Stardew Valley Boyfriend Scenarios

Witches Am I Right? Pt. 2

Requested by 99its_me99

The witch decided she hadn't had enough fun playing with yours and your husband's lives. So she cast another spell on you, and your boys had to leave before you woke the next morning. What will happen now?

🍕Sam🍕
Sam stretched out his arms as he walked back to the farm. His dad needed his help with something early in the morning, so he had to leave even before you were up. Now all he wanted to do was kiss you good morning and crawl back into bed for a few hours.

He opened the gate towards your farm and walked in, smiling at the sight of you picking some of your crops. "Morning sweet cheeks!" He called out as he came closer to you. But when you stood and looked at him, your eyes were full of surprise and fear. "Um hello? Can I help you?" Sam's face fell, but he picked the smile right back up. "Oh ha ha ____. I know you don't love the nickname, but humor me a little?" He moved to pull you into a tight hug, but you backed away quickly. "Vivi!" You called out, hoping the dog would protect from this weird guy.

"H-honey this isn't funny..." Sam's face paled. You shook your head, "I'm sorry, I don't know you.." He couldn't look you in the eyes, all he saw was fear. This was the exact nightmare he had had before. "Do you uh, know a Shane?" You still had a puzzled look on your face. "Uh no not yet? Does he live in town? I haven't had a chance to go yet?"  Now Sam was confused. "What? What do you mean? You've been to town thousands of times? You've lived here for...4 years now..." (A/N: I have no idea how long in story its been and too lazy to try and count, just bear with me)

Vivi finally found you two and ran up to Sam happily. Jumping on him and demanding his attention. You looked at the scene confused. Suddenly a light bulb went off in Sam's head. "What do you remember?" You thought about it, "The farm and Vivi. That's about it." "Ok..thus is bad. Let's see if we can jog that memory." He motioned for you to follow and you reluctantly did so with Vivi at your side and your farming tools in hand, just in case.

Inside, Sam tried showing you pictures of the two of you together and even on your wedding day. You shook as you stared at the pictures. You were married.  You were planning a family. And you didn't remember any of it. "S-Sam what's going on?" You asked, voice quaking. Sam's heart broke at the sound. "Don't worry ___, I know someone who might ne able to help.." With that, Sam out towards the wizard's tower.

Sam returned later that day, stating that the memory loss isn't permanent and should return in the morning. Until then, Sam stayed and helped out as best as he could on the farm, and keeping you calm.

🏈Alex🏈
Alex left early in the morning to get a head start on his exercises so he could make you breakfast in bed. You were still sleeping away before your alarm went off, giving him the time to put together a complete breakfast.

The smell of food roused you from your sleep, but that wasn't right. You lived on the farm alone. Why would you be smelling food? Maybe your dad was coming to visit. With that excitement, you jumped out of bed and quickly made your way toward the kitchen, but froze when you saw someone unfamiliar in your home.

Alex noticed your presence and smiled, "Morning babe! Breakfast is ready!" There was a beat of silence, then you screamed. "Who are you!? What are you doing in my house!?" You grabbed the closest blunt object, which happened to be a lamp, and held it out defensively. Alex looked confused, "What? What are you doing babe? You're gonna hurt yourself." He walked toward you, making you stumble back. "St-stay away from me!" Panic and fear took over your body, and Alex looked hurt. "___...calm down and listen..please..." "How do you know my name!?"

You two backed into your room, and you fumbled for the phone, dialing Leah's number. "___, if you'll just listen.." He was closer now, just an arm's length away. "Hello?" Leah's voice came from the phone. "Get away from me!" You screamed again, swiping the lamp badly, totally missing Alex. "What!? ___ what's going on!? Where's Alex!?" You both heard Leah's voice. "Leah! Something's wrong!" Alex yelled. Panic now overtaking him as well. "I'm on my way!" Leah hung up.