A Hopeless Dream (Creepypasta x reader)

I'm not that bad? 😳

I had woken up to something soft being placed on me and what I felt to be a pair of eye's watching me. I gently fluttered my eye's open. I was face to face with a... clock? And a green eye? I reflexively jumped up colliding our heads together. Already in pain I squeaked. "Oh shit, I'm sorry. You just looked like you needed a blanket cause you have no real clothes on." She said rubbing the back of her neck looking away ashamed. I apologized to her and then noticed there was another girl, she was just watching this drinking something.

I furrowwed my brows "Am I in another house or something, who are you two?" I asked quietly thinking to myself. The girl who was drinking something spoke up and looked over at BEN. Huh, guess I am at the house. She said "Why didn't you tell us you guy's brought home a cutie?" She asked smirking going up to me. The girls seemed kind of excited to see a new face. The brunette muttered somthing blushing. I blushed realizing they were so close.

"I'm Jane, it's nice to see such a cute face here." She said sticking her hand out smiling at me. I shook it blushing sort of shy. "And I'm Natalie, but I also go as Clockwork." She said smirking at me winking. W-was she hitting on me? I blushed and waved. "I-I'm Y/N sorry I don't have proper clothing, I passed out." I said truthfully blushing and smiling. "Cute name too!" Jane said. They did look pretty I can't lie. "Is it just me or do you also want to protect that innocent smile too?" She said turning to Natalie. She nodded and they began talking to each other.

I got up slowly out of the couch stretching then grabbing the bag of my clothes. BEN winked at me while I went towards the bathroom and I blushed and flipped him off. I got dressed into just a simple shirt/hoodie/crop top with a skirt/shorts/pants. I made sure to have my pendant and moon hair pin in. Going back downstairs and putting my bag back, Natalie was holding something.

"Here, it's a present from both Jane and I. We were told there was a new person and we wanted to get something so, yeah." She said smiling. She handed me a crimson scarf. It was kinda big but, it was fluffy and warm. I smiled "Thanks, it's really nice!" They had kind of looked at me and smiled at each other. Man, I must have been super adorable in their eye's. I laughed to myself and went to the kitchen bored. I remembered that my ankle was super fucked when I accidentally stood on it. Yelping in pain I held it and fell ontop of someone.

That someone was Helen. Shit, he was scary to me. "S-SORRY!" I shouted blushing. My face was too close to his. "It's fine Y/N, quit yelling." I could see he was blushing a little his mask was accidentally knocked off. His eye's were such a pretty dark blue. I was drawn in. "His eye's are so pretty..." I said aloud. That made his face go to a bright pink. "Th-thanks." He said averting his eye's looking away from me hiding the slight smile he had. I tried to get off of him only to hurt another thing. Jeeeez I'm a klutz.

He left with his mask on and I sat on the floor unable to get up for now. Soon enough Jeff came in looking for a drink. He looked at me confused. "Why are you on the floor?" He asked genuinely confused and interested. "I kind of fell and then I couldn't get up." I told the partial truth, he sighed rolling his eye's. He gently lifted me up and looked at me embarrassed

"I want to say that I'm s-......." he looked around to see if anyone was there. "Sorry, ok. I didn't mean to be so rude last night." He said averting his eye's not looking at me. I smiled, this was definitely not somthing he'd do. "It's okay, I was also acting like an ass too." He smiled " Damn right. Also if you tell anyone what I said I'll end you. Got it?" Jeez way to ruin the moment. I nodded furiously and went to the living room, a lot of people were just there lounging around.

We spent the whole day just watching the T.V. not a very fun thing but oh well. Jane and Clockwork were very invested in me though. I felt special and enjoyed every moment with them. They seemed very pleasant. Clockwork gave off the vibe of cool girl and Jane had a badass vibe to her. I'm glad we were clicking so fast. They were a lot better than most of the people here not gonna lie.

Soon enough it was dinner again. But Masky and Brian let me help cook. Huh, does everyone take turns cooking or what? This time they grilled a lot of meats. They had some red solo cups in hand. It reminded me of my Dad. How he'd teach me how to cook food and grill. I smiled at them thinking of the thought. It was nice and peaceful. They were teaching me some things I hadn't learned. And I surprisingly taught them some things too. After they finished the preparations we started eating.

This time at the dinner table I didn't feel so left out or alone. People were actually including me now and talking to me. I guess the key was to find out their darkest secret. I still felt off about them being killers. How could they be so.... so, not that bad? What is it with them? I know killing people is horrible and disgusting but... why are they somehow decent enough? Maybe I should just stop thinking and save my energy. After all, tonight was supposed to be my " huge test" right? Collect eight pages without being caught. Easy, right?

After dinner and helping clean up, Toby came to me "W-We'll get y-you at t-twelve f-for the ch-*tic* challenge. O-okay?" He asked I nodded "s-sleep in th-the mean t-time." I nodded again curling up on the couch and I noticed this place was deserted by everyone. I was the only one left. Weird but aight. I fell asleep to the only sound, my heart beat.

-_-_-_-_-_-
Oh boy, this was more laid back than the other's. I hope you enjoyed! Peace
Word count: 1113