Dust!Sans x Shy!Reader x Horror!Sans Part Two!

801 18 6
                                        

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~This story was requested by CinderStomes YT (Quotev)! Go show them some love!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

(If you chose Dust)

"R-really?" I ask in shock. I have always had a crush on Dust, but if I choose him Horror but be hurt! I don't know what to do... I should follow my heart though. I look over at Dust and then at my shoes, feeling my face heat up. "Dust, I a-actually always have had a crush on you-"

I was suddenly cut off from being tackled to the ground by dust, he tackled me into a bear hug as he smiled. "I knew it! God I was so worried you wouldn't, the truth is I love you Y/N" I smiled back and giggled a small bit but suddenly felt his cold smooth lips go onto mine. Is he kissing me?!

I smile softly and kiss him back, blushing. He lets me go and I look over to see Horror, he looks upset and hurt. He started to walk away sadly, I quickly got up and ran over to him and grabbed his hand.

"Horror? Hey I'm sorry but I still love being with you, you are my best friend." He turned and looked at me with a small smile and hugged me.

"It's alright Y/N. I love being with you and you are my best friend too. Its okay though I'll be fine, go and have some fun and Dust. You both are good for each other" He seemed to be a tad bit sad but happy at the same time. I nodded and smiled at him and went over to Dust and hugged him.

"How about we both go to my room and watch a movie or two?" I nod happily and smile, going up to his room with him and cuddle with him as we watch some movies until we fall asleep.


(If you chose Horror)

"R-really?" I ask in shock. I have always had a crush on Horror, but if I choose him Dust might feel hurt... I don't know what to do... I should follow my heart though. I look over at Horror and then at my shoes, feeling my face heat up. "Horror, I a-actually always have had a crush on you-"

I was suddenly cut off from being tackled to the ground by Horror, he tackled me into a bear hug as he smiled. "I knew it! God I was so worried you wouldn't, the truth is I love you Y/N" I smiled back and giggled a small bit but suddenly felt his cold smooth lips go onto mine. Is he kissing me?!

I smile softly and kiss him back, blushing. He lets me go and I look over to see Dust, he looks upset and hurt. He started to walk away sadly, I quickly got up and ran over to him and grabbed his hand.

"Dust? Hey I'm sorry but I still love being with you, you are my best friend." He turned and looked at me with a small smile and hugged me.

"It's alright Y/N. I love being with you and you are my best friend too. It's okay though I'll be fine, go and have some fun with Horror. You both are good for each other" He seemed to be a tad bit sad but happy at the same time. I nodded and smiled at him and went over to Dust and hugged him.

"How about we both go to my room and watch a movie or two?" I nod happily and smile, going up to his room with him and cuddle with him as we watch some movies until we fall asleep.

(If you chose both)

"R-really?!" I ask in shock. I have always had a crush on both of them, I could never choose one of them and not the other one of them. I look at them both as my face heats up a little. "I can't choose between the both of you. I l-love you both more than anything in the world...."

"Hey don't worry about it too much, you can take all the time you need to decide or not even choose. We will be fine with whatever you choose." Horror said in an attempt to comfort me and make sure I don't feel rushed.... It worked.

"He's right Y/N. We both love you so much but we want you to be happy more than anything so take your time. We will respect whatever you choose." Dust said as I looked up at the both of them and smile softly.

"Alright I think I have decided but I'm not sure if you guys will be okay with it..." They both looked at each other and then back at me and nodded.

"Like we said before we will be okay with whatever and whoever you choose." Horror spoke. I blushed softly and look at my shoes as I fiddled with my hands nervously.

"I love you both- so much. I can't choose but I want to be with the both of you." They both came over to me and hugged me.

"Like we said we both love you and respect whatever you choose, and with this choice we all will be happy." Dust said as Horror nodded, agreeing with him.

"How about we all head up to my room and go watch some movies?" Horror asked. Dust then agreed as I did too. We all went up to Horror's room and cuddled all together as we watched movies happily.

(If you choose neither)

"R-really?" I asked in shock as they both nodded, saying it's true. I thought for a moment, I love them but not that way. They are my best friends. I just don't think I could date them... Will they be okay with this decision though?

"Hey don't worry about it too much, you can take all the time you need to decide or not even choose. We will be fine with whatever you choose." Horror said in an attempt to comfort me and make sure I don't feel rushed.... It worked.

"He's right Y/N. We both love you so much but we want you to be happy more than anything so take your time. We will respect whatever you choose." Dust said as I looked up at both of them and smiled softly.

"Alright I think I have decided but I'm not sure if you guys will be okay with it..." They both looked at each other and then back at me and nodded.

"Like we said before we will be okay with whatever and whoever you choose." Horror spoke. I looked at my shoes as I fiddled with my hands nervously.

"I love you both but only as my best friends, I'm so sorry." I looked up at them both, worried about how they will react. They looked a small bit hurt. "I'm so sorry but I love being your best friend." They came over to me and hugged me.

"Like we said we both love you and respect whatever you choose, if this is how you feel that's perfectly fine." Dust said as Horror nodded, agreeing with him.

I smiled softly and hugged them back. "Thank you so much for understanding. I would hate to make you guys upset"

"Don't worry about it, we only want you to be happy Y/N" Dust said with a small smile.
"How about we go and watch some movies in my room?" Horror asked, Dust and I nodded agreeing before we all went to Horror's room and watched movies together.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Hey people, monsters, and hybrids! I know I have been gone for a long time but finally a chapter is here. This is a part two so go read the first chapter! My Best Friend LunaTheMoonGoddess is also going to be making some chapters for this book and take your requests so if you have any just write them down in the comments and we will get to it so go crazy!

AU sans x reader one-shotsStories to obsess over. Discover now