What ifs? - Two Peas in One Pod (Meggy x Male Reader) edition

What if Meggy and Y/N were both Yanderes?

Requested by the amazing @StoryTeller_Tari

Y/N and Meggy were always crazy for each other, but they never knew that the other one was as crazy as they were, but besides that, it was a normal day, SMG4 normal..

Mario: Mario loves this spaghetti!

SMG4: We get it Mario, you love the spaghetti! Shut up!

Mario: You're just jealous you don't have anything to love on!

SMG4: That's really harsh, coming from you.

Mario: Maybe you shouldn't be an asshole!

SMG4: Maybe you shouldn't be a dumbass!

Y/N: Guys, that's enough.

Mario: Shut up!

You immediately grab Mario and pick him up.

Y/N: I'm sorry?

Mario: Uhhhh..nothing.

You throw Mario outside.

Meggy: Hey Y/N..

Y/N: Oh, hello Meggy..

They both sounded off and wondered what was wrong with each other.

Meggy: Are you alright?

Y/N: I'm doing just fine, are you alright?

Meggy: I- Uh..yeah..

Beta: Okay this is getting freaky.

Meggy and Y/N: Shut up Beta.

Beta: Oh...well damn..

He left the castle, feeling bitter towards the two.

Beta: What's with them? They never acted like this before.

He thinks for a moment and realizes why they act strange towards each other, and almost aggressive. As he learned in the past that they both stare aggressively at each other from time to time.

Beta: Fuck, they're both Yandere's, and I wish I didn't have to say that..

-Day One-

Ever since Beta found out that they're both Yandere's he had to keep it to himself for now without drawing suspicions. Today he decided to hang out with Tari, as he feels comfortable with her.

Tari: Hey Beta, did you want to play some games?

Beta: Uh- Yeah, sure, let's play a game.

Tari: Yay! What game should we play?

Beta: Uh, how about Mortal Kombat X?

Tari: Ooh, sounds good!

They both play and they decided to tag team against Shao Kahn.

Beta: Let's beat this bastard back to hell.

Tari: With pleasure.

They both fight the emperor, it was a tough battle, a bloody and a hammer swinging battle..the violence reminded him of what Y/N and Meggy might do if they find out he knows..

His thoughts are interrupted by a fatality on Shao Kahn.

Tari: Yay! We got him!

Beta: Y-yeah! Yay!

Tari: Hmm? Are you okay?

Beta: Yes.

Tari: Hey..

She drags Beta somewhere more private to chat with him.

Tari: What's wrong? You've never acted like this before, and I want to help.

Beta thinks about it, he trusts Tari the most, so he explains.

Beta: They're both Yandere's...I can sense it..

Tari: What? You're joking right?..this isn't another prank?

Beta: No Tari, I'm dead serious, they have been acting almost strange and aggressive towards each other lately, haven't you noticed them?

Tari thinks about yesterday and she did see that they did like watching each other.

Tari: I did notice, but what if it's just them in love?

Beta: No no, that is not love..I know that because I may or may not have played Yandere Simulator and have seen them act exactly like how the main protagonist acts.

Tari didn't question on why he played that game, she believes him, she did notice that Beta's never been this serious before.

Tari: Okay, I believe you, what should we do about it?

Beta: I don't wanna draw suspicious activity, so I say we lay low for now.

Tari nods in agreement and they both head back to play another game, only to find Y/N and Meggy beating up Mario.

Beta: What's going on here?

Y/N: This fat shit decided to throw ravioli at Meggy..

Meggy: Glad we got him.

Tari: Is he ok?

Y/N felt his pulse.

Y/N: He's alive, for now.

Beta: Uh..good.

Tari: Okay, good to know.

Meggy: We could use some help, training today, right Y/N?

Y/N: Right, can you two help us out?

Beta seemed skeptical..they both needed help?

Tari was a bit sketchy about this.

Beta: Uh, we'd love to, but we were busy gaming.

Meggy: You can play your games later, we really need help.

Y/N: We don't wanna fail the splatfest.

Tari looks at Beta, waiting for an answer.

Beta: We're sorry, but we're busy.

Meggy: We're not taking no for an answer.

Beta: What?..

Y/N: We both know you know our little secret..

Meggy and Y/N kiss, shocking them both.

Tari: You Botha started dating?

Meggy: You both know our secret, you're coming with us..

Tari: No!

Beta: Hell no! You can fuck off!

Y/N: That's just too bad Beta.

Meggy: Come on Tari, don't make this difficult.

Beta: How about this?

Beta got his scythe and slashed at Y/N's stomach, crippling him.

Meggy: Y/N! NOOOOO!

She went to go mourn him and stop the bleeding.

Meggy: You- y-you..

Before she could finish, Beta swiftly kicked Meggy in the head, knocking her out. Tari was traumatized.

Beta: Are you okay?..

Tari shook her head and hugged Beta.

Tari: You we're right..they're both psychopaths.

Beta: Yeah..

Tari: What should we do with them?

Beta: I'll call up an old friend, they'll take care of them.

———

From then on, Y/N and Meggy's terror ended up in The Complex, locked up behind cell doors, Beta and Tari felt safe from them. Will they ever escape?