Pie

140 11 0
                                    

Telly and Maisie were twins. But one day Maisie went missing, Telly searched the whole neighbourhood for her. At one particular house lived an old lady that they were scared of. But since she was desperate to find Maisie, she knocked on the door. The old lady answered the door, without answering Telly's question, she invited her in her house for some pie. Because Telly was pretty hungry, she said yes. The pie was exceptionally good, she thanked the old lady and asked her if she knew where her sister is. The old lady smirked and said "She's in you".
Telly's eyes widened and whispered "no, no she isn't"
The old lady told her she wasn't lying, then told her that she gave her food and answered her question, for payment, she would have to make her into her next pie.
She went to the cabinet, took out a butcher knife and started chopping her into mincemeat.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hey readers, sorry if this chapter didn't make sense, I'll try to improve the other stories so they'll make sense.
And I'm also kinda running out of ideas, so please help me out!

Horror stories, urban legends, e.t.cWhere stories live. Discover now