yanderes x reader [scent of the dead]

[R/D]chapter fifty three: pathological liar

Haven't updated this in a while, have i?

Toby POV~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Running down the tile, my heart races...im excited, i never though i would be to murder a friend, but...in my book, he deserves it, he knew what he did was wrong.

"H-how much longer?? This hurts!"
(Y/n) groans, i guess even with me holding most of their weight, their leg is pretty pained.

"We're almost there, just around this corner..!"
I assure them.

As we turn the corner, i see the rotten body of water, and no Conny..! Or Noah for that fact, hope hes alright.

"Oh no...what if hes gone?!"
(Y/n) mumbles, man, i hope he is.

"Ah, hey guys! I got some motherfuckin' STICKS!"
Conny yells, running over with hands full of sticks and small cups...and along comes Noah.

"Wh...what...?"
I whisper.

"Oh thank god! Wait, Toby said he heard you screaming..!"
(Y/n) says.

"I did, i grabbed a stick and a centipede was on it...it was scary."
Conny says.

"Oh...alright."
I grit my teeth, my eyes going to meet Noah's, he looks guilty...oh god.

"Noah...how about Conny and (y/n) stay here, we can talk over by somewhere else."
I say, Before Noah can agree or disagree, i grab his arm and start walking.

Once we make it far enough from them, i stop, still gripping his arm, but now he cant move.

"So...wanna tell me why the hell he wasnt gone?"
I ask.

"I-i....couldnt.."
Noah mumbles, somehow his speech is making me more mad than his growls at the moment.

"You couldnt?? Dude, he kissed them, and he was gonna do a hell of a lot worse if nobody showed up, who knows what he'll do the next time he finds them alone..!!"
I protest.

"B-but...con..nys n-nice!"
Noah says, trying to back up.

"It could end up just like that store, Noah. Dont you remember how scared we were? (Y/n) was left for Conny to help, and they ended up on the brink of death...what would happen if we trusted Conny again?"
I say, he stops, thinking.

"He...d-didnt...mean to...!"
Noah says, i squeeze his arm tighter.

"Didnt he? He knew what he was doing when he kissed them, when he ran off with them instead of taking them to the group, who knows, maybe he was the one to break their fucking leg in the first place..!"
I say.

"B-but...no..."
Noah whispers.

"We cant trust him, you know that deep down."
I say.

"Hes...g-good..."
Noah says, it sounds like hes trying to reassure himself.

"Hes not, i know it feels like he is, but what is he hiding under all his jokes and grins? Noah, he could be a monster, waiting for us to get comfortable before eradicating us...!"
I say, it may be a bit of an exaggeration...but anything's fair in this life.

Noah doesnt speak, he just nods weakly and walks back to (y/n) and Conny.

"So, how about you?"
Conny asks.

"No, i dont think ive ever seen a hairless possum hiss at an empty ramen cup...although that does sound funny to see."
(Y/n) says.

"Alright, i think its time for us to go back to Oliver and the big guy."
I say, grabbing (y/n)'s arm and pulling them to my side.

"Awe...! I gotta get to that food place still...! Oh well, i guess I'll see you later (y/n)...?"
Conny mumbles.

"Sure thing..!"
(Y/n) says.

We start walking back to the others, and i cant help but feel a little jealousy at Conny, he somehow always gets to be the favorite, maybe...just maybe, i can do something about that..

"Hey, (y/n)...did you hear anything from conny?"
I ask.

"Hm? About what?"
They ask.

"The....Hotel thing, with Sam."
I mumble.

"What?? Why would we talk about that?"
They ask.

"Well, i-i thought you knew...River and i have been talking, and they said you knew.."
I say.

"About what?"
(Y/n) asks.

"...about Conny going missing the night of Sam's disappearance."
I say, their eyes go wide.

"What?! Toby, y-you cant just think that Conny killed one of his friends!"
(Y/n) says.

"Well...i wont make you believe what i say, but...Conny was the only person i think could've done it, he was missing when it happened, and he seemed more..happy, the day after."
I say.

"But...he's always happy..he's always this happy."
They say.

"Yeah, but... You gotta wonder why, He lives in an apocalyptic hell, why does he just smile like its completely fine?? He could be crazy..!"
I say.

"He's just a nice guy, he wouldn't hurt somebody..!"
(Y/n) says.

"(Y/n), open your eyes, somebody has been killing off this entire group! First Jack, then Sam, who's next?? Are you gonna forget how horrible it was when we were told jack was worn apart?!"
I say.

"Dont you fucking speak about Jack!"
They growl.

"Just...think about it, something is happening..."
I pause, turning around and walking off.

"And ignoring it could get us killed."
I say, turning a corner.

They're not getting that this group is going to hurt them...so if i cant convince them to leave them, I'll convince them that one of the group is going to kill them, then i can slowly pick people off...they'll be safe when its just the two of us.