head to see her friends giving her an odd look. "Are you alright? You keep staring at Y/N and that shy girl and it's a bit...weird." For a brief moment, Nagatoro remained silent. She had only told them that she and Y/N broke up, but didn't bother to give them any details. She didn't need her friends leaving her too. "I'm fine. Just spacing out." Slowly, Nagatoro walked over and sat beside Y/N and Yui. "...What are you doing over here?"

"I... I just wanted to talk to you. Just us please." Y/N turned his head to Yui before doing a plug like motion. Yui then pulled out her phone and a pair of earbuds. Once she put them in, Y/N turned back to Nagatoro. "I'm sorry..." She quickly blurted out. "I... I shouldn't have messed around with that other guy. He... He doesn't even come close to you!" She then looked down, her eyes watering up only a little bit. "If... If I could go back and change what I did, I would do it in a heartbeat!"

"Toro..." Nagatoro looked up at him with a few tears slipping down her face. Y/N pushed her chin up slightly and sighed "What we had... it's in the past. No matter how much you beg and cry... I won't come back to you. You broke my heart..."

Biting her lip, Nagatoro wrapped her arms around him "But that's all I want. You're all I want. I miss cuddling together. I... I miss your warm lips... I... I..." No longer being able to hold it in, Nagatoro cried into his chest. "I just miss us!"

"..."
"Please... I... I've changed. I learned what it's like to lose."
"...It isn't that simple."
"Please..." Nagatoro begged.
"..."
"If... If I have to tell the whole school what I did just so we can get back together, I'll do it."
"Toro... just stop."
"But... But I just want us to be back together."
"I know... I know..."

As Nagatoro continued to cry into his chest, Y/N looked back at Yui, who seemed to be playing a game on her phone. "Toro... I've moved on. I think you should too." She then lightly pushed off of his chest "H-How can I when you were the best thing I ever had?"

"...I don't know."