I have no clue if they are in character but this is just for silly fun so don't take anything too serious.
Superman:
His arms will be crossed, nodding his head at all your words so you know he's paying attention and simply not speaking as he is taking it in. If there is something he thinks could be planned better he will say so as this is no time to worry about hurting anyone's ego or skill. He admires you a lot during this as this shows you put serious thought into this, are determined, and just being a wonderful person. He loves to see that, especially in his partner.
Batman:
He's listening, trying not to do his own thing. Sometimes he'll zone out as he has his own way of doing things but then snaps back to attention when he feels your eyes burning into his, angry he's not listening. He'll assure he's listening, even though he wasn't, but you know the truth so he just mumbles a 'continue' so you do. He hates when the plan gets executed and it's perfect. Not because it went well or you did amazing organizing it all but just because he's stubborn and doesn't like to admit a plan is better than his own. But he can give credit so he'll give it in a mumbled quick way.
Wonder Woman:
She'll listen closely, amazed by how you organized this all. If it's not a good plan she'll say it bluntly. No use in hiding it as this is a needed skill if you wish to be a good hero who succeeds in their fights. If it's a good plan she quietly listens, nodding and humming. Once it's over she thanks you for doing this, gives you a kiss then leaves to get ready for where she plays in on the plan.
J'onn J'onzz:
He usually informs the others of the plans and comes up with them so both go through it together before spreading it to the rest. Both will spend quite a bit over everything, even the smallest details as even the tiniest thing can change everything. It's mentally exhausting work so he makes sure to tell you to drink water, take a break for a snack, and just makes sure to take a break after a long period; more for you than him. He doesn't care much for his own being, mostly for you. So when you show the same worries for him it touches him.
Flash:
At this point you know someone else has to tell him all you said because he is NOT listening, even when he tries. He tries at first, he gets all the words and understands but then slowly he notices things. How pretty your hands are as they trace on the map, how gorgeous your eyes are as your eyes flicker between the information and him, how perfect your lips are as it moves. Oh wait... your mouth is forming words... 'Flash!' Damnnit.
He tries to play it off but then remembers this is important so he goes back to being serious, a firm 'sorry' then focuses for real as this is serious and he can kiss those perfect lips any other times.
Hawkgirl:
She will have a frown on her face. Sometimes you think she's not listening or angry but this is her concentration face. When you ask if she's understanding it she raises her eyebrow, almost taking it personal that you think she wouldn't but assures she understands. What she does take personal is when you don't put her in your plan; aggressively asking you why you aren't putting her in or if you think she can't handle it.
Green Lantern:
He'll listen, arms crossed and looking disapproving so when you ask what's wrong with it he is confused but then assures nothing. So you'll point out his look, which confuses him greatly. To him he has a normal face on so you discard it and continue telling. If he does not approve you'll know as he'll say so. Once it's over he puts a hand on your back, giving your cheek a kiss, and telling you you did a good job.
YOU ARE READING
Justice League x Hero! Reader Scenarios
Short StoryThis is based off the animated series (2001)! Includes only founding members. Reader is whatever gender, age (but obviously not underage), height, etc you want them to be. I write these when bored, stuck with writer's block, etc so this will not be...