I sat on an underground train to get into central New York when I saw the most beautiful girl in the world. I recognised her immediately only to be THE Sarah Catharine Paulson.
I just couldn't believe my eyes. My life is brilliant, I thought to myself as I saw her talking to the person next to her. She looked gorgeous as the lights of the train illuminated her face.
I saw an angel, of that I'm sure.
She smiled at me on the subway, but she was with another woman. I knew she was already in love with Holland, I am happy for them of course. But that won't stop me from thinking she is the most beautiful woman on earth.
'You're beautiful', I mouthed to her. She pointed at herself, "me?" she asked and I nodded. 'You're beautiful, it's true' I mouthed again, making her blush.
I saw her face, in a crowded place. And I don't know what to do. 'I'll never be with you' I thought.
She then motioned for me to sit next to her. I didn't hesitate to do so.
"You caught my eye" she smiled. But her face dropped as she took a closer look. She could see from my face that I was fucking high. "I don't think that I'll see you again" I sighed. She placed her hand on my knee. "Says who?" she smiled.
I shrugged, blushing. "You're beautiful" she whispered. My eyes widened, "me?" I asked and she nodded, just as I had done earlier. "You're beautiful, it's true. I saw your face in a crowded place. And I don't know what to do... cause I'll never be with you" she sighed, looking at Holland who was falling asleep next to her.
"But Sarah, Holla-" I started. "Shh, it's okay. I love Holland but" she stopped suddenly, looking down at her hands. "I just met you yet I feel drawn to you" she whispered.
"I get that Sarah. You don't know me though... you probably never will" I sighed, making her look at me with sad eyes.
I looked at her one last time before saying to her... "but it's time to face the truth... I'll never be with you" I smiled, getting up and walking off the train. Leaving her behind.
YOU ARE READING
Sarah Paulson one-shots: You & Her
FanfictionA series of one-shots with Sarah Paulson and her characters Rankings :) #2 in supreme (28/8/22) #1 in Lana winters (19/8/22) #3 in Billie dean Howard (6/5/22) #2 in Bette and dot (22/8/22) #16 in cordelia Goode (15/4/22) #66 in American horror story...