Be More Chill, Hamilton, and Dear Even Hansen x Reader

Michael x popular! Reader-I know that voice

WARNING: A bit of sexual assault. And a plot twist at the end! If your good with this, read on!

"Get out of my way, you loser!" Jake Dillinger, my boyfriend, yelled while pushing a kid with a red hoodie and glasses away from the classroom door. 

Okay, I won't pretend I don't know who the guy was that Jake pushed away. 

His name is Michael Mell. He wears a red hoodie with different patches lining the sleeves of it, he had dark, coffee-brown eyes that I could get lost in easily, and brown-black hair that was always a bit messy. He was unpopular and friends with another unpopular guy, Jeremy. He was the school's stoner, and often smoked outside at the back of the school or his basement. 

Your probably thinking, "Wow, this chick is a weird stalker." And you'd be right. 

Kinda. 

I've ALWAYS had a crush on Michael, but one day Jake Dillinger, the most popular guy in school, asked me out. I knew he and his popular friends would make my life HELL if I didn't say yes, so here I am now. 

I sighed and slipped into the hallway with Jake, who was snickering about what he had just done to poor Michael. 

"Did you see that, babe? Ain't no one gonna get in our way!" he snaked his arm around my waist. I giggled nervously, but a weird feeling bubbled in my stomach. 

We passed by the detention room, and no one other than Rich, Jake's short and purvey friend, was sitting in there. He grinned at Jake slyly and gave him a thumbs up. Jake winked back and tightened his grip around me. 

"Ummm....why don't we go out back, babe, there's something I need to show you," Jake said darkly. 

"Uh...why don't we just go to lunch? I'm kinda hungry," I said nervously. 

Jake chuckled darkly and muttered, "Me too." 

He took my hand and dragged me outside. I did NOT like where this was going. I tried to protest, but Jake insisted as he dragged me to a very private spot. It smelled like pot. 

Jake pinned me against the tree and said, "Ready to see what I wanna show ya'?" 

"Jake, please, let's just go and—"

I was cut off by Jake hungrily kissing me on the lips. I get it, Jake was my boyfriend and all, but I did NOT want what he wanted that second. I tried to push him off, but he just tried to deepen the kiss. I tried to scream, but Jake just used that opportunity to slip his tong in my mouth. 

I felt helpless. (And no, not helpless like Eliza) I wanted him to stop, but he kept going. Was this all Jake wanted? To get in my pants? 

"HEY! LEAVE Y/N ALONE, YOU...YOU PERV!" 

I looked up to see no one other than... 

"Jeremy!?" I cried. 

Jeremy pushed Jake off me and lifted him by the collar. "If you ever touch y/n EVER again, I will make sure the whole school knows your a perverted jerk that only uses girls for his own personal pleasure!" 

Jake broke out of his grasp laughed. "And who would believe YOU?" 

Jeremy took out his phone, and showed Jake it was recording. Jake gasped and ran away. 

I looked at Jeremy. His brown hair was a bit messy, and his glasses were crooked on his face. You would have never guessed he was strong for looking that scrawny. He was actually kinda cute. 

He held his hand out to help me up. "H-Hi! I'm Jeremy! I..uh..I'm sorry, I shouldn't have followed you guys out here and-" 

I hugged him. "No, Jeremy, your a hero. Thank you! If it wasn't for you...well..." 

Jeremy softly hugged me back, like he didn't want to break me. He stayed in that position for a few minutes. It was...nice! 

Jeremy broke away from the hug first, his face redder than a tomato. "M-Maybe you can meet my f-friend Michael and his girlfriend, Nichole?" 

"Yeah, I would love too—" 

Wait, WHAT? 

Michael...had a girlfriend? 

I could feel my heart slowly breaking, but I looked back up at Jeremy, who was beaming. Gosh, his smile was cute... 

"GREAT! I..uh..mean, cool, dawg. Wait, what am I saying? Uhhh..." he stuttered. 

I smiled and took his hand. "Lead the way~" I cooed. 

Jeremy smiled, his face burning. "Of course," he said happily. 

This one shot wasn't my best, but I did do a nice plot twist. Jeremy needs more love, y'all. Well, hopefully y'all are having a good day, and I'll see you all on Friday! ❤️🦙❤️