Obey Me! Shall We Date Oneshots

Frustrated

TW: non-graphic Sexual content, cheating
Perspective: third person

MC is a bad person in this one-shot (and is gender neutral)

It was the middle of the night and MC was frustrated. Being with Simeon was like heaven, until it became hell. Simeon, as an angel, isn't allowed to have sex. MC has a very high sex drive... and it was getting to the point where masterbation wasn't enough. While Simeon wasn't allowed to engage in sex, he occasionally would bend the rules. Send scandalous photos, dirty talk over the phone, but it wasn't enough. They needed to feel another person.
Simeon had just lightly scolded them for asking him to send a fully nude photo, saying it was too much and that he'd be breaking the rules. That was the final straw. Feeling more sexually frustrated than they ever had in their entire life, they went to the one person they could think of to help.

They took a breath and knock on the door. A moment later, it opened, and a friendly face welcomed them.
"MC! What's up?" Asmo greeted, wearing nothing but a light pink robe.
"Um... can I come in?" They asked, avoiding eye contact. Asmo frowned.
"Sure..." he stepped aside and let them enter. "Is something wrong?" He asked, closing the door behind them. He saw their back as they lowered their head.
"I can't take this anymore." They said. Asmo walked up and placed a hand on their shoulder.
"What do you mea-" He started, to then be inturrupted by MC turning around and catching his lips in a greedy kiss. Asmo kissed back for a moment, before pulling away.
"Asmo, please. I need to have sex with someone. This is getting to a point where I can't handle it." They begged. Asmo smirked and raised a hand to cup their cheeks.
"And so you came to me, and not your boyfriend?" He said with half a laugh. MC looked down.
"Me and Simeon aren't official, and even if we were it wouldn't matter. Angels aren't allowed to have sex." MC excused. Asmo reached his other hand to cup their other cheek as he locked his gaze into their eyes.
"Oh, that must be so frustrating. Humans are, for the most part, sexual creatures. And being left unsatisfied... I won't mince words here, my dear, what you are doing is cheating. You may not technically be official but it'd break poor Simeon's heart if he found out." Asmo explained. MC frowned, looking in his eyes.
"Is that a no, then?" They asked. Asmo chuckled.
"I never said that. I'm just making sure you know what you're getting into." He kissed MC for a moment, then went back to staring in their eyes. "As the Avatar of Lust I often deal in... unsavory types of love. Affairs and cheating are nothing I'm afraid of. I honestly find it quite thrilling. The taboo and forbiddeness of it, the idea you're doing something wrong makes it feel a lot more dirty..." He moved one hand to slowly trail down their cheek and neck to their chest. "...doesn't it, MC? You know it's wrong, but it feels so right. It feels amazing to give in to those sinful desires. So tell me..." He used his other hand to grab their side. "...what was your dirty little mind hoping to get out of this? Do you want me to be dominant? Do you want me to be submissive? Perhaps you want me to roleplay as him. Or perhaps you want the opposite, for me to take my demon form and fuck you that way. So what is it? I'm up for anything."

After that, the night was a long and erotic blur. There were two things MC could remember clearly, though. The first was how Asmo would keep repeating how fun it was to cheat, how this was their dirty little secret, how great it is to give in to temptation. The second was the pit in their stomach after they orgasmed for the first time that night. They didn't feel guilty... and that made them feel unnerved. MC always thought they were, for the most part, a good person. They helped people when they could, they were kind, they looked for the best in people, but this... it was inexcusable how they didn't feel bad about this. It's a strange thing, feeling bad about not feeling bad.
This wasn't the last time this happened. Far from it.  For the next month nearly every other day they'd have sex, often moving into more kinky territories. They became less careful, less quiet. That lead to their downfall.

It was evening and Simeon had entered the House of Lamentation, hoping to surprise MC. He walked throughout the hallways and passed by Asmodeus' door. Lewd sounds were coming from inside. Simeon sighed. He knew what Asmo's sin was and what that meant for him, but the least he could do would be to soundproof his room a little. Simeon stepped forward to continue to MC's room, when he heard an ever so familiar voice.
"Yes-!" the voice moaned from inside. Simeon shook his head. It couldn't be... right? He knew it was impolite to eavesdrop, but he needed to know. It couldn't be the love of his life, but he needed to clear his doubts. He neared the door and pressed and ear to it.
"Look at you..." Asmo said from behind the muffled door. "You really were made for this, weren't you? You aren't for angels. You're for demons. No angel would be able to fuck you like this. He'd never even dare to imagine it. Only a demon can handle just how lustful you are. Only I can handle it." Asmo said passive aggressively. Simeon felt attacked, but couldn't be sure it was towards him until he heard the other party again.
"Fuck... Asmo... keep going..." They moaned. Simeon still couldn't quite tell, until Asmo said it clear as day.
"You feel so good, MC." He groaned. There it was. 'MC'. Simeon stepped away from the door, holding back tears. There must be some other explanation for this. Maybe Asmo had some demon transform and pretend to be them? Simeon rushed towards MC's room, praying they were inside...

But they weren't. Simeon sadly walked to MC's bed and sat on it, legs nearly giving out. Why? Why would they do this? He wanted to give them the benefit of the doubt, but he just couldn't. He knew what he heard.

Hours later, MC entered the room innocently. They were surprised by Simeon sitting there in silence.
"Simeon! You should have told me you were coming over!" They smile and walk over, no hint on their body that just a few hours ago they were having sex with a demon. Simeon stands up and looks them in the eyes, sternly.
"Don't act nonchalant. I know what you were doing just a little bit earlier." Simeon says. MC raises an eyebrow.
"What I was doing?" They feign ignorance. Simeon sighs and looks down.
"Drop the act." He says degectedly. "You were... together with Asmodeus. Sexually." MC steps back.
"Um... what makes you think that?" They ask, internally panicking. Simeon looks them in the eyes again.
"I came over here a few hours ago. I wanted to surprise you. I walked by Asmo's room and heard you two. It broke my heart." He explains. MC frowns. "I've been sitting here for hours thinking about it. Thinking about why you would do something like this. Thinking about what I could've done to stop you before he got the chance to seduce you. Thinking about what I'll do next." MC lays a hand on his arm.
"I... I'm so sorry. I was frustrated and I needed a release. I went to Asmo, don't think he tricked me or anything. This is my fault." They say. Simeon closes his eyes.
"Was this a one time thing? Please, answer honestly." He asks. MC sighs and sits next to him.
"No, it's happened 14 times now." They answer.
"Is it really because I kept on refusing you? You could have talked to me about it. About how you were getting to the point you were thinking about having sex with someone else." He looks to them with sorrow. MC lays another hand on his arm.
"I thought you'd be mad at me, tell me how sinful a thought like that is." They explain. Simeon looks them in the eyes.
"One thing I overheard from earlier was Asmo saying how I wouldn't dare to imagine having sex with you... But that's far from the truth. I fantasize about you so often. Over and over I've wanted to break the rules for you, but I held myself back. Why couldn't you have just held yourself back too?" He pleads.
"I'm just not as good as you are." They answer. Simeon steps up, shaking off MC's hands on him.
"I always thought you were. Better, even. But now.... I don't think I can forgive you." He walks forward. "Goodbye, MC."
"Wait-!" They rush up and grab his arm once more, but he shakes it off again.
"I love you." He says suddenly, looking away from them. "I love you more than anything. I was even considering losing my status by breaking the rules just to make you happy. We could have been happy..." He turns and looks them in the eyes. "Why did you give that up?" He asks.
"Because..." they sigh. "You deserve better. Asmo was right. I'm not made for angels. I'm a bad person, and I'm not just saying that to make you feel guilty! This was a terrible thing I did and I don't even fully feel bad about it! So..." They close their eyes. "It's okay if you don't forgive me. I wouldn't either."

Without another word, Simeon left the House of Lamentation. MC knocks on Asmo's door once again.
"Back again, are we~?" He flirts as he answers the door. MC looks to the floor sadly. "What's wrong, darling?" He asks. MC walks into the room and hugs him.
"Simeon knows. He wants nothing to do with me now." They whisper. Asmo hugs them tight and closes the door behind them.
"It's okay. I know this hurts, but-" He starts.
"Punish me." They inturrupt, tears starting to well in their eyes. "Please."