Peter Pan Imagines

Imagine [10: Request] ⭐

* * * *

Requested By: enametsohg

Type: Fluff

Other: Reader Is Bisexual

* * * *

Boys are idiots. Why am I saying that?

Let me take you back in time slightly. How much back? I couldn't say, it's been too many years since I arrived on this Island.

Oh! My name is F/N L/N, I live on Neverland with my best friend Felix and our Leader, Peter Pan. Yes Pan, the 'fairy-tale' character. He's much different to how he's portrayed in the movies, he's more tough, more adventurous and sometimes, often cruel.

Felix has been my best friend since before our time in Neverland, that's the only reason I'm with them. Felix refused to leave me behind. Where Felix is Pan's righthand man, I am his left hand.

Anyway, on with the story.

Pan had gone out searching for new recruits, as he did every so often, leaving myself and Felix in charge. We were great leaders, him being more quiet, me being loud and always speaking my mind. We were kind of opposites, yet similar.

It was dark when Pan arrived back, with him was only four recruits, one of them a smaller build than the others. There was something strange about the person, I didn't know what it was, so I moved towards them.

Felix tried to stop me, though as I went towards the group, I pulled the person's hood, revealing long hair.

Pan had brought another girl.

Pan had brought the most beautiful girl I had ever seen.

We held eye contact, both our eyes widening as we stared at each other. My heart was beating faster than it had in many decades.

How was one girl so beautiful?

Yes, yes I'm attracted to girls and boys, more so girls, something only Felix knew.

I had to beg Pan to let the girl stay. Okay, so it wasn't so much 'begging', more threatening, then begging. He made me a deal, one I accepted gracefully. It was my job to train the beautiful-

I mean, it was my job to train Ella. Ella, even her name was beautiful.

Many moons had passed. I found myself growing closer and closer to Ella. It was one day while we were searching through the forest, where we shared our first kiss. Ella was a Lesbian, not interested in men, which made sense, she was accepted in her time, though I wouldn't have been if people knew back then.

We started a secret relationship, since we weren't sure how Pan would react.

The night was strange warm as Pan played his pipes for us. Ella and I had been dating for twenty four moons. Yes, we had counted, she was counting, and I was too. I noticed Pan keep glancing at Ella with each note he played.

When he finished, he approached us, standing tall as he always did. "Ella, I have a question or you," he told her. "What is it?" she asked him. I was confused. Why didn't he ask me the question?

"I want you to go out with me."

My eyes widened as I stared between the two. Why would Pan ask out my-?

Oh Right, he doesn't know, does he. It's time to see what he'd say.

Ella looked at me and I nodded my head. "Thank you, but I'll have to recline, you see." She gently took my hand, linking her fingers with mine. "I'm not into boys, I'm actually into girls, this one." She placed a kiss on my hand. "This one in particular."

All of the Lost Boys(minus Felix) and Pan, stood around us asking multiple questions.

Some of them were like 'would you sleep with a man if he was hot?'

Though Pan seemed the most interested. He was curious on how it worked, considering he was a lot older than all of us. He didn't know girls could like other girls that way.

After a long night of answering questions, I made my way back to my tent I shared with Ella. "I have to admit, that went better than expected," I said, causing her to smile. "I'm glad they know the truth."

She placed a kiss on my lips, before I could say, 'Me Too.

* * * *

* * * *