This is just my headcanon
Mike
-Geronimo
-Daddy Issues
Dustin
-Girls like Girls (I literally believe he would listen to lesbian and bisexual girl songs unironically)
-The Pi Song (he unintentionally memorized it and now it's one of his favorites)
Lucas
-Be kind to yourself (Andrew Peterson is a vibe 😎)
-Can't Help Falling in Love-TOP version
Will
-You are my sunshine-Kira Grannis version
-Soldier Poet King
Johnathan
-Photograh-Ed Sheeran
-Washing Machine Heart
Steve
-Literally any Bruno Mars song
Nancy
-I Kissed a Girl
-SOS-Joseph
Robin
-Girls
-Paper Rings
Eleven
-You Belong With Me
-Drive all Night
Max
-Cool for the Summer
-You Stupid Bitch
Billy
-Everywhere I Go
-Riot
Eddie
-Any Metallica song
