You're Joking...Right?

33

RILEY'S POV
After I woke up, I realized that Donovan was holding me, but my head was killing me, so I went to my bathroom to get meds. When I glanced at myself in the mirror, I noticed that the shirt that I was wearing wasn't mine... Then I saw my hair. I took a quick shower and when I peeked into my room, Donovan was gone, so I quickly got dressed. I put on leggings and the sweatshirt Donovan had given me when we went to the ski lodge, then dried my hair in the bathroom. When I walked out of my bathroom, I screamed since Donovan was sprawled out on my bed.

"Morning." He laughed.

"Don't do that!"

"My bad."

He was shirtless and had wet hair, so I figured that he showered, then we went and found Ethan, who was excited that I was hungover too since he wanted to try some smoothies that supposedly take care of that. Surprisingly, they worked and after we ate, Donovan stood up.

"I'm taking your sister." He said.

"She's all yours." Ethan smirked.

"Well then..." I laughed.

After I grabbed my things, we headed over to Donovan's house (I'm starting to spend a lot of time there) and while we were watching Netflix in his room, I remembered what Ethan said.

"Babe?" I asked.

"Y-Yeah?" He asked with surprise.

"Why do you look so shocked?" I laughed.

"Because you called me 'Babe.' You never call me that." He grinned as he pulled me into him.

"Really?"

He nodded as he smiled, then I pulled him into a kiss.

"Alright, what's wrong?" He chuckled.

"What do you-"

"You kissed me first."

"Because I like you."

That made his dopey grin break out on his face and I felt butterflies in my stomach. Then, I made a decision and took a deep breath.

"I don't mean to be hesitant. It's just... In the past, I haven't been involved with the best guys. Then you and I... You know, and you disappeared after that. I just don't want to get hurt again." I admitted.

"Babe, I'm not gonna disappear. You can't get rid of me." Donovan said as he nuzzled his face into my neck.

"I'm sorry."

"Don't be. And I'm not saying that I'm never gonna hurt you since I'm not perfect, but I will try my best to keep you happy and treat you how you should be treated. I promise."

"I'm holding you to that." I smiled.

"I hope so."

"I promise to try to open up to you and be more affectionate."

"I'd like that."

"Oh really?"

"Yup."

I smiled, then climbed on top of him and kissed him.

"I could get used to this." He smirked.

"I bet." I giggled.

As we made out, he took off his shirt, then I blushed.

"Come on, you've seen me naked before." He said.

"But you haven't seen me."

"Oh yeah, you kept your bra on and would not let me see anymore of you... No matter how much I begged." He smirked.

"Shut up."

"Make me." He coaxed as he bit his lip.

I giggled and kissed him again as he grabbed my ass, then the door flew open.

"Yo, Don- Woah! Holy shit man, my bad!" Quintin laughed.

"Ugh, Quin!" I groaned.

"Fuck, bro!" Donovan groaned as he threw a pillow at him.

"Thanks for the warm welcome." He laughed before running in and jumping on the bed.

I laughed as I rolled off of Donovan and kissed his cheek, then Quintin crawled under the blanket with us, but he took control of Netflix and I poked Donovan since he was covering his face.

"You might wanna hide that." I whispered as I pointed to his boner.

"Shit!"

"Don, I swear if that thing touches me, I'm punching you in the face." Quintin said.

With that, I burst out laughing, then Donovan pulled me on top of him to hide his boner.